4 High-Yield Dividend Stocks Retirees Should Think Twice About Owning
This post may contain links from our sponsors and affiliates, and Flywheel Publishing may receive compensation for actions taken through them.
All four household names below yield between about 5% and 6.3%. An advisor on The Clark Howard Podcast said in January that the S&P 500 yields only a little above 1%, so these payouts stand out. A high yield is only worth what the company can keep paying, though, and each of these four shows warning signs that income investors should consider before counting on that check.
Here’s the check: a dividend holds up when earnings and free cash flow (operating cash flow minus capital spending) cover it with room to spare and the company doesn’t have to borrow to pay it. If any of those three gives way, the payout is at risk.
United Parcel Service (UPS): Thin Cash Cushion Under a 6% Yield
United Parcel Service (NYSE:UPS | UPS Price Prediction) pays $1.64 per quarter, or $6.56 annualized. At a $106.25 share price, that works out to roughly 6.2%. Some of that yield comes from a falling stock: shares are down 34.85% over five years. The dividend itself has sat at $1.64 through every 2025 and 2026 payment, and the increases have stopped.
Cash coverage is the biggest problem. UPS expects 2026 dividend payments of about $5.4 billion[1] against adjusted free cash flow of about $6.1 billion, so roughly 89% of free cash flow goes to the dividend. Over the first nine months of 2026, operating cash flow minus capex came to $3.765 billion, short of the $4.064 billion paid out. In 2025 the figures were $4.765 billion against $5.398 billion. Volume is contracting too: U.S. average daily volume slid to 15,621K pieces[1]. Cash fell from $5.887 billion to $4.653 billion[2] in six months, and interest expense was up 14.3%.
Among the positives, adjusted EPS guidance of about $7.28[1] covers the dividend, and U.S. revenue per piece rose 6.1%[1]. The payout needs stable volumes and free cash flow growth beyond $6.1 billion to feel safe. A retiree who has 1,000 shares takes in $6,560 a year that depends on that happening.
Pfizer (PFE): Free Cash Flow Falling Short of the Payout
At Pfizer (NYSE:PFE) the dividend of $0.43 quarterly comes to about 6.3% at $27.43. The stock has gained 17.45% this year but is still down 29.26% over five years.
On adjusted EPS guidance of $2.95 to $3.05[3], the payout ratio is a comfortable 57% to 58%. Free cash flow tells a less comfortable story. In 2025 it came to $9.076 billion against $9.771 billion in dividends. In the first nine months of 2026 it reached $7.283 billion against $7.347 billion paid. Pfizer’s free cash flow yield of 5.81% is below its dividend yield. Net debt to EBITDA stands at 2.76, and the company has made no buybacks this year and plans none. Paxlovid sales fell 63%[3], and a $3.8 billion[4] impairment hit the second quarter.
The non-COVID business grew 7%[3] operationally, led by Eliquis, up 25%. Those growth drugs have to outrun the COVID decline and a roughly $1.1 billion[3] hit from generic competition.
Kraft Heinz (KHC): A Yield Propped Up by a Sliding Stock Price
The dividend at Kraft Heinz (NASDAQ:KHC) is $0.40 quarterly, which comes to about 6.3% at $25.42. The stock has lost 51.63% over ten years, and that decline is a big reason the yield looks so high. This isn’t the first cut: the quarterly dividend went from $0.625 in 2018 to $0.40 by 2019, a 36% reduction.
The dividend eats 75% to 77% of guided adjusted EPS, at a time when constant-currency adjusted operating income is expected to fall 16% to 18%[5] and organic sales to drop 0.5% to 1.25%. Organic sales in North America fell 3.4%[5]. A $7.4 billion impairment drove trailing GAAP EPS to -$2.93, and the planned split into two companies is on hold.
Cash flow is the bright spot. In 2025, operating cash flow of $4.462 billion easily covered capex and $1.898 billion in dividends, and the company has paid back $3.982 billion[5] of debt so far this year. The next thing to look for is North American sales steadying.
AT&T (T): Borrowing Climbs While the Dividend Stays Frozen
AT&T (NYSE:T) pays $1.11 annualized, which comes to about 5.0% at $22.34. Shares fell 8.32% over the past year. The payout has been flat since 2022, when AT&T cut the quarterly dividend from $0.52 to $0.2775.
The balance sheet is where the risk shows. Total debt reached $159.6 billion[6], up from $144 billion[7] a quarter earlier, after the EchoStar spectrum deal. Net debt to adjusted EBITDA rose to 3.13x[6] from 2.68x[7]. AT&T doesn’t expect to get back to its 2.5x target until 2029. Third-quarter free cash flow dropped 5.9%[6], and EBITDA from the legacy business is expected to turn negative after 2027[7].
AT&T has the strongest coverage of the four: the dividend is about 46% of guided adjusted EPS of ~$2.40[6], and free cash flow is guided to $18 billion+ this year. Management has also committed to keeping the dividend through 2028. The debt still needs to come down.
How to Spot a Yield Trap Yourself
Compare free cash flow to dividends paid, check whether a declining stock is driving the yield, and keep an eye on debt and GAAP earnings next to the adjusted numbers (we pulled the full set of warning signs into a free dividend trap guide here: seven signs a big yield is about to be cut). When a dividend gets cut, the stock usually drops as well, so retirees can lose income and principal at once. A high yield alone should never justify a purchase.
Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.







