He Chose the Single-Life Payout on a $750,000 Annuity Because It Paid $668 a Month More. He Died at 71, the Checks Stopped, and the Insurer Kept the Other $412,000

Published November 17, 2026, 4:03pm ET · 4 min read

The Full Benefits Desk desk. Editor: Gerelyn Terzo.

This post may contain links from our sponsors and affiliates, and Flywheel Publishing may receive compensation for actions taken through them.

A man leaning forward using a calculator on a coffee table, a woman holding and reading a sheet of paper
© Thinkstock

A hypothetical 65-year-old married man gives an insurer $750,000 for an immediate annuity, and the insurer quotes him two options. Annuity.org figures reported by CBS News in 2026 put the single-life payout for a 65-year-old man at about $4,688 a month and the joint payout at about $4,020. He picks single life, which pays $668 more each month. He dies six years later at 71. The checks come to a screeching halt, as does survivor income for his widow, and the insurer keeps the part of his premium it never paid out.

That choice is one of the most important decisions on an annuity application. Annuities are back in front of retirees this month, with AARP publishing a primer on key things to know about annuities. The payout election deserves more scrutiny than it usually gets.

How the Math Played Out for One Retiree

Hypothetical example: Six years of $4,688 checks add up to $337,536. Subtract that from the $750,000 premium and $412,464 was never paid out. Over those six years, the extra $668 a month came to $48,096. That’s everything the single-life election made him.

Payout Option Monthly Check While He Lives After His Death
Single life $4,688 Payments end
Joint life $4,020 Payments continue for the surviving spouse

Why Insurers Pay More for a Single Life

A single-life annuity covers one person against living a long time. The insurer pools many buyers, and the money left by those who die early pays for those who live into their 90s. That pooling makes the single-life check bigger. It also means an early death leaves money with the insurer.

The IRS Single Life table used for required retirement account withdrawals gives a 65-year-old a life expectancy of 22.9 years. At 71, the same table still shows 18 years. The buyer in this example died well short of both.

“Guaranteed” income on an annuity depends on the insurance company’s ability to pay its obligations. State life and health insurance guaranty associations step in when an insurer fails, but their coverage limits vary by state.

A Tax Deduction Survivors Often Miss

When an annuity is bought with after-tax (nonqualified) money, each check is split into a tax-free return of principal and taxable earnings. The split comes from the exclusion ratio, which compares the investment in the contract to the expected return under 26 U.S.C. § 72(b)(1)[1]. If payments stop before the full investment comes back, 26 U.S.C. § 72(b)(3)[1] lets the unrecovered investment be deducted on the annuitant’s last tax return. That deduction can lower the tax bill on the couple’s final joint return, but the cash itself stays with the insurer.

Annuities funded from an IRA or 401(k) usually have little or no after-tax basis. For those qualified contracts, the deduction is generally small or zero.

What Suze Orman and Clark Howard’s Show Told Listeners

Suze Orman walked a caller through the same tradeoff on a pension election: “So the less your spouse gets on your death, the more you get while you’re alive.” She said she normally recommends that both spouses “take the 100% joint and survivor option if you’re going to rely on that” income.

On an April 2026 Ask An Advisor episode of The Clark Howard Podcast with Wes Moss, listeners heard that when payments end early, the payer gets “to keep all the money.” The advice was to “make sure they have at least a minimum amount of years that they get paid out so that at least you get your money back.” A September 2026 episode gave the other side: for someone with a large life insurance policy that runs well into retirement, “you absolutely should consider the life only amount.”

Questions to Answer Before Signing the Payout Election

  1. Does a spouse depend on this income? Compare what the survivor will need with Social Security alone. The estimated average monthly benefit for an aged widow(er) living alone is $1,919 after the 2026 COLA. Survivor benefits run on their own rules, which we untangled in a free guide to the survivor benefit math.
  2. Is the gap covered somewhere else? Life insurance or other assets large enough to replace the lost check can make single life viable. That was the approach discussed on Howard’s show.
  3. What do refund and period-certain options cost? Life with a guaranteed payment period, or a cash or installment refund, pays less each month than straight single life. In return, unpaid premium goes to a beneficiary. Ask the insurer to quote each option side by side in dollars per month.
  4. How is your health, and your spouse’s? Family history and current health decide whether pooling is more likely to help or hurt you.
  5. Who backs the guarantee? Check the insurer’s financial strength and the caps your state’s guaranty association sets.

On immediate annuities, the payout election is generally locked in once income starts, so choose wisely.

What to Check Before Locking In Income

Payout quotes move with interest rates and differ by insurer, so a real buyer’s gap between the two options won’t match the $668 in this example. The 2027 Social Security cost-of-living adjustment (COLA) is 3.6%, which boosts a survivor’s base income. A fixed annuity check stays flat unless the buyer paid for an inflation rider. The numbers to ask for are what each survivor and refund option costs per month. Then compare those costs with what a surviving spouse would actually have to live on.

Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.

Gerelyn Terzo

Gerelyn Terzo is the author of dividend investing handbook "Dividend Investing Strategies: How to Have Your Cake & Eat It Too." A veteran financial journalist, she covers agri-finance for outlets like Global AgInvesting and the broader stock market and personal finance for 24/7 Wall Street. She began at CNBC and later helped launch Fox Business in New York. Gerelyn currently resides in Woodland Park, Colorado and dabbles in nature photography as a hobby.

All articles →

Sources

  1. 26 U.S.C. § 72 — Annuities; certain proceeds of endowment and life insurance contractsOffice of the Law Revision Counsel, U.S. House of Representatives