American Integrity Insurance Q3 2026: EPS More Than Doubles Estimates

As seen on the 24/7 Wall St. homepage on November 10, 2026.

AII American Integrity Insurance Group
Q3 2026
EPS
$1.44
est $0.66 +118.2%
Revenue
$113M
est $105M +7.7%

Cutting the non-catastrophe quota share from 40% to 25% let American Integrity keep far more of what it writes, nearly doubling net premiums earned and more than doubling consensus earnings. The combined ratio improved to 70.6% from 78.9%.

Continue ReadingShow less

American Integrity Insurance Group reported adjusted earnings of $1.44 per share for the third quarter of 2026, more than doubling the consensus estimate of $0.66, a beat of 118%. Revenue came in at $113.5 million, topping estimates of $105.4 million by about 7.65% and surging 83% year over year.

The single biggest driver of the outperformance was a structural change made at the start of the year: the company cut its non-catastrophe quota share ceding percentage from 40% to 25% effective January 1, 2026. That shift meant American Integrity kept a much larger slice of every dollar it wrote, lifting net premiums earned 94.5% to $101.2 million and pushing underwriting income to $30.82 million from $11.55 million in the same quarter a year earlier. The combined ratio improved sharply to 70.6% from 78.9%, even as the expense ratio rose to 34.0% because of lower ceding commission income flowing back.

Voluntary new business also accelerated meaningfully. The company wrote roughly 41,000 voluntary new policies in the quarter, up 57% year over year, fueled by its re-entry into Florida's Tri-County region and expanded capacity for middle-aged homes. Tri-County alone produced 8,003 new voluntary policies compared with just 233 a year earlier, while the middle-aged home segment added 8,561 new policies versus 568 in the prior-year period.

Sponsored

CEO Robert Ritchie pointed to broad-based momentum across the company's strategic initiatives: "We delivered another strong quarter that reflects the continued execution of our strategy and the increasing strength of our voluntary growth platform. Following record voluntary new business production in the second quarter, we sustained that momentum in the third quarter, writing approximately 41,000 voluntary new business policies, an increase of 57% year over year, and an acceleration from the second quarter's year-over-year growth rate. We are seeing broad-based growth across our key strategic initiatives and believe we have substantial runway ahead."

Looking forward, management is evaluating further state expansion and new products in its existing ex-Florida footprint for 2027. The company also noted that Citizens Insurance policies in force are at their lowest level in 20 years, a structural tailwind that management believes will continue to drive voluntary market opportunities for established carriers like American Integrity. The total cost of the 2026/2027 catastrophe reinsurance program is expected to fall between $430 million and $440 million.

Sources

Mentioned: AII