A 12% Yield From Gold? Here’s How This Monthly Income ETF Does It

Gold has always occupied a strange place in a portfolio. Unlike stocks, its returns aren’t tied to corporate earnings or dividends. Unlike bonds, there is no contractual interest payment or principal repayment. Instead, gold tends to respond to a different set of structural drivers, including real interest rates, inflation expectations, currency movements, central-bank demand, geopolitical uncertainty, and investor demand for a monetary safe haven.

That independence is one of the reasons investors use gold alongside stocks and bonds. It’s also the source of one of the most common criticisms of owning it: gold produces no cash flow. An ounce sitting in a vault doesn’t pay a dividend, coupon, or rent. If you want spendable income from it, you ordinarily need to sell some of your position.

The NEOS Gold High Income ETF (IAUI) attempts to change that equation. It maintains gold exposure while using options to turn some of the asset’s volatility into monthly distributions, currently producing a distribution rate of 11.98%.

How IAUI Generates Income From Gold

IAUI obtains its underlying exposure through spot gold ETFs. That gives shareholders exposure to movements in the price of physical gold without requiring them to buy, transport, insure, or store bullion themselves.

The income comes from an actively managed options overlay. IAUI can sell and purchase calls and puts on gold ETFs. That flexibility allows the managers to construct multi-leg option positions rather than relying exclusively on a mechanical covered call written against 100% of the portfolio.

Selling options generates premiums, while purchasing other options can reshape the resulting payoff. For example, buying an option can restore some exposure beyond a particular strike or limit risk created elsewhere in the options position. The exact trade-off depends on the strikes, expirations, option types, and combination of contracts used.

That gives IAUI more flexibility than simply selling a call against every ounce of gold exposure each month. But the underlying economics remain the same. The fund is monetizing some of gold’s volatility to generate cash flow, and option premiums aren’t free money. Depending on how the positions are structured, the strategy can surrender some potential gains.

A 12% Distribution Comes With Trade-Offs

IAUI currently has an 11.98% distribution rate and pays monthly, which is substantial for an asset that inherently produces no income. The strategy is relatively expensive, however. IAUI charges a 0.79% expense ratio, considerably more than the cheapest long-only spot gold ETFs. Investors therefore need the options management to generate enough value to overcome both its fees and any upside sacrificed through the derivatives strategy.

There is also an interesting tax component. IAUI’s September Section 19(a)-1 notice estimated that approximately 86% of its latest distribution consisted of return of capital (ROC). ROC generally reduces an investor’s adjusted cost basis rather than creating an immediate tax liability. That can defer taxation until the position is sold or the cost basis reaches zero, after which additional ROC is generally treated as capital gain. The 19(a)-1 classification is preliminary, though, and final tax treatment comes on Form 1099-DIV.

The more important criticism is total return. Since inception, IAUI has lagged comparable long-only spot gold ETFs on a cumulative total-return basis. That’s the opportunity cost I’d expect investors to watch with any options-income strategy. The monthly distributions are much larger, but the options overlay and higher expenses can reduce participation in gold’s appreciation.

That makes IAUI easier for me to understand as an income vehicle than as the most efficient way to accumulate gold. If you’re reinvesting every monthly distribution anyway, a cheaper spot gold ETF gives you purer exposure without deliberately converting part of the asset’s volatility into cash.

For someone who specifically wants monthly income, however, IAUI addresses gold’s biggest structural drawback. It takes an asset with no native cash flow and uses derivatives to manufacture one. The trade-off is that investors shouldn’t expect a 12% distribution and full participation in gold’s returns at the same time.

Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.