Nvidia Just Fell 32% From Its Record. Here’s Warren Buffett’s Rule for a 67-Year-Old With $1.6 Million in Nvidia Stock and $2,900 a Month in Social Security
This post may contain links from our sponsors and affiliates, and Flywheel Publishing may receive compensation for actions taken through them.
Warren Buffett put his rule for risk in one sentence of his 2018 letter to Berkshire Hathaway shareholders: “Rational people don’t risk what they have and need for what they don’t have and don’t need.” He wrote it about borrowed money. This weekend it reads just as well for anyone whose retirement now rides on Nvidia (NASDAQ: NVDA).
Take a 67-year-old retired engineer, single, who bought 250 Nvidia shares for $34,055 in January 2019 and holds 10,000 of them after two splits, worth $1,628,500 at Friday’s close beside $600,000 in an IRA and $2,900 a month from Social Security. Nvidia is 73% of his investments, it closed Friday 32% below its Oct. 6 record of $239.24, and it reports earnings on Tuesday, Nov. 17, after the close. On Sunday, the Financial Times reported that Jensen Huang, who resigned as CEO on Thursday, has discussed a return with people close to him; Nvidia has not confirmed it.
Turned toward a retiree, Buffett’s sentence reads this way: the money that has to pay your bills for the rest of your life is what you have and need, and it should not ride on one company’s earnings call; the limit of that reading is that Nvidia has already fallen 32%, so selling now locks in a price far below what the same shares fetched five weeks ago. Here is the rule applied to one case, a scenario built for the arithmetic.
The retiree with 10,000 Nvidia shares
He is 67, a retired engineer, single, living in a state with no income tax. In January 2019 he bought 250 Nvidia shares at $136.22, a $34,055 purchase in his taxable brokerage account. The 4-for-1 split in 2021 and the 10-for-1 split in 2024 turned them into 10,000 shares. At the Oct. 6 record they were worth $2,392,400. At Friday’s close, $162.85 a share, they are worth $1,628,500. He has lost $763,900 since the record and still has 48 times the money he put in. These figures use Friday’s close, and Nvidia’s own guidance for the quarter it reports Tuesday was $108 billion of revenue, plus or minus 2%.
The rest of his money is $600,000 in a rollover IRA in an S&P 500 index fund, and $2,900 a month from Social Security. Nvidia is 73% of his investments. He spends $7,000 a month.
What he has and needs
Social Security covers $34,800 of his $84,000 a year. The other $49,200 has to come from savings, every year, for the rest of his life. Twenty-five years of that gap is $1,230,000, which is the 4% rule turned around: a pile that size pays $49,200 a year at 4%.
That $1,230,000 is what he has and needs. The IRA covers $600,000 of it. The other $630,000 is sitting in Nvidia, where it will move with Tuesday’s numbers. Everything above $1,230,000 is what he does not need, and Buffett’s sentence leaves him free to risk it.
So the rule says: sell enough Nvidia to fill the need pile, and let the rest ride. In round numbers that is 4,000 shares. At $162.85 they bring $651,400, which takes the need pile to $1,251,400. He keeps 6,000 shares worth $977,100, still the largest position he has ever owned.
The tax bill
The 4,000 shares carry a cost basis of $3.4055 each after the splits, $13,622 in all, so the long-term gain is $637,778.
His Social Security is taxable at the maximum 85%, which is $29,580. The standard deduction for a single filer in 2026 is $16,100 plus $2,050 for being over 65; the new $6,000 senior deduction phases out completely at his income. Ordinary taxable income is $11,430, taxed at 10%: $1,143.
The gain stacks on top. The first $38,020 of it falls under the $49,450 line where long-term gains are taxed at 0%. The next $496,050 is taxed at 15%, up to the $545,500 line: $74,408. The last $103,708 is taxed at 20%: $20,742. Then the 3.8% net investment income tax applies to the part of his income above $200,000: $17,760.
Total federal tax: $114,052, or 17.5% of the sale. He nets $537,348.
Two years later Medicare sends a second bill. Premiums for 2028 are set by 2026 income, and a year with $667,358 of modified adjusted gross income lands in the top tier. At 2026 rates that is $689.90 a month for Part B instead of $202.90, plus $91 on Part D: $578 a month more, $6,936 for the year.
Where the $537,000 goes
The 10-year Treasury yielded 5.10% on Wednesday, according to Treasury data. A ladder of Treasury notes paying about 5% on $537,348 produces $26,867 a year, $2,239 a month, without selling a share of anything. That covers more than half of the $49,200 gap. The IRA covers the other $22,333 at a 3.7% draw, and the 6,000 Nvidia shares are never part of the budget.
Tuesday, in his dollars
A 10% move on 10,000 shares is $162,850. On 6,000 shares it is $97,710. With the sale done, Tuesday’s swing lands on money he does not need. Without it, Tuesday afternoon decides whether his need pile is full.
The other side of the rule
Buffett wrote the sentence about debt, and nothing in it says a great business should be sold after a bad month. Selling 4,000 shares at $162.85 brings $305,560 less than the same shares would have brought at the Oct. 6 record. If Nvidia gets back to $239.24, the 6,000 shares he keeps are worth $1,435,440, and the 4,000 he sold would have been worth $956,960.
There is also a cheaper way to do it. Selling 2,000 shares in December and 2,000 in January spreads the gain over two tax years, keeps every dollar of it under the 20% line and cuts the net investment income tax: $48,915 a year, $97,830 in all, $16,221 less than one sale, if the 2027 brackets match 2026. Medicare takes some of that back, because two income years land in a surcharge tier instead of one, about $12,710 over 2028 and 2029 against $6,936. The net saving is about $10,400, and the price of it is that half the sale rides through Tuesday.
The bottom line
A $34,055 purchase in 2019 is worth $1,628,500 after a 32% fall, and it is 73% of this retiree’s investments. Buffett’s rule draws one line: $1,230,000 is what he has and needs. Selling 4,000 Nvidia shares fills that pile at a federal tax cost of $114,052 and a one-year Medicare surcharge of $6,936, and puts $537,348 to work at about 5%. The 6,000 shares he keeps are what he does not need, and Tuesday’s report can do what it likes to them.
Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.






