The IRS Takes Up to 37% of These 5 Monthly Dividend Payers (Unless You Move Them)
This post may contain links from our sponsors and affiliates, and Flywheel Publishing may receive compensation for actions taken through them.
A monthly payer matches income to monthly bills, which is why retirees living off a portfolio like them. In a brokerage account, though, each of these five payments comes with an ordinary-income tax bill. A $500,000 portfolio split evenly across them returns about $52,800 a year. At the 24% bracket, roughly $12,700 of that goes to federal tax.
Roth Versus Taxable: $12,700 a Year at 24%
Qualified dividends are taxed at the 0%, 15%, or 20% capital gain rates. REIT and BDC payouts are generally ordinary dividends taxed at your marginal rate, so they gain the most from Roth placement. Qualified REIT dividends can also claim the deduction under 26 U.S.C. § 199A[1], which lowers the effective rate. The math below uses the full bracket rate.
| $500K Portfolio | Gross Income | Tax at 24% | Net Income |
|---|---|---|---|
| Taxable account | $52,800 | $12,700 | $40,100 |
| Roth IRA | $52,800 | $0 | $52,800 |
Over 10 years with no growth, the gap adds up to about $126,700. Yields below are based on Nov. 19 prices.
Realty Income
Realty Income (NYSE:O) is a net-lease REIT with 676 consecutive monthly dividends. Its $0.274 November payment sets the forward yield at 5.69%, which makes it a high-yield stock. Its 2026 AFFO guidance of $4.45 to $4.46 per share covers the $3.288 annualized dividend. The main risk is slow internal growth: same-store rent growth guidance is just 1.1% to 1.3%.
Main Street Capital
Main Street Capital (NYSE:MAIN | MAIN Price Prediction) is an internally managed BDC. BDCs lend borrowed money to private companies, so their payouts depend on how those loans perform. The regular $0.265 monthly payment yields 5.65%. Including the $0.30 quarterly supplementals, the trailing yield rises to an ultra-high 7.71%. Q3 adjusted DNII came in at $0.96 per share, against $0.795 in regular Q4 dividends. The main risk is credit quality: non-accruals reached 3.5% of portfolio at cost[2].
LTC Properties
LTC Properties (NYSE:LTC) is a healthcare REIT that owns seniors housing and skilled nursing properties. It has paid $0.19 every month since January 2020, for a high yield of 5.26%. Q3 core FFO of $0.71[3] per share covered the $0.57 quarterly payout. The main risk is its operating portfolio (SHOP), now 45% of annualized NOI, which ties results directly to occupancy and expenses.
AGNC Investment
AGNC Investment (NASDAQ:AGNC) is a mortgage REIT. In practice it is a leveraged bond portfolio, and its payout depends on interest spreads. The $0.12 monthly dividend has held since April 2020 and yields an ultra-high 18.39%. Q3 adjusted EPS was $0.37[4]. The main risk is book value: tangible book value fell 16.9%[4] to $7.13, with leverage at 7.9x.
PennantPark Floating Rate Capital
PennantPark Floating Rate Capital (NYSE:PFLT) is an externally managed BDC with 99% variable-rate debt. In mid-2026 it cut its monthly payout from $0.1025 to $0.0833 to bring it "better aligned with NII"[5]. The stock now yields an ultra-high 15.74%. The main risk is credit: non-accrual companies rose from 3 to 4[5].
What 37% Costs Versus 22%
The 37% rate is the highest bracket, and it applies only to income in that bracket. Most readers sit in lower brackets and pay correspondingly less. Higher earners may also owe the 3.8% net investment income tax above income thresholds that depend on filing status.
| Bracket | Taxable Net Income | The Yearly Roth Advantage |
|---|---|---|
| 22% | $41,200 | $11,600 |
| 24% | $40,100 | $12,700 |
| 32% | $35,900 | $16,900 |
| 37% | $33,300 | $19,500 |
Compounding Makes the Gap Permanent
Invest the $12,700 annual advantage at a conservative 4%, with no price appreciation assumed. After 10 years the Roth advantage reaches about $152,100, and after 20 years about $377,300. That is the permanent cost of owning these names outside a tax-free account.
Three Moves Before Your Next Filing
A Roth payout is tax free only if it meets the IRS rules for withdrawals. Under Publication 590-B (2025), it must come after the 5-year period that starts with your first Roth contribution year. It must also be made at age 59½ or older, because of disability, to a beneficiary after death, or for a first home up to a $10,000 lifetime limit. Roth IRAs also require no RMDs while the owner is alive.
- Get your Form 1099-DIV and add up the ordinary dividends from every REIT and BDC you own. Then apply your bracket.
- Start with AGNC and PFLT for the Roth conversion math, since their yields create the largest tax cost per dollar invested.
- Model a phased conversion that moves the ordinary-income payers into the Roth first and leaves qualified-dividend stocks in the taxable account.
Phased conversions work best in the quiet tax period after your last paycheck and before your first required withdrawal, a window we sized up in a free Roth guide: The Roth Window.
At any bracket, these five monthly payers lose thousands of dollars a year to tax in a brokerage account. Run the numbers on your own holdings before you file.
Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.







