ETF

Forget Chasing Yield: This Is the Best Dividend ETF if You Actually Reinvest

Photo of Omor Ibne Ehsan
By Omor Ibne Ehsan Published

Quick Read

  • DGRO's quarterly payout has more than doubled since 2016, compounding into 244% total returns over a decade for investors who reinvested dividends.

  • DGRO outpaced VYM by 48 percentage points over 10 years despite VYM offering a higher starting yield, proving dividend growth beats chasing income.

  • DGRO's 0.08% expense ratio suits accumulating investors with a decade-plus horizon but delivers too little current income for retirees funding living expenses.

  • Are you ahead, or behind on retirement? SmartAsset's free tool can match you with a financial advisor in minutes to help you answer that today. Each advisor has been carefully vetted, and must act in your best interests. Don't waste another minute; learn more here.

This post may contain links from our sponsors and affiliates, and Flywheel Publishing may receive compensation for actions taken through them.
Forget Chasing Yield: This Is the Best Dividend ETF if You Actually Reinvest

© Investment and saving money concept. A man placing coins with growing tree with white up arrow of financial developments and business growth (Shutterstock.com) by Sichon

Chasing yield is the most expensive habit in dividend investing, and the iShares Core Dividend Growth ETF (NYSEARCA:DGRO) exists precisely because a lot of investors keep doing it anyway. DGRO holds companies that have grown their dividends for years and are likely to keep raising them, then lets that rising stream compound rather than chasing the fattest current payout. If you actually reinvest the dividends DGRO pays, rather than spending them, this is arguably the best-designed dividend ETF on the shelf.

The mechanics are unglamorous, which is the point. DGRO tracks a screen of U.S. stocks with at least five consecutive years of dividend growth, positive earnings, and payout ratios that leave room for future raises. Nothing about that screen produces a headline yield. The fund’s trailing 12-month distribution comes to $1.477673 per share against a price of $77, which puts the starting yield somewhere south of what a high-yield fund like the Vanguard High Dividend Yield ETF (NYSEARCA:VYM) offers. The return engine is the growth of the check, stacked on top of reinvestment, stacked on top of modest capital appreciation from businesses that can afford to keep raising payouts.

The Compounding Actually Shows Up

Look at what has happened to the dividend since inception. DGRO’s quarterly payout was $0.157888 in the first quarter of 2016. The most recent quarterly payment, in June 2026, was $0.330603. The Q4 2025 payment was even higher at $0.447036. Lumpier quarters sometimes produce a year-end true-up like that. A shareholder who bought a decade ago is now collecting more than twice the per-share dividend on shares they can plow back into at higher prices, which still buy more future dividend growth. That is what reinvestment does when the payout itself is climbing.

Total return tells the same story. DGRO has returned 245% over ten years and 68% over five, on an adjusted basis that assumes distributions are reinvested. Compare that to VYM, the natural foil. VYM returned 196% over the same ten-year window and 77% over five. VYM pays a bigger dividend today. DGRO ended up with more money in the account across a full decade. The growth-of-payout screen quietly won.

What You Give Up

The tradeoff is real, and pretending otherwise is how people end up disappointed. You start with less income. If you need to fund groceries next month, DGRO’s yield will look thin next to a covered-call fund or a high-yield basket.

Second, DGRO tilts toward large-cap quality names, financials, healthcare, and industrials. In a year where mega-cap growth carries the market, DGRO can trail broad indexes even while doing exactly what it says on the tin. Third, the dividend itself is bumpy quarter to quarter. The distribution jumped to $0.447036 in Q4 2025, then settled back near $0.330603. Retirees who budget on quarterly checks would rather see a smoother line.

The cost of admission is almost nothing. DGRO’s expense ratio sits at 0.08%, which is what BlackRock charges when it wants a fund to be a default holding rather than a specialty product. For a $100,000 position, the annual fee is $80.

Who Should Actually Own It

DGRO fits investors who are accumulating, not spending. Younger investors building a taxable portfolio, savers filling up an IRA or Roth, anyone with a decade or more before they need the cash.

If your dividends are automatically reinvested in the account to buy more shares, DGRO’s design works for you every quarter. If you need maximum current cash flow, look at high-yield or covered-call products instead, and accept that you are trading tomorrow’s compounding for today’s check. For everyone in between, DGRO earns a core dividend holding slot the boring way. It keeps raising the payout.

Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.

Photo of Omor Ibne Ehsan
About the Author Omor Ibne Ehsan →

Omor Ibne Ehsan is a writer at 24/7 Wall St. He is a self-taught investor with a focus on growth and cyclical stocks that have strong fundamentals, value, and long-term potential. He also has an interest in high-risk, high-reward investments such as cryptocurrencies and penny stocks.

Continue Reading

Top Gaining Stocks

PYPL Vol: 65,526,676
CBRE Vol: 877,607
KMX Vol: 2,201,078
BLK Vol: 1,031,028
IVZ Vol: 2,650,351

Top Losing Stocks

PNR Vol: 8,106,430
DELL Vol: 8,891,191
NTAP Vol: 1,616,763
WDC Vol: 4,989,821
PGR Vol: 3,443,127