How American Express Is the Worst DJIA Stock of 2016, by Far

Print Email

It seems like the old advertising line “Don’t leave home without it!” has turned into “Just don’t leave home.” American Express Co. (NYSE: AXP) now has the dishonorable title of being the worst performing Dow Jones Industrial Average stock of 2016. The year may not even be a month complete yet, but as of Friday American Express shares were down a whopping 20.5%, on a dividend adjusted basis.

To add insult to injury, Amex shares were down a sharp 24.2% in 2015, even after adding the dividend yield back into the equation. Wal-Mart barely beat out Amex for the worst DJIA stock of 2015 with its drop of 26.6%, and Caterpillar was the only other Dow stock to come close with a total return of some -22.97%.

Of the 30 Dow Jones stocks, nine were down by more than 10%. America Express was the only one down over 20%, led by its 12.1% post-earnings drop on Friday alone. Does a 0.9% recovery make much difference on Monday? Not really.

American Express was already down with the broad market so far in 2016 before earnings. Now its earnings made things go from bad to worse. Sadly, very few investors see any real catalysts for a return of upside here. It also doesn’t even matter that Warren Buffett is the largest Amex shareholder by far here, because he has owned it so long his cost basis on a dividend-adjusted basis would have to date back to the 1980s.

At the end of 2015, American Express had a market cap of some $68.45 billion. Now that is down to $53.8 billion. Its dividend yield was a paltry 1.67% at the end of 2015, but the poor price performance has artificially lifted that yield up to about 2.1%. What was a price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio of about 12 times forward earnings at the end of 2015 is now closer to 10 times expected earnings.

Here is where the real killer comes into play. Without considering the dividend adjustment, analysts on Wall Street were suggesting that American Express shares had a consensus analyst target of $80.92 — a total return possibility here of 18% if you included its dividend. With a poor earnings reaction and a poor stock performance, guess where analysts think Amex is fairly valued now (hint: it’s a lot lower).


The $69.55 unadjusted closing price for 2015 is now down to $55.49 on a dividend-adjusted basis. The consensus analyst price target has now gone down to $69.29, but the reality is that Thomson/First Call’s consensus analyst targets often take a few days before fully reflecting the right prices for the analyst targets.

Things might not have seemed so bad for Amex if you just looked at the numbers on a raw basis:

  • Revenues would have increased 4% if you exclude the impact of foreign exchange rates and the Concur gain, primarily from continued growth in net interest income and higher customer spending.
  • Its return on average equity (ROE) was 24.0%, down from 29.1% a year ago, but if you took out the enterprise growth group charge its adjusted ROE was 25.6%.
  • For 2016, Amex gave guidance of $5.40 to $5.70 earnings per share (EPS), compared to the consensus estimate of $5.41 in EPS.
  • Streamlining and driving efficiencies are now expected to remove $1 billion from Amex’s overall cost base by the end of 2017.
  • U.S. Card Services reported fourth-quarter net income of $799 million, up 20% from $665 million a year ago.

Now we have many analysts who have lowered their ratings or targets on Amex, with a few trying to be less negative due to low valuations. These were seen as follows:

  • Argus downgraded it to Hold from Buy.
  • Credit Suisse lowered its target price to $66 from $71 and maintained its Underperform rating.
  • Jefferies kept its Hold rating and lowered its target to $58 from $70.
  • KBW downgraded it to Market Perform from Outperform.
  • Morgan Stanley downgraded it to Equal Weight from Overweight.
  • Oppenheimer raised it to Perform from Underperform.
  • RBC kept an Underperform rating and cut the target.

Maybe some investors were glad to see Amex shares back up 0.9% at $55.55 late on Monday. Others would point out that this might be a dead cat bounce as shares also hit a new 52-week low of $54.14 on Monday. The 52-week high is $86.18.