A year ago, the question was whether Warren Buffett’s conviction in Occidental Petroleum (NYSE: OXY) was reason enough to buy the stock. The answer, in hindsight, is yes, though the path forward is more complicated than the rear-view mirror suggests.
What Happened Over the Past Year
The shares traded at $45.47 on March 3, 2025. It closed at $53.68 on March 3, 2026, an 18.07% gain over 12 months. That return came despite benchmark West Texas Intermediate (WTI) crude falling from $71.53 in February 2025 to $57.97 at its December 2025 low — a punishing commodity backdrop that Occidental navigated through operational discipline rather than price tailwinds.
The company beat EPS estimates in every quarter of 2025. Q3 2025 delivered the most impressive beat at 29.90%, with adjusted EPS of $0.64 against a $0.4927 consensus. Full-year FY2025 EPS came in at $2.21 on revenue of $22.4 billion, with operating cash flow of $11.7 billion. The transformative move was the sale of OxyChem to Berkshire Hathaway, which closed January 2, 2026, and enabled $5.8 billion in debt reduction, bringing principal debt to $15 billion. CEO Vicki Hollub framed it plainly on the Q4 earnings call: “The portfolio we have today is the strongest Oxy’s ever had.”
The most recent catalyst was geopolitical. Occidental surged approximately 6% in pre-market trading on March 2, 2026, as WTI gained 6.5% and Brent rallied 7.5% on U.S.-Iran tensions and Strait of Hormuz supply fears. The company confirmed that its Middle East operations were unaffected.
Where Wall Street Stands Now
The analyst picture is cautious at current prices. The consensus analyst target price is $51.88, with 16 Hold ratings, six Buy ratings, and four Sell ratings across the coverage universe. With shares trading at $53.68, the average analyst effectively sees the stock as slightly overvalued at current levels.
The outlier is BMO Capital, which raised its price target to $60 from $48 on February 23, 2026, following Occidental’s Q4 earnings beat. Susquehanna had already raised its target to $55 following Q3 2025 results. Argus and Wall Street Zen both recently upgraded the stock to Hold, suggesting the broader analyst community is warming but not yet bullish.
What the Gap Between Price and Target Means Now
Occidental is trading above the Wall Street consensus target for the first time in the past year’s price trajectory. That doesn’t make it a sell, but it removes the easy margin of safety that existed when the stock was at $38 in May 2025.
The structural case remains intact. Hollub noted that 84% of Occidental’s total resource base breaks even below $50 per barrel, and the company expects free cash flow to improve by more than $1.2 billion in 2026. The quarterly dividend was raised 8% to $0.26 per share, with an ex-dividend date of March 10, 2026. But the macro risk is real: J.P. Morgan’s long-term Brent forecast for 2026 is $60 a barrel, and if the geopolitical premium from the Iran situation fades, the recent price surge could partially reverse.
Insider activity adds a nuanced signal. CEO Hollub was a net acquirer of 35,856 shares on February 18, 2026, joined by the COO and other senior executives. That is a meaningful signal of internal confidence at the $47 level.
The Verdict
Buying shares a year ago was the right call. The stock delivered an 18% return through a difficult oil price environment, driven by execution, deleveraging, and a transformative asset sale. From here, Wall Street’s Hold consensus reflects a stock that has priced in much of the good news. BMO’s $60 target offers a credible bull case, but it requires oil prices to hold and geopolitical premiums to persist. For investors already holding, the thesis remains sound. For those considering entry today, the risk-reward is narrower than it was 12 months ago.
Top Gaining Stocks
Top Losing Stocks