Retirees Are Buying Annuities at a Record Pace Following the Fed’s September Rate Hike

Published November 19, 2026, 7:37pm ET · 3 min read

This post may contain links from our sponsors and affiliates, and Flywheel Publishing may receive compensation for actions taken through them.

A marble eagle sculpture perched on a stone pedestal with wings spread
© Wikimedia Commons
Annuity sales in the United States climbed to a record $126.3 billion in the third quarter, the industry research group LIMRA reported, as insurers raised the rates they guarantee after the Federal Reserve’s September rate increase.
For a retiree with CDs coming due, the reason is easy to see. As of Nov. 19, the best five-year fixed annuity from an insurer rated A- or better, which falls in the rating firm AM Best’s second-highest category, “excellent,” paid 6.30 percent, according to rates compiled by AnnuityRateWatch and published by MyAnnuityStore. The best five-year CD paid 5 percent.
On $100,000, the annuity would earn about $1,300 more than the CD in the first year, or about $108 a month. The gap grows with the savings. Consider a hypothetical 67-year-old with $500,000 in CDs and $2,800 a month in Social Security: the annuity would pay $31,500 in interest in the first year, the CD $25,000. That is roughly $542 a month more, or $6,500 a year, before taxes.
The extra income comes with three strings, though one difference, taxes, may work in the annuity’s favor.
First, getting out is costly. Many annuities charge surrender fees for early withdrawals, FINRA warns, and the Minnesota attorney general’s office says those penalties may be as much as 25 percent of the principal, with the fees typically starting over if you switch to a new annuity. That makes a contract a poor place for money a retiree may need for a hospital bill or a new roof.
Second, it isn’t federally insured. The F.D.I.C. lists annuities among the products it does not insure, even when a bank sells them.
Third, it is only as safe as the insurer. Warren Buffett’s Berkshire Hathaway once turned down a chance to take on annuity guarantees; from a company’s perspective, he said in 2009, “that’s poison.” And insurers are putting more of their money into private loans that don’t trade on public markets: 26 percent of their cash and investments in 2025, up from 18 percent in 2016, a Demotech analysis found.
If an insurer does fail, your state’s guaranty association protects policyholders, but only up to a limit set by state law. In most states that is $250,000 for a fixed annuity, and it is a combined limit per person, not per policy; a few states differ, such as North Carolina, at $300,000. Failures have happened. When Executive Life was seized in 1991, its annuity checks stopped, though a Federal Reserve bank later wrote that none of the thousands who had bought its investment-oriented products would lose everything.
Now the tax point, which can help a retiree whose income sits near the line where Social Security benefits become taxable. Interest on bank CDs is taxed every year. With an annuity, FINRA says, “you don’t have to pay taxes on any growth in an annuity until you start making withdrawals,” so that delay could keep more of the $2,800 monthly check untaxed for a while. Money already in a traditional IRA gains nothing here, since the I.R.S. already holds off on taxing IRA earnings until withdrawal. A tax professional can say whether it applies.
Before signing, three questions settle most of it. Will you need the money before the surrender period ends? If so, keep it out. How is the insurer rated? Look for A- or better from AM Best, which notes that a rating “is not a recommendation to purchase” a policy. And does the amount stay within your state’s guaranty limit? Your state’s guaranty association can confirm the figure.

Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.

Don Lair

Don Lair writes about options income, dividend strategy, and the kind of boring-but-durable investing that actually funds retirement. He's the founder of FITools.com, an independent contributor to 24/7 Wall St., and a former writer for The Motley Fool.

All articles →