Suze Orman Explains Why Dividend Income Can Beat Treasury Income After Taxes

A retiree in the 24% federal bracket can move $100,000 out of a 10-year Treasury and into a dividend portfolio that pays a lower yield, and still end up with more available cash each year. Whether that works out depends mostly on one thing: the state the retiree lives in.

Suze Orman covered this comparison in a Suze School episode of her Women and Money podcast. She is a personal finance author and podcast host. Her central warning is one most income investors skip: “Don’t look at how high the yield is. You need to look at how safe the yield is, and one way you look at that is through free cash flow.”

She’s right on both counts. Dividends really do get a tax advantage, and her safety test is the price of collecting it, though one gap needs filling: state income tax can wipe out that advantage completely.

Two Tax Rules Decide What You Actually Keep

Most dividends from regular U.S. corporations are “qualified.” That means they’re taxed at the long-term capital gains rates of 0%, 15%, or 20%. To get that treatment, you have to own the stock for a minimum period around the dividend date. Sell too soon and the dividend is taxed like a paycheck.

Treasury interest works the other way. It’s taxed as regular income at the federal level, where brackets run from 10% up to 37%. But every state must leave it alone. So dividends win on the federal return, and Treasuries win on the state return.

Running the Numbers on $100,000

The 10-year Treasury yields about 5.2%. On that stake, that’s $5,240 a year before tax. After a 24% federal bite, the retiree keeps $3,982, with nothing owed to the state.

Now take an example dividend portfolio yielding 4.8%, which pays $4,800. At the 15% qualified rate in a state with no income tax, the retiree keeps $4,080. The lower yield delivers more cash.

In that no-tax state, the dividend portfolio only needs to yield about 4.7% to match the Treasury after taxes. Every dollar of yield above that is extra spending money.

Your State Tax Rate Can Flip the Answer

Move the same retiree to a state with an example 9% income tax. The dividends now lose 9% on top of the federal 15%, and take-home income falls to $3,648. The Treasury still delivers $3,982 because the state can’t touch it.

In that state, the dividend portfolio has to yield the full 5.2% just to tie. Going up into a higher federal bracket extends the dividend’s lead, because Treasury interest gets hit harder. A higher state rate reduces it. Your answer comes from where those two rates meet on your own return.

A Guaranteed Coupon Versus a Board’s Decision

A Treasury coupon is a contract. The government owes you $5,240 every year until the bond matures. A dividend is a decision by a company’s board, and the company can cut it or end it whenever it chooses.

That’s why Orman’s safety test matters. Free cash flow is the cash a company has left after paying its bills and reinvesting in the business. Think of it as a household’s take-home pay after the mortgage and roof repairs, and in the episode, Orman says a company should have enough free cash flow to cover the dividend. If the payout is bigger than that leftover cash, the company is borrowing or draining savings to fund it.

Dividends have one advantage a coupon can’t match: they can grow. Say that $4,800 rises by an example 5% a year. By year 10 it would be about $7,819, while the Treasury coupon stays flat.

What to Do Before Moving Any Retirement Money

1. Find both of your rates. Get out last year’s return and note your top federal bracket and your qualified dividend rate. The Qualified Dividends and Capital Gain Tax Worksheet in the Form 1040 instructions shows which qualified rate applied to you.
2. Run the comparison with your state included. Treasury take-home is the yield times one minus your federal rate, while dividend take-home is the yield times one minus your qualified rate and your state rate combined. Use the yields actually on offer to you.
3. Check free cash flow for every holding. Compare several years of free cash flow to the total dividends paid, and if the dividend is covered with room to spare, it holds up better when business slows.
4. Look at which account has the money. Withdrawals from a traditional IRA are taxed as regular income either way, so the dividend tax edge only applies in taxable brokerage accounts.

Treasuries suit retirees who need a fixed amount. They can count on it, along with savers in high-tax states where the state exemption tips the math. Dividends suit certain retirees. They live in low or no-tax states and higher federal brackets, and can live with a possible cut in exchange for income that can increase over time. Before you compare yields, compare what’s left after both federal and state taxes.

Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.