The RMD Tax Trap That Turns $260,000 in 401(k) Deferrals Into a $700,000 Problem

Published May 15, 2026, 7:15am ET · 5 min read

This post may contain links from our sponsors and affiliates, and Flywheel Publishing may receive compensation for actions taken through them.

Two men in business attire sit at a dark table in an office with large windows. The man on the right, with gray hair, glasses, and a beige jacket, is speaking and gesturing with his hands while holding papers. The man on the left, with dark curly hair and a beard, is wearing a dark blue suit and listening intently, seen from the shoulder up in profile.
Financial advisors are increasingly challenging high earners to re-evaluate their long-term savings plans, especially concerning 401(k) contributions as retirement nears. © Tempura / Getty Images

A 56-year-old dual-income couple earns $480,000 in combined W-2 wages, holds $2.6 million in traditional 401(k)s, and plans to retire at 60. They walk into a fee-only advisor’s office expecting praise for maxing both plans. They walk out with a recommendation to stop. The pre-tax deferrals that built the balance have become the thing working against them.

The logic seems airtight at first. Each spouse contributes $32,500 in 2026, which is the $24,500 base deferral plus the $8,000 catch-up available at age 50 and older. Over four more years, that adds up to $260,000 in new deferrals. Assuming a 32% federal bracket plus state taxes, the upfront savings is roughly 38% of each dollar. The harder question is what happens to those dollars between now and the first required distribution.

The Roth catch-up rule changes the math. Under SECURE 2.0, workers 50 and older whose prior-year FICA wages from the plan sponsor exceeded $150,000 must make catch-up contributions on a Roth, after-tax basis starting in 2026. Each spouse earns $240,000, so both clear that line. Only the $24,500 base deferral can go in pre-tax, which shrinks the upfront tax break well below the headline figure.

The Deferred Dollar Compounds Into a Bigger Tax Bill

A dollar deferred at 56 would sit in the account for about 19 years before required minimum distributions begin at age 75. The article’s earlier figure of 73 applies only to people born from 1951 through 1959. At a 6% annual return, $1 deferred today grows to roughly $3 of fully taxable RMD income. On that assumption, $260,000 in new deferrals grows to more than $700,000 of ordinary-income withdrawals spread across the RMD years.

The tax bracket on the way out is where the plan breaks down. A retired couple living on Social Security, pensions, and RMDs from a balance that has compounded for two decades rarely lands in a 12% bracket. Federal tax on those withdrawals typically runs 22% to 24%, plus state tax. Up to 85% of Social Security benefits become taxable once provisional income clears the threshold, and IRMAA Medicare surcharges rise with income. Stacked together, the effective marginal rate on the last RMD dollar can approach 40%.

At that level, the gap between today’s deduction and a 35% to 40% all-in rate in retirement is, at best, a wash. In a less favorable case, it reverses.

Why Brokerage Beats the Marginal 401(k) Dollar

Once the employer match is captured, the next dollar has a stronger case in a taxable brokerage account. The reason is a set of tax-code features that a traditional 401(k) cannot offer:

  1. Liquidity before 59.5. Retiring at 60 still means a gap year for one spouse if either is younger. Brokerage assets carry no penalty, no Rule of 55 workarounds, and no 72(t) lockup.
  2. Step-up in basis at death. Appreciated brokerage shares passed to heirs reset cost basis. Traditional 401(k) dollars pass to beneficiaries as ordinary income inside a 10-year distribution window.
  3. Long-term capital gains rates. Most growth in a brokerage account is taxed at 15% or 20%, compared with the 22% to 24% ordinary rates that apply to RMD income.
  4. Direct indexing. Harvested losses offset gains elsewhere and can shelter up to $3,000 of ordinary income annually.
  5. Qualified charitable contributions of appreciated shares. No capital gain is recognized, and the donor claims a full fair-market-value deduction.

Rising Yields and a Fed That Is Tightening Again

Market conditions have shifted against the pre-tax plan since this analysis first ran. The 10-year Treasury yield was 5.10% on November 12, 2026, up from 4.08% a year earlier. It closed at 5.15% on November 13, according to recent market data. The yield’s 52-week high was 5.31% on October 5.

The Federal Reserve moved in the same direction. On September 16, 2026, it raised its target range by a quarter point to 3.75% to 4%, its first increase since 2023. Chair Kevin Warsh described the move as removing “a dose of accommodation.” Fed projections show most officials see at least one more rate hike this year.

Higher long-term yields combined with a renewed tightening cycle weaken a core assumption behind many “always max your pre-tax plan” rules of thumb. Those rules assume tax-deferred returns will outpace the tax cost of future RMDs. That assumption is harder to defend when the cost of money is rising.

The Playbook From Age 56 to 60

  1. Contribute only to the match. Capture the employer dollars, then redirect the rest. For this couple, the $49,000 in combined base deferrals would instead go to cash flow for a brokerage account using direct indexing.
  2. Max the HSA if HDHP-eligible. The 2026 family HSA limit is $8,750, set by IRS Revenue Procedure 2025-19. Because both spouses are 56 and not yet on Medicare, each can add a $1,000 catch-up for ages 55 and older into their own HSA. That lifts the household ceiling to $10,750. After age 65, the account can be used for non-medical withdrawals, subject to ordinary income tax.
  3. Map a Roth conversion corridor for ages 60 to 72. If they retire at 60, the window before RMDs begin at 75 is about 15 years, which makes it the most favorable tax period this couple will likely see. Converting $150,000 to $200,000 a year inside the 24% bracket can meaningfully shrink the future RMD base before the IRMAA two-year lookback kicks in at age 63.

The catch-up math also changes at 60. Under SECURE 2.0, workers who turn 60 through 63 can contribute a larger catch-up of $11,250 in 2026, up from the standard $8,000. That higher ceiling only helps a couple who keeps deferring pre-tax, which is the very habit this plan argues against.

The visible deduction on this year’s tax return feels like a clear win. The RMD bill it seeds stays hidden until withdrawals begin. Capture the employer match, stop there, and direct every additional dollar toward accounts the tax code treats kindly at the back end.

Editor’s note: This update replaces the Treasury yield and Fed figures with November 2026 data, including the September 16 quarter-point hike to 3.75% to 4%, and confirms the 2026 401(k), Roth catch-up, and HSA limits. It also corrects the RMD start age to 75 for those born in 1960 or later and removes unverified deficit and FOMC-minutes claims.

Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.

Austin Smith

Austin Smith is a financial publisher with over two decades of experience as an investor, analyst, and advisor. He covers stocks, ETFs, Artificial intelligence and personal finance for 24/7 Wall St. Previously, he spent over a decade at The Motley Fool as a senior editor for Fool.com, portfolio advisor for Millionacres, and launched The Ascent to help reader take control of their personal finances.

His work has been featured on Fool.com, NPR, CNBC, USA Today, Yahoo Finance, MSN, AOL, Marketwatch, and many other publications. He is as an advisor to private companies, and co-hosts The AI Investor Podcast with Eric Bleeker. 

When not looking for investment opportunities, he can be found skiing, running, or playing soccer with his children. Learn more about Austin's investment approach here.

All articles →