‘Long Term Care Insurance as a Market Is Substantially Broken’: Clark Howard Breaks His Own Rule for 36-Year-Old Officer With $2 Million
This post may contain links from our sponsors and affiliates, and Flywheel Publishing may receive compensation for actions taken through them.
Clark Howard has spent years telling listeners to skip whole life insurance. On his October 2, 2026 show, he made an exception. He said he has “a genetic disposition to having a very high percent odds of having Alzheimer’s, which one of my siblings has. My mom had dementia and that’s a risk that I face.”
Then he gave his verdict on a whole industry: “Long-term care insurance as a market is substantially broken.”
That collapse is real. Clark has noted that the standalone LTC industry once had more than 1,000 carriers and has since shrunk to roughly 10. The companies that remain are the ones that learned, often at policyholders’ expense, how badly the original pricing assumptions failed.
The caller was Jared from Maryland, an active duty Air Force officer with 14 years of service, a wife and two kids. The couple has saved over $2 million in index funds and the Thrift Savings Plan (TSP).
Both parents were diagnosed with early-onset Alzheimer’s in their 50s. Jared puts his odds of carrying the single gene variant at around 50% and two copies at around 25%. At 36, he wanted to know whether to lock in coverage before getting tested.
The dilemma cuts two ways. He could pay for decades on a policy the insurer is free to reprice. Or he could test first and find that a positive result has closed the door on coverage entirely.
Why Clark’s Whole Life Exception Fits This Caller
Clark’s exception rests on guarantees. Standalone long-term care insurance premiums are not guaranteed. On Aug. 24, 2026, Clark explained: “Insurers can raise them to the point where they hope people leave and give up on their policy, what they call a ‘death spiral.’ A mutual insurer is less likely to do that.”
Consider a straightforward scenario. Jared buys a standalone policy at 36 for $2,000 a year. Over time the insurer wins three 50% rate increases, and his premium rises to $6,750. If he drops the policy at 60, he has paid $48,000 and gets nothing back. He walks away right before the years he is most likely to file a claim. For the insurer, a policyholder who leaves at that point is the best possible outcome.
Clark’s alternative is a whole life policy with a long-term care rider from a mutual company, where policyholders are also owners, rated double-plus for financial strength by AM Best. The premium is locked in by contract. If Jared needs care, the policy pays for it. If he never does, his wife and kids get the death benefit. Because the insurer cannot raise the price, the death spiral strategy has no leverage.
The tradeoff is cost. Hybrid policies typically run 200% to 300% more than a comparable standalone LTC policy. But the locked-in premium and the return-of-value structure are exactly what justify that gap for someone in Jared’s position.
The exception is narrow. On Sep. 28, Clark warned about insurance products sold with “enormous commissions and fees” that make you “our prisoner for up to 15 years.” Whole life carries the same commission load. It only makes sense when the risk being covered is as concentrated as Jared’s.
Genetic Test Timing Can Lock Him Out
Federal law decides the timing question Clark left open, and it does not favor waiting. The Genetic Information Nondiscrimination Act (GINA) does not apply to life or long-term care coverage. Life and long-term care insurers can legally use a positive genetic test result to deny coverage or set higher rates. Some states have enacted additional protections beyond GINA’s federal floor, so Maryland’s own rules are worth checking, but the federal gap is real.
That gap shapes the decision tree clearly. If Jared applies first, he is underwritten on his current health and coverage is secured. If he tests first and the result is negative, he can skip coverage and keep his money. If the result is positive, carrying roughly 50% odds, he may be turned down for good. Testing before applying only helps in the favorable outcome and can eliminate coverage in the unfavorable one. Applying first preserves the option either way.
Some will argue that $2 million lets Jared self-insure the risk. Clark’s rule is to buy insurance only when “the loss you would suffer is something that would be a big financial hazard in your life.” A private nursing home room now averages roughly $115,000 to $130,000 a year nationally, and memory-care units run higher still. Early-onset Alzheimer’s in his 50s could mean a decade or more of care while his wife is still working and his kids head to college. That kind of sustained draw on a seven-figure portfolio, during the years it would otherwise be compounding hardest, is a genuine financial hazard.
Steps to Take Before Ordering a Genetic Test
- Get quotes before any test is ordered. Price a standalone policy and a whole life policy with a care rider side by side. Ask each insurer, in writing, which premiums are guaranteed by contract.
- Screen the insurer the way Clark did. Only consider mutual companies. Check the AM Best rating yourself rather than taking the agent’s word for it.
- Get the full cost picture in writing. Ask for the commission, the surrender schedule, and how many years it takes for cash value to build.
- Add up your other income sources first. Under the Blended Retirement System (BRS), a 20-year retiree keeps 40% of base pay; a 30-year retiree keeps 60%, plus the TSP match. Jared may also have access to care through the VA system. Size any policy to cover the gap those sources leave.
When you are weighing a risk that could run for decades, a premium locked in by contract is the one variable that cannot be used against you later.
Editor’s note: This update adds 2026 national long-term care cost figures (private nursing home rooms averaging roughly $115,000 to $130,000 per year, per CareScout data) and context on the collapse of the standalone LTC market from more than 1,000 carriers to roughly 10, as cited by Clark Howard. The BRS retirement pay percentages (40% at 20 years, 60% at 30 years) were verified against Department of Defense sources and confirmed accurate.
Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.







