After She Died on Medicaid, the State Sent Her Estate a $140,000 Bill and Named the House. Her Son Had Lived There With Her for Nine Years on $31,000 a Year, and Under the State’s Own Hardship Rule the Claim Was Waived

When a parent gets Medicaid long-term care after age 55, federal law requires the state to bill the parent’s estate for that care after death. The house is often a major asset in that estate, and Medicaid estate recovery rules also contain an undue hardship waiver. Every state must have one, and many write it to protect an adult child who lived in the home and cared for the parent. A hypothetical $140,000 claim against a house where a son lived for nine years on $31,000 a year is what the waiver covers.

How a Hardship Waiver Cancels the State’s Claim

Estate recovery lets the state collect what Medicaid spent on nursing facility services, home and community-based services, and related hospital and prescription drug services. The hardship waiver overrides that claim. If an heir meets the state’s criteria, the agency drops the claim. Some states waive it permanently, and others only postpone it, so the family may not have to sell the house to repay Medicaid. Home values determine what is at stake. The Case-Shiller national home price index was at 337.3 in July 2026, up 1.9% from a year earlier.

Federal Law Behind the Waiver

The rule comes from Section 1917 of the Social Security Act, found at 42 U.S.C. § 1396p. Subsection (b)(1)(B) requires recovery for beneficiaries who were 55 or older when they received care. The law also bars recovery while a surviving spouse is alive, or while the beneficiary has a surviving child under 21 or a blind or disabled child. It requires each state to set up procedures to waive recovery when it would cause undue hardship. The federal State Medicaid Manual, Section 3810, says that “where estate recovery would work an undue hardship, adjustment or recovery is waived.” It leaves most of the specific criteria to the states.

Pennsylvania’s rule, 55 Pa. Code § 258.10, shows what those criteria look like, but the state will waive its claim if the person applying meets three tests. The first test is whether they have lived in the decedent’s primary residence continuously for at least two years immediately before Medicaid long-term care began.

The second condition is that they have no other permanent home. Finally, they must also have provided care or support for at least two years. A son who lived in the house for nine years, including the two years before his mother’s care began, meets the residence test.

Heirs Who Qualify and Heirs Who Miss Out

Hardship waiver criteria differ by state, and many require the heir to have lived in the home continuously for 12–24 months before the death. Some states add an income limit. One common version waives recovery when the heir’s income is less than 200% of the Federal Poverty Level, and the heir provided care.

For a one-person household in 2026, the federal poverty guideline is $15,960, and 200% of it is $31,920. A household making $31,000 is $920 under that limit. Full-time workers make a median of $1,251 a week in the second quarter of 2026.

Other states look at the house itself. Virginia exempts a “homestead of modest value,”. It defines this as a home worth 50% or less of the average or median home price in its county or city. Heirs who own another home, moved in shortly before the death, or never provided care usually fail these tests. Pennsylvania also bars creditors from asking for a waiver.

Steps to Claim the Waiver Before the Deadline

1. The estate recovery notice lists three things: the claim amount, the property named, and the deadline to request a hardship waiver.
2. Each state’s written hardship criteria are available from its Medicaid agency or administrative code.
3. You can document residence for the full required period with tax returns, a driver’s license, voter registration, and utility bills sent to the address.
4. You can document caregiving with physician letters, care records, and statements showing the care kept the parent at home.
5. Household income is measured against the 2026 guidelines, such as $31,920 at 200% for one person.
6. The request must be filed on time, and heirs can appeal a denial. Pennsylvania allows 30 days after notice of the decision.

Gaps and Deadlines That Can Cost Heirs the House

The waiver applies only if an heir requests it, and response windows can be short, as many states require residence and care to run continuously and immediately before the qualifying date. One elder law analysis warns that a six-month gap can break eligibility, even when the heir’s total time in the home passes the requirement. Some states only delay recovery, so the claim can come back once the heir sells the house or moves out, and heirs will also be judged under their own state’s rules. Pennsylvania’s caregiver test, Virginia’s modest-value test, and an income-limit test can each produce a different result for the same family.

Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.