Two 68-Year-Old Neighbors With Diabetes Leave Medicare Advantage by Dec. 7. His Plan Is Closing, So Medigap Must Take Him. She’s Leaving by Choice, So a Medigap Insurer Can Turn Her Down
This post may contain links from our sponsors and affiliates, and Flywheel Publishing may receive compensation for actions taken through them.
Two neighbors on the same street are both 68, both manage type 2 diabetes, and both plan to leave Medicare Advantage by the time enrollment closes on Dec. 7. He got a nonrenewal letter because his plan ends Dec. 31. She wants her own doctors back and is tired of prior authorization fights. On paper they’re making the same move. Federal Medigap rules treat them very differently.
He has plenty of company. About 3.2 million Medicare Advantage members need a new plan for 2027 because insurers are dropping coverage. That includes about 600,000 members of Humana (NYSE:HUM | HUM Price Prediction) whose plans won’t be offered next year. If you got an Annual Notice of Change (ANOC) instead of a nonrenewal letter, your plan is continuing and you’re in her position.
A Closing Plan Forces Medigap Insurers to Accept Him
Medicare’s Medigap guide lists a few events that give a buyer a guaranteed-issue right. One is a private Medicare plan that leaves the program or stops providing care in the member’s area. In that case, “the insurance company must cover all your pre-existing health conditions without a waiting period,” per Medicare.gov. He can apply as early as 60 days before his coverage ends and no later than 63 days after. For a Dec. 31 end date, that window runs roughly Nov. 1 through March 4, 2027. His diabetes can’t be used against him.
His risk is drug coverage. If he does nothing, Medicare switches him automatically to traditional Medicare, which only includes Part A and Part B. His nonrenewal Special Enrollment Period runs from December 8 through the last day of February. But a Part D plan he picks in January doesn’t start until Feb. 1, which would leave his insulin uncovered for a month.
Leaving by Choice Lets an Insurer Turn Her Down
Her Medigap Open Enrollment Period lasted six months from when she first had Part B at 65, and it only happens once. Medicare also gives a one-year trial right to people who joined Advantage when they were first eligible and then leave within 12 months. Hers ran out at 66. Now insurers “may deny you a policy unless you have a guaranteed issue right.” Medigap health questions are written to catch conditions like diabetes. Even if an insurer approves her, it can charge more or delay coverage of her diabetes care for up to six months.
Where she lives matters. Connecticut, Massachusetts, Maine, and New York provide stronger protections ensuring policy approval. Connecticut, Massachusetts and New York need continuous guaranteed issue, while Maine requires an annual window. In most other states, the federal rules apply and she can be turned down.
What a Bad Year Costs Without a Supplement in 2027
These figures come from the 2027 plan-year numbers the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid (CMS) released on Nov. 17, 2026[1]. The standard Part B premium rises to $209.40[1] a month from $202.90, or $2,512.80 a year per person. The Part B deductible goes to $292[1]. Both neighbors pay that standard premium if their 2025 income was $112,000[1] or less for a single filer. CMS says surcharges hit only about 8% of enrollees, but IRMAA is one of several premium traps that catch retirees off guard (we mapped the rest in a free Medicare guide).
Original Medicare by itself leaves annual out-of-pocket costs uncapped. Here’s a bad diabetic year with no supplement:
- Two hospital stays in separate benefit periods: two inpatient deductibles of $1,776[1], or $3,552
- A full skilled nursing stay, days 21 through 100, at $222[1] a day: $17,760
- 20% Part B coinsurance on an example $15,000 of specialist visits, glucose monitor supplies, and outpatient care: $3,000
That adds up to $24,312 before premiums. Plan G covers all of it except the $292[1] Part B deductible. Her current Advantage plan at least caps in-network costs. If she drops it and Medigap turns her down, she loses both forms of protection.
Three Moves to Make Before Dec. 7
- He should enroll in a standalone Part D plan by Dec. 7. Pick one that covers his insulin at his pharmacy so coverage starts Jan. 1. Then apply for Plan G now and include the nonrenewal letter as proof of his guaranteed-issue right.
- She should get approved for Medigap before she drops anything. Apply first and get the approval in writing. Then join a Part D plan, which automatically takes her out of her Advantage plan. If she’s denied, she should choose the strongest 2027 Advantage plan by Dec. 7, after checking that her endocrinologist is in network and her diabetes drugs are on the formulary.
- She has a backup window if approval comes late. The Medicare Advantage Open Enrollment Period runs January 1 through March 31 and lets Advantage members switch to Original Medicare once. A Medigap approval that arrives in January still works, as long as she stays enrolled in an Advantage plan through Dec. 31.
He can make his switch without any health questions. Before she gives up her current coverage, she needs a Medigap insurer to approve her in writing.
Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.








