NVDY Investors Chose Monthly Income Over 854% Returns; Here’s What That Trade Cost Them

YieldMax NVDA Option Income Strategy ETF (NYSEARCA:NVDY) monetizes NVIDIA‘s (NASDAQ:NVDA | NVDA Price Prediction) volatility through a synthetic covered-call strategy, converting option premiums into weekly cash distributions. The fund once ranked among the highest-yielding listed ETFs, but the critical question is whether those distributions represent durable income or a slow-motion return of your own capital. The answer, based on the May 2026 fact sheet and recent distribution data, is more nuanced than the headline yield suggests.

How NVDY Manufactures Its Yield

NVDY holds a small slice of NVIDIA stock (11.5% of net assets) and uses options to synthetically replicate exposure, then sells short-dated calls at strikes near NVIDIA’s spot price to harvest premium. The rest of the portfolio, over 80% in Treasury Bills and a First American Government Obligations money market position, sits as collateral and earns short-term interest.

The income you receive blends option premium (which scales with implied volatility) and T-Bill yield. When NVIDIA trades around 40 vol, premiums are rich and distributions swell. When volatility compresses or NVIDIA rallies past the short strike, the math turns against holders. NVDY caps upside at the sold strike, meaning if NVIDIA rises 15% in a month, the fund captures 3% to 5% while the call is assigned or rolled at a loss.

The Distribution Trend Tells the Real Story

NVDY’s payout history is the single most important safety signal. In March 2024, the fund paid $2.62 per share in a single month. By mid-2024, monthly distributions were still running above $1.00. By the July 2, 2026 ex-date, and the weekly payment was $0.0984, with recent weeks clustering between $0.08 and $0.15. Even annualized across 52 weekly payments, the current run-rate falls well short of the 2024 pace.

That decline reflects two forces. NVIDIA’s realized volatility has moderated as the stock matured into a mega-cap, compressing the premiums NVDY can harvest. Meanwhile, the fund had to fund several distributions during periods when NVIDIA rallied through the short strike, which erodes NAV to make the payment whole. NAV erosion is the covered-call ETF‘s silent tax: the yield looks fine on paper, but the price per share drifts lower over time.

Total Return, Not Just Yield

NVIDIA itself returned roughly 24% over the past year and more than 854% over five years. NVDY, by design, cannot match that because every meaningful upside move is capped. Investors who bought NVDY at inception seeking “Nvidia income” have collected large distributions but watched share price decline while NVIDIA rallied. The tradeoff is real cash today for surrendered compounding tomorrow.

The 1.09% expense ratio compounds that drag. On $1.37 billion in net assets, that is meaningful friction versus simply holding Nvidia and selling covered calls in a personal account.

The Verdict

The distribution mechanics work. The Treasury collateral is safe, and premium income will keep flowing as long as NVIDIA trades with reasonable volatility. What is at risk is the size of the check. Distributions have already fallen sharply from 2024 highs, and there is no structural reason to expect a return to those levels absent a fresh volatility regime.

For investors who understand they are trading upside for cash flow and are comfortable with a slowly eroding NAV, NVDY works as an income sleeve. For anyone treating it as a proxy for owning NVIDIA, the past year has been an expensive lesson. A lower-yielding alternative such as a broad dividend growth ETF, or simply holding NVIDIA and selling covered calls selectively, will usually produce better total returns.

Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.