Should Caterpillar Still Be the Best DJIA Stock of 2016?

It almost seems too good to be true, but Caterpillar Inc. (NYSE: CAT) is still the best performing of the 30 Dow Jones Industrial Average components so far in 2016. This total return of 27.3% is also the best performing DJIA stock by almost a full 5.5 points.

Less than robust economies in China, Brazil, Russia and other growth markets have all eaten into Caterpillar’s revenue growth. Ditto for the U.S. dollar strength and a slow capital spending climate. One issue that is more prevalent today than in years past is that there is now a rather large inventory of used equipment that can be bought or leased in many of these nations that might otherwise buy new equipment.

After tallying everything up, it almost seems ludicrous that Caterpillar should be up this much at — let alone be the best DJIA stock so far this year.

24/7 Wall St. wanted to look back over this case to see if it is overblown or if this resembles that mysterious recovery that catches cautious or logical investors by surprise. One key issue here is that the stock market tries to act like a discounting mechanism, looking beyond today’s news and figuring out what the scenario will look like six or 12 months in the future. In the case of big companies and expected turnarounds, sometimes the valuations and news headlines of today get discounted for 18 to 24 months.

Caterpillar’s year-to-date performance is 27.3%, if you include dividends. That seems hard to fathom for a company with no revenue growth and that just had one of the newer layoff announcements. The DJIA stocks behind Caterpillar in the chase all have total returns of 21% to 22% — Merck, UnitedHealth, 3M and Wal-Mart, respectively. The median gain on all Dow stocks is right at 6.3%, and the Dow itself is up over 8% so far in 2016.

Several big analyst calls have been made on Caterpillar in 2016. Some of these calls seem small in the big picture, but others stand out handily. These were seen as follows:

  • On August 16, Merrill Lynch’s technical team said its chart was favorable. On July 26, the fundamental team said that Caterpillar’s questions remain and its rating was Neutral with a $76 price objective.
  • On August 11, Jefferies maintained its Hold rating and $72 price target (versus $83.24 at the time). The firm feels like the end growth looks elusive and the restructuring may be only half way done.
  • On August 20, Caterpillar was maintained as Sell with a $63 target for 12-months out at S&P Global.
  • On August 9, Macquarie maintained its Underperform rating with a mere $51 price target. Its view is that investors should sell Caterpillar shares on any strength, as 2016 should be a challenging year with worst of the oil and gas declines yet to come.
  • On July 27, Caterpillar was maintained as Sector Perform at RBC Capital Markets, but the price target was raised to $73 from $70, after having raised Caterpillar’s target to $70 from $68 back on April 25.
  • On April 26, Argus raised Caterpillar to Buy from Hold with a $92 price target.
  • On April 25, Goldman Sachs raised its rating to Neutral from Sell and put a $78 target on it, rather than the prior $62 target. That downgrade to Sell had been on January 25, with a $51 target, versus a then-current share price of $60.98.