Kevin Warsh Just Pulled Off a Stock Market First, But History Says a Bigger Test Is Coming
This post may contain links from our sponsors and affiliates, and Flywheel Publishing may receive compensation for actions taken through them.
The stock market loves a fresh narrative. Each time a new Federal Reserve chair takes office, investors search for clues about the path ahead, whether that means lower rates, higher rates, easier money or tighter policy. Markets seldom deliver a clear verdict right away.
Kevin Warsh’s first week as Fed chair produced a result investors had never seen before. The open question is whether that opening tells us anything about what lies ahead, or whether history points investors toward other signals.
A Record-Breaking Start for a New Fed Chair
Data compiled by Carson Research show the S&P 500 rose on each of Warsh’s first seven trading days as Federal Reserve chair. No new Fed chair had ever opened with a longer winning streak.
The previous record belonged to William Miller, whose 1978 tenure began with five straight daily gains. Earlier chairs fared far less well:
- Two Fed chairs started with three-day winning streaks in 1948 and 1979
- Two began with two-day streaks in 1930 and 1970
- Three managed only a single up day
- Most new Fed chairs saw no winning streak at all
That makes Warsh’s opening a rare statistical outlier. Because investors parse every word a new chair says, markets have historically been slow to warm to a leadership change.
Warsh’s arrival coincided with enthusiasm for artificial intelligence, resilient economic growth, and hopes that interest rates would drift lower over time. Those forces combined to power a seven-session rally.
Does a Strong Start Predict Strong Returns?
Carson Research also examined market performance during the tenure of each Fed chair. The analysis finds little evidence that a strong opening streak leads to superior long-term returns.
Miller’s record start did not usher in one of the great market eras. The S&P 500 gained 19.1% during his tenure, well below the 47.8% median. His 13.2% annual average gain ranked among the strongest, but he served only 1.4 years.
William Martin recorded no up days to begin his term in 1951, yet presided over the largest median market gain at 295.8%. He held the post for nearly 20 years, which pulled his average annual return down to 7.8%.
Warsh’s predecessor, Jerome Powell, also posted zero gains in his first week, yet still produced a respectable 12.7% average annual return.
Investors eventually shift their attention from the individual at the top to the policy fundamentals underneath:
| What Matters Most | Why Investors Care |
| Inflation | Determines future rate decisions |
| Employment | Signals economic strength or weakness |
| Corporate earnings | Drives long-term stock valuations |
| Financial conditions | Influences borrowing and investment activity |
In other words, a new chair’s first market reaction usually matters less than the economic backdrop he or she inherits.
The Honeymoon Ends Quickly
The seven-day streak did not last. After Broadcom (NASDAQ:AVGO | AVGO Price Prediction) reported results on June 3, the S&P 500 fell 0.74%. The chipmaker posted second-quarter revenue of $22.19 billion, up 48% from a year earlier, which beat the $22.13 billion Wall Street had been looking for. Investors, however, focused on guidance that did not fully satisfy elevated expectations.
That reaction underscores Warsh’s challenge. Markets have grown used to near-flawless execution from AI-related companies, and with much of the S&P 500’s recent gain concentrated in technology and AI stocks, modest disappointments can trigger outsized moves.
Rate Hikes Replace the Rate-Cut Hopes
The hopes for lower rates have since reversed. The Fed raised rates by a quarter-point in September, the first increase since July 2023. That move lifted the target range to 3.75%-4%.
At its October 28 meeting, the committee held steady. Fed Governor Lisa Cook and one other official dissented in favor of a hike, making the vote 10-2. Market pricing tracked by the CME FedWatch tool showed a 79.6% chance of a hike at the December meeting, and Warsh declined to commit to one.
Inflation data then added fuel to those bets. The Bureau of Labor Statistics reported that the consumer price index rose 0.4% in October, above the 0.3% forecast by economists polled by Dow Jones, after a 0.6% increase in September. On November 10, the S&P 500 fell 0.38% to close at 7,520.93, and the index remains just 4.1% below a record high.
Warsh’s Bigger Test
Stocks extending a seven-day rally is the smaller question. The larger one is managing a monetary policy environment with competing risks:
- Inflation remains above the Fed’s long-run 2% target, and the October CPI came in hotter than forecast.
- The economy is growing at a healthy pace, yet unemployment is at 4.2% and hiring has been sluggish.
- AI-related capital spending continues at record levels.
- Equity valuations remain elevated compared with historical averages.
That balancing act will determine whether this opening streak is remembered as the start of a larger advance or as a historical footnote.
Key Takeaway
Warsh did set a mark no new Fed chair had reached before: seven consecutive market gains to open a tenure. History suggests those early sessions deserve limited weight. Long-term returns have depended far more on inflation, economic growth, earnings and monetary policy than on the market’s first reaction to a new chair.
The streak has given way to a harder backdrop. The honeymoon is over, and the Fed has moved from talk of cuts to talk of hikes, while investors weigh inflation, AI-driven market swings and a market that expects near-perfect results.
Editor’s note: Since this piece first ran, the Fed raised its benchmark rate by a quarter-point in September and held it steady on October 28 by a 10-2 vote, while a hotter October inflation report revived bets on a December hike. The S&P 500 closed at 7,520.93 on November 10, about 4.1% below its record high.
Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.




