Annuities Are Worse Than People Think, and High Yield Savings Accounts Are Better
There’s a reason people are often drawn to annuities, especially as retirement gets close. The nice thing about an annuity is that it could set you up with steady, guaranteed income for life. Plus, there can be certain tax benefits…
This post may contain links from our sponsors and affiliates, and Flywheel Publishing may receive compensation for actions taken through them.
Retirement is one of the most compelling reasons people turn to annuities. The appeal is straightforward: guaranteed income for life, along with tax-deferred growth on contributions. For anyone who dreads outliving their savings, that pitch carries real weight.
But annuities are not the only path to dependable retirement income. As of September 2026, the Federal Reserve has held its benchmark federal funds rate steady at 3.50%-3.75% for five consecutive meetings, and that policy stance continues to support competitive returns on cash. High-yield savings accounts are currently delivering up to 4.50% APY at the top end, compared to a national average savings rate of just 0.38% APY. That gap makes the restrictive features of annuities harder to justify for many savers who need flexibility as well as yield.
Complexity is another hurdle. Annuities come layered with contract terms, optional riders, and fee structures that can take real effort to untangle. Before committing to one, it pays to understand the specific drawbacks that do not apply to high-yield savings accounts.
1. High fees
Annuities carry multiple layers of cost, and they stack on top of each other. Variable annuities typically run 2% to 3% in total annual charges, covering mortality and expense fees, administrative fees, and the underlying investment expense ratios. Add an optional income rider and total annual costs can climb to 3% or more. Fixed and multi-year guaranteed annuities (MYGAs) generally have no explicit annual fees, but the insurer builds its margin into the spread between what it earns on its portfolio and what it credits to your contract.
High-yield savings accounts, by contrast, frequently charge nothing at all. Many online banks impose no monthly maintenance fees and no minimum balance requirements. The difference in cost drag compounds meaningfully over a decade or two.
2. Illiquidity and Opportunity Cost
Annuity surrender periods lock up your capital, sometimes for seven years or longer. Surrender charges often start at 7% to 9% in year one and step down gradually before reaching zero. On a $200,000 contract, an 8% first-year surrender charge equals $16,000 in penalties if you need to exit early. Most contracts do allow a free annual withdrawal of up to 10% of contract value without triggering the surrender charge, but anything beyond that can be costly.
A high-yield savings account carries no such restrictions. Your money is available whenever you need it, with no penalty and no waiting period. That kind of instant liquidity matters when markets shift and better opportunities appear, since an annuity’s long surrender period can prevent you from acting on them.
3. Potential losses
Variable annuities carry genuine principal risk because their returns are tied directly to market performance. A bad sequence of returns early in the contract can permanently reduce the value of your account, even after fees are factored in. Fixed annuities avoid principal loss in nominal terms, but they carry a different kind of risk: if the guaranteed rate lags inflation, the purchasing power of your future income quietly erodes over time.
With a high-yield savings account, your balance cannot shrink in nominal terms as long as you stay within Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC) coverage limits, currently $250,000 for individual accounts and $500,000 for joint accounts. The trade-off is that savings rates are variable and will move with the Fed, but the principal is always intact.
Annuities can provide a reliable income floor for retirees who prioritize certainty above all else, and in 2026, competitive MYGA rates from A-rated carriers are running roughly 5.0% to 5.6% depending on term. Still, for savers who also value flexibility and transparency, a tiered cash management strategy anchored by high-yield savings offers a strong alternative worth comparing carefully.
Editor’s note: This update corrects the previously stated top high-yield savings APY from 5.00% to 4.50% based on September 2026 rate data, updates the Federal Reserve’s benchmark rate to the current 3.50%-3.75% range held for five consecutive meetings, and adds specific annuity fee ranges including variable annuity annual charges of 2%-3% and surrender charges that can start at 7%-9% in year one.
Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.
Maurie Backman has more than a decade of experience writing about financial topics, including retirement, investing, Social Security, and real estate. Her work has appeared on sites that include The Motley Fool, USA Today, U.S. News & World Report, and Kiplinger.
Prior to becoming a full-time financial writer, Maurie worked in the financial industry trading distressed debt. She then changed course and spent a few years designing electronic toys. After a stint in content marketing and UX, she shifted back into writing and has since covered everything from the housing market to estate planning to Medicare.
When she's not busy writing, Maurie can be found hiking, walking her dogs, driving her kids to their various sports practices and games, and curling up with a good book. She cooks on occasion and bakes way too often.
