At 71, She Chose Humana for the Part B Giveback in Her Social Security Check. For 2027, Humana Will Cut or Eliminate It for 62% of Those Members
This post may contain links from our sponsors and affiliates, and Flywheel Publishing may receive compensation for actions taken through them.
Imagine a 71-year-old retiree who picked a Humana (NYSE:HUM | HUM Price Prediction) Medicare Advantage plan specifically for its Part B giveback. The giveback works exactly as the name suggests: the plan covers part of her Medicare Part B premium. Because that premium normally gets withheld from her Social Security payment before it hits her bank account, a giveback means more money deposited each month.
For 2027, Humana is shrinking or eliminating that benefit for 62% of the members it affects. Her plan may still show a $0 monthly premium on the Annual Notice of Change, while the boost to her Social Security deposit quietly shrinks. A plan with a $0 premium can still leave her with less real income than it did a year ago.
How the Giveback Reaches Your Bank Account
Some Medicare Advantage plans route part of their federal rebate toward paying a share of the member’s Part B premium. Social Security then withholds a smaller amount, so the net deposit rises. The confirmed 2026 standard Part B premium is $202.90, up from $185.00 in 2025. For members who pay Medicare directly rather than through Social Security withholding, the giveback shows up as a lower bill instead of a larger deposit.
Plans direct only a fraction of their rebate money this way. A MedPAC analysis estimates that conventional Medicare Advantage plans put about 9% of those rebate dollars toward Part B premium reductions in 2026, compared with 40% toward lower Part A and Part B cost sharing and 25% toward supplemental extras such as dental, vision, and hearing. For 2027, Humana chose to trim or eliminate the giveback for a substantial share of its affected membership.
Why Humana Is Pulling Back for 2027
Humana designed its 2027 plans with wider margins in mind. On its July 29 earnings call, CFO Celeste Mellet cited benefit adjustments and targeted plan exits, with the exits alone expected to affect about 600,000 members. Humana had already signaled that Medicare’s 2.48% net payment increase for 2027 fell short of its medical-cost pressures, making benefit changes a central part of the response. A Leerink Partners analysis of Medicare Plan Finder data confirmed that the Part B giveback reductions hit 62% of Humana’s affected members, while UnitedHealthcare’s comparable cuts landed on just 7% of its members.
What a $50 Giveback Loss Does to a $2,000 Check
Consider a simplified example: a $50 monthly giveback on a $2,000 gross benefit. The Social Security Administration officially announced a 3.6% COLA for 2027 on October 14, 2026, the largest increase in four years. At that rate, the $2,000 gross benefit grows by $72. The table below holds the Part B deduction at the confirmed 2026 figure of $202.90 because CMS has not yet set the official 2027 premium. The 2026 Medicare Trustees Report projects that premium at approximately $209.50, though the final number will not be confirmed until CMS makes its annual announcement, expected in mid-November 2026.
| Year (monthly, per person) | Gross Benefit | Giveback | Part B Deducted | Net Deposit |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026 | $2,000 | $50 | $152.90 | $1,847.10 |
| 2027 (giveback removed) | $2,072 | $0 | $202.90 | $1,869.10 |
The official 3.6% COLA adds $72 to the gross benefit, but the disappearance of the $50 giveback cancels out most of that gain, leaving a net increase of just $22 in this example. Over a full year, losing a $50 monthly giveback amounts to $600 in foregone income.
Traps Hiding Behind the Renewal Button
- Auto-renewal locks in the new version. If she does nothing, she stays in the 2027 plan with whatever giveback and formulary changes come with it. Open enrollment runs October 15, 2026 to December 7, 2026.
- Going back to Original Medicare can make the Medigap side harder at 71. Her one-time Medigap open enrollment window closed years ago. In most states, insurers can review her health history and charge more or deny coverage. New York, Connecticut, Massachusetts, and Maine have broader protections.
- The out-of-pocket maximum leaves out drugs. Part D spending sits outside the Advantage cap. The Part D cap moves to $2,400 in 2027, up from $2,100.
- Networks are shrinking across the industry. UnitedHealth Group (NYSE:UNH) unit UnitedHealthcare and CVS Health (NYSE:CVS) unit Aetna have both said their 2027 Medicare Advantage plans will offer more limited provider networks.
For a member in good health whose primary reason for choosing Humana was the giveback, the most practical step is comparing other Advantage plans in her county that still offer a giveback and keep her current doctors in network. (The giveback is one of several Medicare line items that can shift against a retiree without obvious warning. We mapped out the rest, from IRMAA surcharges to coverage gaps, in a free guide: Medicare’s Hidden Bills.)
Three Moves to Make Before December 7
- Find the giveback line on your Annual Notice of Change. It usually appears as a “Part B premium reduction.” Compare the 2027 amount with what you receive now, then multiply the monthly difference by 12 to see the full-year impact.
- Use Medicare Plan Finder to compare plans in your ZIP code. Open the plan details and look for the Part B premium reduction line, then weigh the giveback alongside dental coverage, full-year drug costs, and whether your doctors are in network.
- Confirm whether Humana is renewing your plan or dropping it. If your plan is among the exits, federal rules grant a guaranteed-issue right to buy certain Medigap plans without medical underwriting for a limited time, an important window that closes quickly.
Editor’s note: This article has been updated to reflect the Social Security Administration’s official 2027 COLA of 3.6%, announced October 14, 2026, replacing the earlier estimate of 3.5%. The example table has been revised accordingly, and the article now includes the 2026 Medicare Trustees Report projection of approximately $209.50 for the 2027 Part B premium, pending CMS’s official mid-November announcement.
Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.








