Oil Just Fell to $93. A 72-Year-Old Widow Who Heats With Oil Is Still Paying $6 a Gallon. Here’s What the Slide Is Worth to Her This Winter

Oil fell to about $93 a barrel on Monday, and for a 72-year-old widow in Connecticut who heats her house with oil and fills one car, the fall in crude since early October is worth about $700 a year at the pump and in the tank. About $170 of it has reached her so far. The rest arrives over the coming weeks, if it arrives at all.

Brent crude, the world benchmark, settled at $92.57 on Monday, 5.8% below Friday’s $98.32 settlement, and West Texas Intermediate settled at $86.85. Brent had already lost 16% last week, its steepest weekly fall since the start of the Covid pandemic. The cause is a proposal carried to the White House by Qatar’s prime minister: Iran would reopen the Strait of Hormuz and stop attacking tankers, and in return the United States would lift its blockade and release $8 billion of Iranian funds frozen in Qatar. President Trump told CNN on Sunday that new strikes were "highly unlikely" if the talks progressed; neither government has confirmed the terms.

Monday’s drop reads as relief on the way for anyone who heats with oil or fills a car: crude is the largest single cost in both fuels, and the $43 a barrel that Brent has lost since its Oct. 2 high of $135.51 in the EIA’s daily price series works out to about $1.02 a gallon of raw cost. The limit is that retail prices follow crude down slowly, heating oil more slowly than gasoline, and a cold snap or a collapse of the talks would send both back up before you see much of it. If you heat with oil, here is what the numbers look like for one household much like yours.

The retiree

She is 72, widowed two years ago, and runs the money her husband used to run. She has lived in the same Connecticut house for 34 years; it has an oil furnace and a standard 275-gallon tank. She has about $1.6 million: $1.1 million in the IRA that was his and is now hers, $400,000 in a brokerage account and $100,000 in cash. One Social Security check arrives each month, $2,350, or $28,200 a year, and she draws 4% from the IRA and brokerage account, $60,000, for a yearly income of $88,200.

She drives about 7,500 miles a year, close to the federal highway agency’s long-used average for drivers 65 and older, in a car that gets 25 miles to the gallon: 300 gallons of gasoline a year, 25 a month. For heat, the Energy Information Administration’s winter outlook puts the average oil-heated home at 402 gallons between November and March; if your tank and mileage are bigger, scale the figures up.

What the pump has already done

Gasoline moved first, and you have already seen it. The national average for regular was $4.01 a gallon on Monday, according to AAA, down from $4.37 a month ago and up from $3.07 a year ago.

On her 300 gallons, today’s price means $1,203 a year, against $1,312 at last month’s price and $921 at last year’s. The past month’s drop of 36 cents saves her $109 a year, about $9 a month. She is still paying $282 a year more for gasoline than a year ago, and so are you if you drive as much.

What Monday’s drop is worth at the pump

A barrel holds 42 gallons, so each $1 a barrel is about 2.4 cents a gallon of crude cost, a rule you can apply to any day’s move. Monday’s $5.75 drop in Brent is about 14 cents a gallon, or $41 a year on her driving if all of it reached the pump. The EIA’s rule of thumb is that about half of a change in crude reaches retail gasoline within two weeks, so by Thanksgiving Monday’s move is worth about 7 cents a gallon to her, about $1 a month.

The bigger figure is the whole slide since Oct. 2: $1.02 a gallon of crude cost, which on her driving is $307 a year, or $26 a month, if every cent passed through. About 36 cents already has. The rest rarely follows in full: the Dallas Fed found that only about 55% of a crude move reaches the pump in the long run, and decreases travel slower than increases.

The bigger number is in her oil tank

Heating oil has barely moved, and she is still paying about $6 a gallon. The EIA’s residential survey for Nov. 2 put the U.S. average at $6.14 a gallon and Connecticut at $5.99, excluding taxes; Connecticut exempts residential heating fuel from sales tax, so that is about what she pays. A year ago Connecticut was $3.57, so the price is up 68%, and it came off its late-October high by only 9 cents nationally and 15 cents in Connecticut while crude fell more than $40 a barrel.

A fill of her tank, about 240 gallons, costs $1,438 at today’s Connecticut price; if you have the same tank, you know the number. The same fill cost $857 a year ago, so each delivery is $581 dearer. Over the EIA’s 402 gallons, her winter costs $2,408 at today’s price, against $1,436 at last year’s, a difference of $972.

The crude slide since Oct. 2 is worth about $1.02 a gallon here too, or $411 over the winter if her dealer’s price followed crude all the way down. Monday’s drop alone is worth $55 to her, and to you if you burn about as much. So far the latest week’s 15 cent decline has delivered about $62 of it. Dealers bought the oil in their tanks at higher prices, and the EIA expects distillate stocks to run about 11% below their five-year average this quarter, which keeps their margins firm.

The EIA’s October outlook already assumed prices would ease: its forecast average for the winter is $5.26 a gallon, $2,115 for the season and 21% more than last winter’s roughly $1,748. That average is $0.73 a gallon below last week’s Connecticut price, a gap worth $294 over the winter. Monday’s crude price makes the forecast more likely to hold. It does nothing for the oil already in your tank.

What to do with the tank

If you heat with oil, do not lock in a fixed price now. Connecticut law bars dealers from selling new prepaid guaranteed-price plans between Nov. 1 and March 31, so the pre-buy season is closed in any case, and locking $5.99 ahead of a forecast decline is a bet against the forecast. A capped-price plan is the middle path: the dealer sets a ceiling and you pay the lower market price if prices fall. The premium typically runs 10 to 30 cents a gallon, or $40 to $121 over 402 gallons, cheap insurance against the talks failing in January. If you are on will-call delivery, skip topping off a half-full tank this week at $5.99; order when the gauge nears a quarter so each delivery catches a lower price, and never let it run below that mark.

Where the money sits

You can run the same arithmetic on your own house. At today’s prices her heating oil and gasoline come to $3,611 a year, about 4.1% of her $88,200 income. At last year’s prices the same fuel cost $2,357, so energy is taking $1,254 more from her this year, more than half a month of her Social Security check. That is the widow’s arithmetic: the house costs what it cost when two checks came in, and now there is one. Her $100,000 in cash pays the oil bill, so a bad week in the stock market never forces her to sell shares to pay the dealer. If your fuel money comes out of a brokerage account, a year of heating and driving costs in cash is the fix.

The bottom line

Oil at $93 is worth about $700 a year to her, $307 at the pump and $411 in the oil tank, if the whole fall since Oct. 2 reached retail prices. About $170, roughly a quarter, has arrived, nearly all of it at the pump. Half of Monday’s own move should reach the gas station within two weeks, worth about $1 a month to her. The heating oil relief comes later, one delivery at a time, and depends on the Hormuz talks holding. If you heat with oil, a capped plan for $40 to $121 keeps the downside open and puts a ceiling on the rest of your winter.

Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.