Her $420,000 in Employer Stock Inside Her 401(k) Lost 11% in a Day. Rolling It Into an IRA Would Turn Her Long-Term Gain Into Ordinary Income
This post may contain links from our sponsors and affiliates, and Flywheel Publishing may receive compensation for actions taken through them.
A hypothetical 61-year-old retiree has $420,000 of Broadcom (NASDAQ:AVGO | AVGO Price Prediction) stock inside her 401(k). She files single, she is past 59½, and her plan offers a straight rollover of the whole account into an IRA.
The stock fell 11% on Friday after analyst Ming-Chi Kuo posted that Alphabet (NASDAQ:GOOGL) unit Google cut its 2027 TPU 8i shipments by about 1M units.
Taking that rollover could cost her more than $30,000. Her shares carry an illustrative cost basis of $70,000, which leaves $350,000 of gain that built up inside the plan. If she rolls the shares into an IRA, every dollar of that gain will be taxed as ordinary income when she withdraws it.
One Rollover Form Erases Her Capital Gains Rate
IRS Publication 575 shows how this works. In its example, a plan participant sells stock distributed from his plan and rolls the $60,000 of proceeds into an IRA, and “the entire $60,000 rolled over will be ordinary income when he withdraws it from his IRA.”
She has another option. Under 26 U.S.C. § 402(e)(4)(B)[1], net unrealized appreciation (NUA) in employer shares received as part of a lump-sum distribution is left out of her gross income. She pays ordinary income tax on the basis now. The appreciation is taxed later at capital gains rates, when she sells.
A poster on the Bogleheads forum who was considering the same move laid out the steps. Open a taxable brokerage account and a rollover IRA, then ask the 401(k) custodian for a lump-sum distribution. The shares go to the brokerage account and everything else goes to the IRA.
Running Her Numbers: $100,800 Versus $69,300
Assume her IRA withdrawals land in the 24% bracket. For single filers in 2026, that bracket covers taxable income from $105,700 to $201,775.
Taking the full stock value out of an IRA at that rate costs about $100,800 in federal tax.
Under NUA, she owes 24% on the basis now, which is $16,800. When she sells, the gain is taxed at 15%. Single filers stay at that rate until taxable income tops $545,500.
| Path | Tax now | Tax at sale or withdrawal | Total |
|---|---|---|---|
| Roll to IRA | $0 | $100,800 | $100,800 |
| NUA distribution | $16,800 | $52,500 | $69,300 |
That’s a $31,500 difference. It increases if her IRA withdrawals end up taxed above 24%.
Friday’s Drop Makes the Case for Selling Early
NUA also gives her a way out of a concentrated position. She can sell the shares soon after the distribution and diversify, paying capital gains rates on the NUA. Kuo put the shipment cut at roughly 20% of Google’s planned TPU 8i shipments. That shows how much one customer decision can move a single stock.
Timing matters because of Medicare. IRMAA surcharges use a two-year lookback, so her income at 63 sets her premiums at 65.
Say she sold everything that year and her income topped $205,000[2]. At 2026 rates, her Part B premium would jump to $649 a month, compared with the $203 standard premium.
Tack on the $83.30 monthly Part D surcharge, and her combined Medicare surcharges come to about $6,355 for the year.
The IRA side has its own tax chain. Withdrawals from her hypothetical remaining balance of $680,000 count toward the Social Security provisional income formula. Above $34,000 for single filers, up to 85% of benefits become taxable.
She was born in 1965, so her RMDs begin at 75. Each dollar of stock moved out of the IRA through NUA stays outside of the IRA, beyond the grasp of RMDs taxed at ordinary rates.
NUA is one of a handful of IRS rules that quietly decide how much of a retirement account ever goes to the retiree. We mapped out nine of them, this one included, in a free tax trap guide.
Three Moves to Make Before She Turns 63
- Get the cost basis from the plan administrator. NUA is reported in box 6 of Form 1099-R. A low basis makes NUA pay off. If the basis is close to the current share price, moving over everything is the better path.
- Distribute the entire balance in one tax year. The law requires the total balance to come out within a single tax year after a trigger like a separation from service or age 59½. Waiting until January 2027 places the basis income in a fresh tax year.
- Finish selling by the end of 2027. Selling the shares at 62 holds the whole gain out of the lookback year that sets what she pays for Medicare at 65. If her taxable income tops the first single IRMAA threshold of $109,000[2] once she is 63, paying a fee-only tax planner to map the remaining IRA withdrawals is worth the cost.
Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.








