Apple: Why Two Analysts See Fair Value at $250 but Won't Buy Yet

As seen on the 24/7 Wall St. homepage on November 19, 2026.

TIP862: Apple (AAPL): Is Apple Priced for a Massive Drawdown? w/ Daniel Mahncke & Shawn O'Malley

  • Services now drives over 40% of gross profit on mid-70s margins, 25% of revenue
  • App Store take rate under fire: US consumer spending down 6%, services growth slowed from 16% to 12%
  • Google still pays roughly $20 billion a year for Safari default; Apple pays about $1 billion for Gemini-powered Siri
  • Fair value pegged near $250, with the hosts waiting for roughly $200 to buy

The toll road thesis is the whole stock: own the device, rent the model, and collect a cut of everyone else's AI apps. Mahncke and O'Malley like the business and still will not pay today's price, putting fair value around $250 on a mid-20s multiple and 10% earnings growth. If agents route around the App Store, that commission stream thins out fast.

Continue ReadingShow less

Apple's Services segment has become the financial engine of the company, now accounting for over 40% of gross profit while representing a far smaller share of total revenue. That margin profile is what makes the business so attractive on paper, and it explains why the stock commands a premium multiple close to 40 times earnings.

The toll on that revenue stream is under real pressure, though. Courts have been pushing App Store fees toward 15%, and Services growth has already slowed to 10% last quarter. US consumer spending through the App Store has declined as well, a concrete sign that the commission engine is not as frictionless as it once appeared.

Sponsored

The Google search deal is one of the most important lines on Apple's income statement that most investors rarely think about. Google still pays roughly $20 billion a year to remain the default search engine in Safari, while Apple pays about $1 billion to Google for the Gemini models powering the new Siri. That asymmetry shows just how valuable Apple's distribution is, but it also creates a dependency that regulators are actively examining.

Daniel Mahncke and Shawn O'Malley land on a fair value near $250, built on a mid-20s multiple applied to roughly 10% earnings growth. The stock was trading well above that at the time of recording, so they set a buy target closer to $200. The core question hanging over that valuation is whether software agents eventually route around the App Store and thin out Apple's cut of the digital economy.

Mentioned: NKE, AAPL, MSFT, ADBE, AMZN, NVDA, NFLX, MELI, META, METAM, SPOT, GOOGL, GOOG, GGLBP, GOOGN