He Will Wait to Buy Long-Term Care Insurance at 65, Three Years From Now. If a Memory Diagnosis Comes First, Insurers Can Turn Him Down, Leaving Him Exposed to $129,575 a Year
This post may contain links from our sponsors and affiliates, and Flywheel Publishing may receive compensation for actions taken through them.
Picture a healthy 62-year-old with a tidy plan: pay off the mortgage, then buy long-term care insurance at 65. That plan has a loophole. These insurers use medical underwriting. They go through your health records and prescriptions before they decide whether to sell you a policy at all. A memory diagnosis in that file, even a mild one, can end the application on the spot.
If he’s turned down, he’s self-insured by default. A private nursing home room carried a national median cost of $129,575 a year, or $355 a day, in CareScout’s 2025 Cost of Care Survey. For a sense of scale, the average American household spent $81,905 on everything in 2025.
Why a Memory Diagnosis Shuts You Out of Long-Term Care Insurance
Dementia drives the claims these policies pay. Under federal tax law, a qualified policy pays benefits when a person can’t perform at least 2 activities of daily living for a period of at least 90 days[1]. It also pays when someone needs “substantial supervision to protect such individual from threats to health and safety due to severe cognitive impairment.”[1] Selling a policy to someone already showing memory loss is like selling fire insurance on a house that’s already smoldering.
Underwriters dig in. When an applicant’s records show any indication of cognitive impairment, carriers give standardized memory tests by phone or in person. Nationwide cut what was a 20-minute telephone assessment down to a three-minute online cognitive screening.
Age alone already hurts his odds. In a 2022 Milliman LTC Survey, 38.2% of applicants ages 65 to 69 were turned down. Among those applying between 70 and 75, 47% were turned down or deferred. “After age 65, it gets increasingly hard to be accepted for this protection,” said Jesse Slome, director of the American Association for LTC Insurance. He pointed to ages 55 and 65 as the “sweet spot” and said that once people get Medicare, more doctor visits tend to add more conditions to their records.
Once he’s approved, the timing works in his favor. Tax-qualified policies must be guaranteed renewable[1], so a diagnosis that shows up after the policy is issued can’t get him dropped as long as he keeps paying. Premiums can still rise. As a 2017 episode of The Clark Howard Podcast warned, “the premiums are not guaranteed. So over the years they could actually go up.”
Early Alzheimer’s Detection Makes Waiting Riskier
Science keeps driving the diagnosis earlier. Stanford scientists found patterns of brain activity that may forecast Alzheimer’s risk years before memory problems appear, ScienceDaily reported on Nov. 14, 2026. That’s great news for treatment and bad news for anyone still shopping for coverage.
Federal law offers less protection here than most people assume. The Genetic Information Nondiscrimination Act does not apply to life, long-term care or disability insurance, and those insurers can use genetic, personal and family health information. A biomarker result or a neurologist’s note in the chart at 64 becomes underwriting evidence at 65.
Medicare Stops at Day 100, and Medicaid Lets You Keep $2,000
People who get turned down often assume Medicare will catch them. The federal health insurance program covers people 65 and older. Short skilled nursing stays are covered, with a limit of 100 days of care in a skilled nursing facility during each benefit period. Days 1 through 20 cost $0. In 2027, days 21 through 100 carry a $222[2] daily coinsurance, up from $217. After that, Medicare pays nothing for long-term custodial nursing home care, meaning the years of help with bathing, dressing and supervision that dementia usually requires. The custodial gap is one of several Medicare surprises we mapped out in a free guide to Medicare’s hidden bills, from Income-Related Monthly Adjustment Amount (IRMAA) surcharges to coverage holes most retirees never see coming.
Medicaid is a different program. It’s run jointly by the federal government and the states for people with limited income and assets, and it does pay for extended facility care. The catch: in most states, a single applicant 65 or older can keep only $2,000 in countable assets in 2026. States set their own limits, and the gap is wide. California brought back its Medi-Cal asset limit at $130,000 for an individual as of January 1, 2026. In a $2,000 state, a dementia patient spends down nearly everything before Medicaid takes over the bill.
Three-Year Delay Puts Coverage at Risk
His plan works only if his medical chart stays clean until 65. Clark Howard pointed to an earlier window on his show back in 2017, but it remains true today: “If you can afford it, you should consider sometime around age 60 buying a long term care insurance policy. They’re not perfect, far from it.”
Applicants with clean records today lock in their insurability. Those who wait take the chance that a memory screen, a new biomarker test or a doctor’s note gets there first. If it does, nothing stands between his savings and a $129,575 annual bill except Medicaid’s spend-down rules.
Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.








