A $1.6 Million Portfolio That Quietly Pays a Couple $9,000 a Month and Stays Below the IRMAA Tier 1 Threshold

A 64-year-old couple with a $1.6 million taxable investment portfolio faces a very specific retirement-income challenge: generating $9,000 per month, or $108,000 annually, while keeping modified adjusted gross income under the 2026 IRMAA Tier 1 threshold of $218,000 for married couples filing jointly. Exceeding that threshold triggers Medicare Part B and Part D surcharges for both spouses, increasing healthcare costs for the year. To produce the desired income, the portfolio must generate a blended distribution rate of approximately 6.8%, calculated by dividing the $108,000 income target by the $1.6 million portfolio value.

That target yield is significantly higher than what investors can earn from lower-risk alternatives. With the 10-year Treasury yielding around 4.5%, the couple is seeking roughly 230 basis points of additional income above the risk-free rate. Achieving that level of cash flow is possible, but it generally requires a portfolio that combines multiple income-producing asset classes. In practice, that often means pairing a tax-efficient core allocation with higher-yield investments and a real estate component to reach the necessary distribution rate while balancing income needs, tax considerations, and long-term portfolio stability.

The Four-Sleeve Allocation

The portfolio splits into four sleeves, each chosen for a specific job.

1. 40% JPMorgan Equity Premium Income ETF (NYSEARCA:JEPI), roughly $640,000. The covered-call sleeve is the income engine, throwing off a distribution rate near 7.5% to 9% depending on volatility. The fund’s 0.35% expense ratio is reasonable for an actively managed options overlay. The tradeoff is well known: upside is capped during sharp rallies, and distributions float with implied volatility.
2. 25% iShares Preferred and Income Securities ETF (NASDAQ:PFF), roughly $400,000. Preferreds typically yield around 6.5%, and the fund is concentrated in bank and insurance issuers, with positions in JPMorgan Chase, Morgan Stanley, Bank of America, MetLife, and Allstate. Price action is bond-like, which means rate moves matter more than equity beta.
3. 20% iShares National Muni Bond ETF (NYSEARCA:MUB), roughly $320,000. This is the MAGI shield. Muni interest is exempt from federal income tax and does not count toward ordinary MAGI, so a yield near 3.7% arrives without pushing the couple toward the IRMAA cliff.
4. 15% Realty Income (NYSE:O | O Price Prediction), roughly $240,000. The Monthly Dividend Company pays a 5.3% yield at a recent price near $61, with 670 consecutive monthly payouts and a May 2026 distribution of $0.2705 per share. The triple-net REIT sleeve adds property exposure that JEPI and PFF do not provide.

Blended yield: roughly 6.8%. On $1.6 million that is $108,640 a year, or roughly $9,053 a month. The headline holds.

Why This Stays Under the IRMAA Line

The MAGI arithmetic is where the design earns its keep. The muni sleeve contributes roughly $11,800 in tax-exempt interest. Strip that out, and ordinary distributions from JEPI, PFF, and Realty Income land near $84,000. Add a typical Social Security benefit for a 64-year-old couple later claiming, and total MAGI sits comfortably below the $218,000 Tier 1 threshold. Cushion matters because qualified dividend treatment varies sleeve by sleeve and JEPI’s return-of-capital portion can shift year to year.

The Tradeoff Most Income Investors Underweight

Reaching 6.79% on a buy-and-hold portfolio means accepting that the principal will not grow the way a 3.5% dividend-growth basket would. A pure SCHD allocation (NYSEARCA:SCHD) yielding around 3.6% on $71.6 billion in assets at a 0.06% expense ratio would generate about $57,600 on the same $1.6 million. That falls short of the income target now, but its distributions historically grow 7% to 9% per year. The roughly 6.8% portfolio prioritizes today’s check; the 3.6% portfolio prioritizes the check ten years from now. A 64-year-old couple bridging to Social Security at 70 is buying time, which is what makes the high-yield blend defensible here.

Three Actions Before You Build This

1. Locate the covered-call and preferred sleeves inside an IRA when possible. JEPI and PFF distributions are largely ordinary income, and sheltering them lowers MAGI directly.
2. Model the two-year IRMAA lookback. Premiums in 2026 are set off 2024 returns, so any Roth conversion or capital gain harvest done this year flows through to 2028 premiums.
3. Stress-test the JEPI distribution at a 6% yield, not 9%. Covered-call payouts fall when volatility collapses. If the sleeve under-delivers, the couple needs a plan to either trim spending or add a small high-yield bond fund rather than chase yield deeper into mortgage REITs.

Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.