‘I Bet You You Could Be Done With This Guy’: Ramsey to Woman Who Owes Her Ex $70,000
This post may contain links from our sponsors and affiliates, and Flywheel Publishing may receive compensation for actions taken through them.
Dave Ramsey told a woman owing her ex $70,000 to buy the debt out early. “If you could get 45 together by next spring and make that offer, I bet you you could be done with this guy,” he said on the October 7, 2026 episode of The Ramsey Show.
The caller, Jennifer from Columbus, owes her ex $1,000 a month. She also owes him a $70,000 lump sum due at the end of five years, and four years remain.
Jennifer has $15,000 in a CD, saves $1,200 a month, and takes home about $9,000 a month. Ramsey told her to buy the debt out early at a discount instead of waiting for the due date.
A lot rides on the price. Every dollar under $70,000 is a dollar she keeps. If she opens too low, though, a good attorney will turn down the offer and she’ll have lost months of negotiating time.
Ramsey Has the Right Strategy and the Wrong Price
The buyout idea is sound. The $40,000 to $45,000 price only works if the seller doesn’t run the numbers.
Ramsey explained the idea behind it, present value: money owed in the future is worth less than money today. He set “the discount rate” at “10%, meaning I can invest the money and make 10% on my money.”
In his seven-year example, he said of $70,000, “today’s valuation of that is 35,000.” That roughly checks out; the precise present value is about $35,900.
Jennifer has four years left. Even at Ramsey’s own 10% rate, her $70,000 is worth about $47,800 today. So his $45,000 offer is already below his own math.
Now use rates someone can actually get without risk. The 10-year Treasury yield hit 5.3% on October 5. At that rate, the $70,000 is worth about $56,900.
At the FDIC’s national average 12-month CD rate of about 1.7%, it’s worth about $65,400.
Ramsey prices the discount off a 10% return. In the same call he told her, “I would not use an investment account. I would just use a High Yield savings.” He wants the ex to accept a discount based on a return Jennifer was told not to pursue.
Ramsey also said, “I’m not sure that his financial advisor or his attorney or he are sophisticated enough to grasp that concept that I just covered with you.” Any advisor who does understand present value will use safe rates and counter somewhere in the $50,000s.
What Your Ex Can Earn on Cash Sets the Deal
One number decides whether the offer works: the return the person you owe could earn on the money in the meantime.
Suppose the ex has credit card debt at 24%. For him, cash today beats cash in four years, so $45,000 now could work. If he’s comfortable with Treasuries, he should hold out for something close to $56,900. By next spring, less than four years are left, so the debt’s value at safe rates rises.
From Jennifer’s side, the math is strong at almost any realistic price. Paying $45,000 to clear $70,000 works out to a guaranteed return of about 12% a year.
At $40,000, it’s about 15%. No savings account comes close to either figure.
At $1,200 a month, growing $15,000 to $45,000 takes 25 months. To reach that by spring, she’d need to put toward much more of her take-home pay.
How to Price an Early Payoff on Any Lump-Sum Debt
- Run present value at three rates. Divide the lump sum by (1 + rate), raised to the number of years left. Use a high rate like 10%, the current 10-year Treasury yield and the average CD rate. That gives you a negotiating range.
- Separate your opening offer from your walk-away price. Open near the high-rate number. Your ceiling is the value at what your own cash actually makes. For Jennifer, any deal under about $65,400 beats leaving the money in an average CD.
- Get it into the court order. Have the divorce attorney amend the decree. Make sure it says whether the $1,000 monthly payments end with the buyout or continue.
- Shop for better than the average rate while you save. The national 12-month CD average is about 1.7%. Many high-yield accounts and short-term Treasuries pay far more, and every point you earn speeds up the buyout.
A lump-sum debt is worth whatever the safe interest rate says it is today, so price your offer from that number.
Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.








