At 66, He Is Leaving Advantage After Medigap Says No. Original Medicare Has No Annual Out-of-Pocket Limit, and One Bad Year Can Cost $14,000
This post may contain links from our sponsors and affiliates, and Flywheel Publishing may receive compensation for actions taken through them.
Insurers are cutting Medicare Advantage plans and counties again for 2027, and the scale is striking. Eighteen payers are leaving the MA market entirely, and at least 3.8 million enrollees will need new coverage for 2027. In 181 counties, no general Medicare Advantage drug plan will be available at all, up from 67 such counties in 2026. Against that backdrop, a 66-year-old who joined Advantage at 65 sees his plan continuing but its network contracting. He applies for Medigap Plan G and is denied based on his health history.
He leaves Advantage anyway, assuming his 20% share must stop at some ceiling. It does not. Original Medicare carries no annual out-of-pocket maximum for enrollees without supplemental coverage.
This risk is narrow but real. It applies to Advantage members past their first-year trial right whose plans are continuing and who live in states that let Medigap insurers screen applicants based on health. If an Advantage plan leaves Medicare or stops serving your area, federal rules generally give you a guaranteed-issue right to buy certain Medigap policies without medical underwriting. His plan is staying, so that protection does not apply to him.
20%, With No Annual Limit
For most Part B services, he pays the $283 annual deductible in 2026 and then 20% of the Medicare-approved amount, with no upper bound. Advantage plans, by contrast, must set an annual maximum on covered Part A and Part B cost sharing. Once a member hits that ceiling, the plan covers 100% of in-network services for the rest of the year. Original Medicare on its own has no such ceiling.
The services that drive the largest exposure are all outpatient: chemotherapy and other Part B drugs, outpatient surgery, imaging, specialist visits, and physical therapy. A single cancer diagnosis can generate all five in the same calendar year, with no mechanism to stop the 20% from compounding.
How One Bad Year Reaches $14,000
Say Medicare approves $70,000 of Part B services during a year of treatment. His 20% share comes to $14,000. Add the $283 deductible, and he owes $14,283 before a single hospital bill arrives. That total comes on top of the $202.90 standard monthly Part B premium every enrollee pays in 2026, which adds another $2,435 over the year.
A hospital stay layers on more. Part A charges a $1,736 deductible per benefit period, and a new benefit period opens after 60 consecutive days out of the hospital. Two admissions spaced far enough apart in one calendar year therefore trigger two separate deductibles. Adding just one admission to the outpatient scenario above pushes his total to $16,019.
| 2026 Cost Item | His Cost Without Medigap | Plan G Covers It? |
|---|---|---|
| Part B deductible | $283 | No |
| 20% of $70,000 in Part B services | $14,000 | Yes |
| Part A deductible, per benefit period | $1,736 | Yes |
| Hospital days 61 to 90 | $434 per day | Yes |
With Plan G, his share of that bad year would shrink to the $283 Part B deductible. The cost of losing Plan G access easily exceeds the cost of the network inconvenience he was trying to escape.
Why One Denial Should Not Settle It
He joined Advantage at his first eligibility, so his federal trial right to return to Original Medicare with guaranteed Medigap access typically lasted only the first 12 months. Past that window, Medigap insurers may screen him based on health unless a separate guaranteed-issue right or a state-level protection applies. New York and Connecticut offer guaranteed issue year-round; Massachusetts and Maine provide broader rights than federal law requires. Getting a written denial from one insurer is not the end of the inquiry.
Worth noting: CMS proposed but declined to finalize a Special Enrollment Period that would have let Advantage members switch plans when an in-network provider left the network mid-year. That proposal was dropped from the 2027 final rule, leaving members without that safeguard and making the calculus here harder to resolve through a simple plan switch.
What Original Medicare Alone Still Gives Him
Without Medigap, he still has Part A hospital coverage and Part B outpatient coverage. He can see any provider nationwide who accepts Medicare, and he can pair that with a standalone Part D plan for drug coverage. What he gives up is any annual ceiling on his costs.
A 66-year-old with substantial savings may conclude the provider freedom is worth absorbing greater financial risk. Someone expecting intensive medical use should compare that uncapped exposure directly against the out-of-pocket maximum and network rules of the Advantage plans available to him. One detail that catches retirees off guard: an Advantage plan’s medical out-of-pocket maximum excludes Part D drug spending, and noncovered or out-of-network care may follow different cost rules (the surcharges and coverage gaps that surprise beneficiaries are detailed in our free Medicare guide, here). For covered Part A and Part B services subject to the plan’s in-network maximum, there is a ceiling. If he leaves Advantage now and develops a significant health condition later, future Medigap applications will likely face underwriting again.
Three Moves to Make Before You Disenroll
- Get written decisions from at least two more Medigap insurers before dropping Advantage. Check your state insurance department’s website for protections stronger than the federal baseline.
- Cost your worst year. Find your plan’s in-network out-of-pocket maximum in its 2027 Annual Notice of Change and compare it with the uncapped Part B exposure you would carry under Original Medicare alone.
- If the network is the problem, consider switching Advantage plans instead. During open enrollment, October 15 through December 7, look for a PPO that covers out-of-network care at a higher cost-share rather than excluding it. Changes take effect January 1.
Advantage limits where he gets care. Original Medicare removes that restriction, but without Medigap, his costs have no yearly ceiling. One year of chemotherapy is enough to illustrate the difference.
Editor’s note: This article was updated to include the 2027 Medicare Advantage market context, specifically that 18 payers are exiting the program entirely, at least 3.8 million enrollees will need new coverage, and 181 counties will have no general Medicare Advantage drug plan available, up from 67 in 2026. It also adds that CMS declined to finalize a proposed Special Enrollment Period tied to mid-year provider network departures.
Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.








