A $400,000 Annuity Guarantees $2,600 a Month for Life, but Here Is the $190,000 Retirees Are Giving Up

Published June 30, 2026, 10:35am ET · 4 min read

This post may contain links from our sponsors and affiliates, and Flywheel Publishing may receive compensation for actions taken through them.

Annuity Concept Displayed on Calculator With Financial Documents in Office Setting
© Fox_Ana / Shutterstock.com

A 65-year-old retiree with $400,000 set aside is considering an annuity that pays roughly $2,600 a month, guaranteed for life. That works out to about $31,200 a year, paid until death. There is no market exposure, no sequence-of-returns risk, and no portfolio to manage.

The offer looks stronger than it did earlier this year. The 10-year Treasury yield jumped to 4.98% on November 10 and briefly moved above 5% after hotter-than-expected October inflation data, according to CNN’s market coverage. That rise followed the Federal Reserve’s September decision to lift its benchmark rate to a range of 3.75% to 4%. Insurers price annuity payouts largely off long-term rates, so higher yields generally mean larger monthly checks. The catch is the estate: the retiree gives up a large share of what would otherwise pass to heirs.

Fidelity’s second-quarter 2026 data put the average baby boomer 401(k) balance at $283,200 as of June 30. The same report showed the average balance across all savers reached a record $155,800. A $400,000 nest egg therefore sits well above the typical boomer account, which puts the annuity question in front of many near-retirees.

Why $2,600 a Month Looks Better Than It Is

A single-premium immediate annuity (SPIA) turns a lump sum into a guaranteed income stream. Because the insurer sets the payout mainly from long-term interest rates, the 10-year yield is the number to watch for anyone shopping annuities now. A $2,600 check can look like a generous return on paper, yet much of each payment is simply the retiree’s own principal coming back. On a life-only contract, the insurer keeps whatever remains at death.

Life expectancy drives the math. The Social Security Administration’s period life table, the 2023 table used in the 2026 Trustees Report, puts remaining life expectancy at age 65 at 18.12 years for men and 20.66 years for women. A couple should plan for the longer-lived spouse needing income well into their 80s and possibly beyond.

The residual value is the most debated piece of the illustration. Keeping the same $400,000 invested while withdrawing $31,200 a year is a draw of about 7.8% of the starting balance. At a 4% annual return, that account would run out before the 20-year mark, so the roughly $190,000 residual depends heavily on returns well above that level. On a life-only SPIA, that residual goes to the insurer rather than heirs.

Inflation is the second cost. The 2026 Social Security COLA was 2.8%. On October 14, the Social Security Administration announced a 3.6% COLA for 2027, the largest increase since 2023. Over the past 20 years, the average COLA has run about 2.6%, according to Boldin’s analysis. A fixed $2,600 check does not adjust on its own, so its buying power shrinks every year, and the loss compounds over a long retirement.

Comparing that against a self-managed withdrawal strategy shows what the insurance guarantee costs over two decades. Coverage matters too. If an insurer fails, state guaranty associations step in, but limits differ by state. Annuity protection in most states covers up to $250,000 in present value, while Connecticut, New York, and Washington offer $500,000. A $400,000 purchase from one carrier would exceed the standard limit in most states, so splitting the premium across two insurers keeps each portion within coverage.

Annuity Types

Not every SPIA ends at death. Three common structures trade off payout size against what heirs receive:

  1. Life-only pays the highest monthly amount and stops at death, even if death comes six months after signing. This is the version that produces the full $2,600.
  2. Period-certain (typically 10 or 20 years) guarantees payments for a fixed window. If the owner dies in year 5 of a 20-year-certain contract, the beneficiary collects the remaining 15 years. The monthly check is smaller than a life-only payment.
  3. Joint-and-survivor keeps paying a spouse after the first death. Payments are smaller still, but the structure protects a surviving spouse who would otherwise lose the income.

Another Option: Annuitize a Slice

Many advisors suggest annuitizing only part of a portfolio. The goal is to cover the essentials gap, meaning the fixed monthly spending that Social Security does not already pay for. The rest stays invested, accessible, and available to heirs.

Take a retiree whose Social Security pays $2,400 a month against $4,000 in fixed costs. The gap is $1,600 a month. The annuity only needs to be sized to produce that $1,600, not the full balance, which keeps the remaining savings liquid and inheritable for medical costs or unexpected needs. Splitting the premium across two carriers also keeps both contracts within state guaranty limits for most policyholders.

Two refinements are worth weighing:

  1. Ladder your purchases. Buying one SPIA now and another in three years spreads interest-rate risk and captures higher payouts as the buyer ages, since older buyers receive more income per dollar committed.
  2. Consider inflation-adjusted SPIAs. These contracts start with a lower initial payment but rise with inflation each year. With the 2027 COLA set at 3.6%, the cost of that protection is easier to justify for a healthy 65-year-old planning a long retirement.

What to Decide First

  1. Calculate your essentials gap before sizing any annuity. Buying beyond that gap converts inheritable savings into a payment stream the retiree will never recover.
  2. Married couples should look at joint-and-survivor or period-certain contracts first. Life-only payments have left many surviving spouses without income, and the extra monthly amount rarely justifies that risk.

Editor’s note: The rate backdrop now reflects the Federal Reserve’s September 2026 hike to a 3.75% to 4% range and the 10-year Treasury’s move to around 5% in November. The 2027 Social Security COLA is now set at 3.6%, the Social Security Administration’s October 14 figure, and the life expectancy and state guaranty limit figures were replaced with current SSA and state-level data.

Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.

Carl Sullivan

Carl Sullivan has been a Flywheel Publishing contributor since 2020, focusing mostly on personal finance, investing and technology. He started his journalism career covering mutual funds, banking and financial regulation in Washington.Carl is a contributing editor at Financial Advisor Magazine and previously served as managing editor at Financial Planning Magazine. He is a long-time manager of editorial teams covering a variety of topics including news, business and politics. He’s currently the North America Managing Editor for Flipboard and worked previously for Microsoft News and Newsweek.Carl loves exploring the world and lived in India for several years. Today, he resides in New York City’s Queens borough, where you can hear hundreds of different languages just by riding the subway.

All articles →