Morningstar's Market Thermometer Is Flashing a Warning for 2026
As seen on the 24/7 Wall St. homepage on November 20, 2026.
How Today’s Markets Stack Up Against the Past 20 Years
- Morningstar's Amy Arnott calls inflation the biggest 2026 risk: price increases are largely permanent, worst for retirees
- Gold down nearly 30% from its January peak as higher yields dull its safe-haven pull; Arnott calls it more speculative now
- US valuations elevated but earnings growth has capped PEs; any earnings miss invites steep declines, international roughly on par
- Bitcoin off about 50% from its $125,000 peak; Arnott caps exposure at 2-3% of a portfolio
All seven indicators on Morningstar's Market Thermometer sit above their long-term averages, which is Arnott's case for trimming risk rather than adding it. For anyone holding broad US index funds, the warning is specific: strong earnings are the only thing keeping valuations defensible, and a single miss changes that math.
Continue ReadingShow less
Morningstar portfolio strategist Amy Arnott uses a seven-indicator Market Thermometer to gauge how stretched markets are relative to history. With every single one of those indicators now sitting above its long-term average, her read is straightforward: this is a moment for trimming risk.
US stock valuations are elevated, but Arnott notes that strong earnings growth has so far kept price-to-earnings ratios from looking outright alarming. The danger is that this balance is fragile. A single meaningful earnings miss removes the only thing keeping valuations defensible and invites steep declines.
Arnott names inflation as the biggest risk heading into 2026, describing price increases as largely permanent and especially damaging for retirees living on fixed income. Gold, often seen as an inflation hedge, has actually fallen nearly 30% from its January peak as higher yields have dulled its safe-haven appeal. Arnott now considers gold more speculative than protective.
Sponsored
Bitcoin has dropped roughly 50% from its peak, and Arnott's guidance is to cap any exposure at a small share of a portfolio. On international stocks, she sees valuations as roughly on par with US equities, which limits the diversification benefit investors might hope to find abroad.
The episode covers gold, interest rates, US and international equities, oil, bitcoin, the dollar, and housing. For investors holding broad US index funds, the core message is that the current environment rewards patience and discipline over enthusiasm.
Mentioned: IXN, OEF, IJH, IJK, IJJ, IVV, IVW, IVE, IJR, IJT, IEV, IJS, ITOT, IYM, IYC