Carpentry Has 62,800 Openings a Year. At 67, Social Security Lets Him Work, but 40 Hours Can Suspend His Pension.

A 32-year-old who recently left tech for carpentry told Business Insider she visited seven construction sites in a week trying to land an apprenticeship. At the other end of the career ladder, experienced carpenters remain valuable enough that retirement does not always keep the phone from ringing. The Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) projects about 62,800 carpenter openings each year over the next decade, many created when workers retire or leave the occupation.

Now picture a 67-year-old union carpenter who already did exactly that. He hung up his tools, started Social Security and began collecting a building-trades pension. Then a former foreman calls. A remodel is behind schedule. Could he help for a few days? A few days becomes 40 hours in one month. Social Security does not care. His pension might.

Social Security and the Pension Run on Different Clocks

At 67, our carpenter has already passed full retirement age (FRA). The Social Security retirement earnings test is behind him. He can work 10 hours, 40 hours or full time without Social Security withholding benefits because of his wages. The annual earnings limit that applied before FRA no longer exists for him.

A multiemployer pension can operate very differently. Federal pension rules allow plans to suspend benefits when a retiree works at least 40 hours in a month in the same industry, the same trade or craft and the same geographic area covered by the plan. That framework shows up in actual carpenter plans.

The North Atlantic States Carpenters Pension Fund, for example, says some New England retirees can have benefits suspended for months in which they work at least 40 hours in disqualifying construction-industry employment. The exact age limits and definitions vary by plan, which is precisely what makes the trap easy to miss. Social Security is looking at his age. The pension may still be counting his hours.

One Busy Month Can Be Enough

The monthly clock is the part a retiree can easily overlook. Suppose he works eight hours one week, 16 the next and then stays on because the contractor still cannot fill the crew. He reaches 40 hours before the month ends. He may have earned only a modest paycheck. He may work almost nothing for the rest of the year. Neither necessarily rescues the pension payment if his plan treats that month as disqualifying employment. And discovering the problem later can make it worse.

Some plans can recover pension payments issued for months in which benefits should have been suspended. That is a very different calculation from Social Security, where a worker past FRA no longer has to pace his earnings at all.

The Trade Itself Can Follow Him Into Retirement

There is another nuance. Going to work for a different contractor does not necessarily solve the problem. For multiemployer plans, the federal test can reach work for another employer if the job is still in the same industry, trade or craft and geographic area. Some plan definitions can also capture supervisory work or self-employment that uses the retiree’s old trade skills. The retiree who thinks, “I’m only helping a friend,” may be answering a different question from the pension fund.

Before Picking Up the Tool Belt

For a retired tradesman considering a short return, three checks are worth making before the first shift:

1. Find the plan’s monthly hour threshold. Do not assume Social Security’s annual rules tell you anything about the pension.
2. Ask whether the specific job is prohibited employment. The employer, trade, location and duties can all affect the answer.
3. Get the determination in writing. Some carpenter funds specifically invite retirees to submit a proposed job description before taking the work.

There may be plenty of room in the labor market for an experienced carpenter to come back. The pension plan may give him considerably less room on the calendar.

Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.