High Earning Retirees Are Being Warned About This $9,240 Medicare Surcharge That Hits Two Years After a Big Income Event
This post may contain links from our sponsors and affiliates, and Flywheel Publishing may receive compensation for actions taken through them.
On the September 15, 2022 episode of Ask Suze & KT Anything, Suze Orman described a deduction that many retirees do not expect until it appears in their own bank account. She was discussing her wife KT’s Social Security deposit, and her example is a useful warning for every high earner approaching 65.
Here is what Suze said: “That’s why I was just showing KT the other day that she got a Social Security check, right, put into her account and they had to subtract 560, I think almost $600 for her Medicare B part of it. So the more money you make, the more you have to pay.”
The deduction she described is IRMAA, the Income-Related Monthly Adjustment Amount. It is a surcharge that reduces a Social Security check once income in retirement passes certain thresholds. For 2026, IRMAA starts once your 2024 income (MAGI) is more than $109,000 (single) or more than $218,000 (married filing jointly). The Medicare Trustees Report counts about 5.1 million Medicare beneficiaries who paid Part B IRMAA surcharges in 2025, amounting to about 7% of the 69 million total enrollees, and roughly 4.4 million paid the Part D version.
How the Surcharge Reaches Your Check
IRMAA is added on top of the standard premium, and the total is typically withheld from Social Security payments. Standard Part B premium: $202.90/month, usually deducted from your Social Security payment. The base charge rose from a year earlier, since the standard Medicare Part B premium for 2026 is $202.90 a month, an increase of $17.90 from $185.00 in 2025, according to CMS. The annual Part B deductible also climbed to $283 in 2026, $26 more than in 2025.
Higher earners pay considerably more. For these beneficiaries, total monthly Part B premiums range from $284.10 to $689.90. The surcharge is layered across tiers, and above those thresholds, IRMAA adds $81.20 to $487.00 per month to Part B, and up to $91.00 more for Medicare Part D drug coverage, across five surcharge tiers. The Part D portion is a fixed surcharge that you pay directly to Medicare (or it is deducted from your Social Security check), regardless of which private drug plan you have. Suze’s figure of roughly $560 reflects one retiree’s bill at one point in time, so it works better as an illustration than as a current rate.
Why the Two-Year Lookback Catches Retirees
Medicare sets your surcharge using the tax return from two years earlier. A 2024 return determines the 2026 premium. That timing means a one-time event such as selling a rental property, exercising stock options, or completing a large Roth conversion can raise premiums two years later, long after the cash has been spent or reinvested.
A Realistic Scenario
Consider a married couple who sells a rental property in 2024 and recognizes $260,000 in capital gains on top of $120,000 in normal retirement income. Their modified adjusted gross income reaches $380,000 for that year. For joint filers in 2026, the third tier covers income from $342,001 to $410,000, so both spouses fall into it. The total Part B premium is $527.50 per month (standard $202.90 plus $324.60 IRMAA surcharge), and the Part D surcharge adds $60.40 per month. That puts the combined surcharge at $385 per spouse each month.
For the couple, that totals $770 a month, or roughly $9,240 over the year, even though the income came from a single sale in 2024. They recognized the gain and paid the capital gains tax by April 2025, then in 2026 saw the surcharge come out of their Social Security checks for a property they no longer owned. The surcharge can add up to $6,936 per person per year.
The surcharge works as a cliff rather than a gradual increase. One extra penny above either figure triggers a Tier 1 surcharge that adds $81.20 per month to Part B and $14.50 per month to Part D per person, totaling $1,148 per year per beneficiary. Once a threshold is crossed, the full tier amount applies to the premium for all twelve months.
The same pattern can affect retirees who do large Roth conversions in their 60s, take a sizable required minimum distribution, or sell a business. The income may be a one-time event, but the premium bill arrives two years later and applies to both spouses on the same joint income figure.
Whether the High Income Was One-Time or Ongoing
The key question is whether the high-income year was a one-time event or your new normal. A retiree who draws $400,000 a year from a portfolio should plan for IRMAA as a permanent line item in the Medicare budget from the start. If the spike came from a property sale, an inheritance, or a Roth conversion, there may be a route back to lower premiums.
Using Form SSA-44 After a Qualifying Event
Form SSA-44 is the tool for reducing a surcharge after a qualifying life event. A life-changing event that lowered your income is not an appeal: it is a request for a new decision, on form SSA-44. You can ask once the event has happened, or before it if you’re retiring on a set date, and the new decision generally starts in January of the year you ask.
The form covers a closed list of situations. Social Security recognizes eight life-changing events on Form SSA-44: marriage; divorce or annulment; death of a spouse; you or your spouse stopped working; you or your spouse reduced work hours; loss of income-producing property (not due to your decision to sell); loss of pension income; and an employer settlement payment due to bankruptcy or reorganization. An income drop by itself does not qualify. Loss of income-producing property applies to losses through no fault of your own, such as disaster or theft, not a voluntary sale. A one-time income spike from a Roth conversion, a property sale, or a large distribution is not one of the eight life-changing events SSA recognizes.
Retirement is usually the strongest basis. Partial retirement or a move from full-time to part-time work counts as work reduction, and full retirement falls under work stoppage. For documentation, work stoppage or work reduction is typically supported by a signed statement from the employer, or a retirement letter, showing the date. Filing options include submitting the form online at ssa.gov/medicare/lower-irmaa or mailing it to your local Social Security office, and you can report a life-changing event by phone at 1-800-772-1213 or at a field office.
Steps to Take Before Your Next High-Income Year
Plan the numbers before triggering any large income event in your 60s or later:
- Check the 2026 bracket table and estimate where your modified adjusted gross income will land two years out. For joint filers, the income brackets for Part B and Part D are the same, with tiers beginning above $218,000 and stepping up at $274,000, $342,000, and $410,000, then $750,000. Because the surcharge works as a cliff, a small difference in income can change annual costs by thousands of dollars for each spouse.
- If a one-time income event is coming, consider whether you can split it across two tax years so each year stays below the next threshold. The Part D surcharge is billed on its own, so the cost of crossing a bracket is higher than the Part B amount alone suggests.
- If a qualifying event has already happened and your income has dropped meaningfully since the tax year Social Security used, download Form SSA-44 from ssa.gov and file it promptly. Do not wait for the next billing cycle to correct the amount on your own.
Suze’s example of KT’s check is the clearest warning a high-earning retiree will hear. The higher your income two years ago, the smaller your Social Security deposit today. The delay between the income event and the premium increase is what makes the surcharge feel sudden, but it traces back to a tax return filed two years earlier, so the best defense is knowing the rules before the bill arrives.
Editor’s note: The illustrative couple now shows about $9,240 in combined annual surcharges for both spouses, using the 2026 tier 3 Part B and Part D amounts. The article also adds the latest count of Medicare enrollees paying IRMAA, the 2026 Part B premium and deductible, and current filing details for Form SSA-44.
Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.








