4 High-Yield Dividend Stocks Paying Over 8% That Retirees Should Think Twice About
This post may contain links from our sponsors and affiliates, and Flywheel Publishing may receive compensation for actions taken through them.
Mortgage REITs carry some of the biggest yields in the market, and this year has shown how fast those payouts can disappear. Shares of Arbor Realty Trust (NYSE:ABR) are down 81.76% year to date, and its board has suspended the common dividend entirely. A high yield only matters if the payout is sustainable. The four mortgage REITs below all show warning signs that retirees should consider before buying for income.
Quick test: a dividend looks unsustainable when the correct earnings measure fails to cover it. For mortgage REITs, that measure is distributable earnings or earnings available for distribution (EAD). Other red flags are a shrinking book value and rising leverage used to keep the payout in place (we pulled the seven warning signs that a big yield is about to be cut into a free dividend trap guide).
Arbor Realty Trust (ABR): A 50% Trailing Yield With Nothing Behind It
On paper, Arbor’s trailing yield is 50%. That figure comes from $0.64 per share paid over the past 12 months against a $1.28 share price. The yield is a mirage. The stock has fallen 83.88% over the past year, and the board suspended the quarterly common dividend[1] to preserve capital and address upcoming debt maturities.
The warning signs showed up quarters earlier. The quarterly payout fell from $0.43 to $0.30 in 2025 and then to $0.17 in 2026. Distributable earnings slipped from $0.35 per share in Q3 2025 to $0.10 in Q2 2026[2], which left the $0.17 dividend not covered. In Q3, non-performing loans rose to 32 loans and $647.6M[1] of unpaid principal, up from 19 loans and $428.8M. For a retiree, the income from this stock is now zero.
A recovery would require management to build cash to roughly $700 million by the end of the first quarter[3] and repay $275 million of unsecured debt maturing in March. On the October 30 call, CFO Paul Elenio said earnings would likely "bottom out over the next 2 quarters."[3]
Blackstone Mortgage Trust (BXMT): An 11.2% Yield After a Deep Reset
Blackstone Mortgage Trust (NYSE:BXMT) yields about 11.2% on its new $1.20 annualized payout at $10.75. Part of that yield comes from the stock, which is down 38.4% year to date.
The board has already reset the quarterly dividend to $0.30 from $0.47[4], a 36.2% reduction. The first payment at the new rate comes January 15, 2027. Q2 distributable EPS of $0.31 had already fallen short of the $0.47 payout. In Q3, CECL reserves increased by $264.8M[4] to $606M, and book value per share fell to $17.06 from $19.31. A shareholder who collected $1.88 per share over the trailing year is now on track for $1.20.
There are real positives. Q3 distributable EPS of $0.38[4] covers the reset payout, watchlist loans fell 56% to $900M, and liquidity stands at $1.3B. CEO Tim Johnson said the new dividend "can be sustained through a range of rate and credit environments."[4] Management also expects pressure on forward earnings from impaired loans and lower-yielding owned real estate, so that coverage buffer could shrink.
AGNC Investment (AGNC): A 17.5% Monthly Yield With a One-Cent Cushion
AGNC Investment (NASDAQ:AGNC) pays $0.12 a month, or $1.44 a year. At $8.24, that works out to a yield of about 17.5%. The monthly rate has held steady since April 2020, which makes the stock popular with retirees who budget month to month.
Coverage is thin. Q3 net spread and dollar roll income came to $0.37[5] per share, against $0.36 of dividends declared, and was down $0.03 from Q2. The net interest spread narrowed to 1.86% from 2.00%[6], and book value per share dropped 16.9% to $7.13. Leverage rose to 7.9 times tangible equity from 7.4 times[5]. AGNC has cut before: its monthly payout stepped down from $0.22 to the current $0.12 across several reductions. A cut would hit a retiree’s monthly cash flow right away.
For the payout to hold, funding costs need to stabilize and mortgage spreads need to tighten. CEO Peter Federico places expected returns in the 18%–20% range[5], but he also warned that "there are a lot of moving pieces that drive these numbers. They will change rapidly quarter to quarter."
Annaly Capital Management (NLY): A 16.9% Yield That Is Covered for Now While Book Value Slides
Annaly Capital Management (NYSE:NLY) yields about 16.9% on a $3 annualized payout at $17.75. This year it raised the quarterly dividend to $0.75 from $0.70, and Q3 EAD of $0.80[7] covered it.
The pressure shows up on the balance sheet. Book value per share dropped to $17.86 from $20.15[7], the quarterly economic return was negative 7.6%, and GAAP leverage rose to 8.0x from 7.4x. Annaly also raised $757M[7] through its at-the-market program. Its history shows how far the payout can move: it was $0.22 a quarter through 2021 and $0.88 in mid-2022.
CEO David Finkelstein said, "We expect to outearn in Q4, and we will see how 2027 evolves." For the payout to stay safe, rate volatility needs to ease so book value can recover.
How Retirees Can Spot a Yield Trap Before It Springs
Arbor and Blackstone Mortgage show that a dividend cut usually takes the stock down with it, so income investors lose twice. See whether the right earnings measure covers the payout and whether book value is shrinking before buying. Also check whether the yield is high mainly because the stock has fallen. A big yield by itself is not reason enough to buy.
Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.








