Fidelity, Schwab, and Vanguard Will Each Calculate Your RMD for You. None of Them Counts the IRA at the Other Two Firms, and the 25% Penalty on the Shortfall Is Yours
This post may contain links from our sponsors and affiliates, and Flywheel Publishing may receive compensation for actions taken through them.
Consider a 75-year-old retiree, a composite, with three traditional IRAs: one at Fidelity, one at Charles Schwab (NYSE:SCHW | SCHW Price Prediction), and one at Vanguard. Every January, each firm posts a required minimum distribution figure for her. All three numbers are accurate. She can still come up thousands of dollars short.
Each custodian calculates the RMD only for the account it holds. The IRS, however, judges the total. If she treats any one firm’s figure as her complete obligation, the federal excise tax on the gap runs 25%, and the law places that liability squarely on the account owner. None of the three firms shares it.
Each Custodian Sees Only Its Own Slice
IRS Publication 590-B places the duty on the owner. For an individual retirement account, “you or your trustee must figure the required minimum distribution for each year.” The trustee knows one balance. The account owner is the only party who sees all of them.
The aggregation rule operates in two steps. First, “you must figure the required distribution separately for each IRA.” Then you must withdraw the combined total, which you “can, however, withdraw … from one IRA or from more than one IRA.” That flexibility is genuinely useful, but it also makes it easy to assume one firm’s withdrawal covered the whole obligation.
Custodians do report to the IRS. On Form 5498, Box 11 must be checked to confirm an RMD is required for the following year. Boxes 12a and 12b, which show the deadline and the computed RMD amount for that account, are optional fields custodians may choose to fill in. Either way, the IRS receives three separate single-account reports, and the job of adding them together falls entirely to you.
How a $16,260 Shortfall Becomes a $4,065 Bill
Assume our retiree was born in 1951, so she turns 75 in 2026. The Uniform Lifetime Table divisor at age 75 is 24.6. Dividing each December 31, 2025, balance by that divisor produces the following:
| Custodian | 12/31/2025 Balance | 2026 RMD |
|---|---|---|
| Fidelity | $400,000 | $16,260.16 |
| Schwab | $250,000 | $10,162.60 |
| Vanguard | $150,000 | $6,097.56 |
| Total required | $800,000 | $32,520.33 |
Say she sets up an automatic withdrawal at Fidelity for the number Fidelity showed her and leaves the other two accounts alone. She is short $16,260.16. At 25%, the excise tax comes to $4,065.04.
That penalty lands on top of ordinary income tax. She still has to withdraw the missing $16,260 and pay federal income tax on it at her marginal rate, plus any applicable state tax depending on where she lives. The excise tax and the income tax are two separate bills.
Section 4974 Cuts the Penalty to 10% for Quick Fixes
The SECURE 2.0 Act cut the old 50% penalty to 25%. It also added an automatic discount under 26 U.S.C. §4974(e): if you take the missed amount and file a return reporting the tax within the “correction window,” the rate drops to 10%. For our retiree, that brings the bill down to about $1,626.
The correction window closes on the earliest of three events: the IRS mails a notice of deficiency, the tax is assessed, or the last day of the second taxable year after the year of the shortfall. The corrective distribution must come “from the same plan to which such tax relates.”
A separate provision, §4974(d), gives the IRS authority to waive the penalty entirely when the shortfall was “due to reasonable error” and “reasonable steps are being taken to remedy the shortfall.” Taxpayers request the waiver on Form 5329 with a brief written explanation. Relying on a custodian’s single-account figure qualifies as the kind of good-faith mistake the waiver process was designed for. The key is catching the error and correcting it promptly.
This cross-custodian gap is exactly the kind of quiet IRS rule that drains six figures from retirement accounts before anyone notices. We listed it alongside eight others in a free tax trap guide for retirees.
Three Moves Before December 31, 2026
For anyone past their first RMD year, the 2026 withdrawal must be completed by December 31. Someone turning 73 this year may wait until April 1 of next year, but doing so stacks two RMDs onto one tax return.
- Build your own total. Collect every traditional, SEP, and SIMPLE IRA balance as of December 31, 2025. Divide each by your divisor and add the results. Compare that combined figure to what each firm individually reports.
- Consolidate. Moving IRAs into a single institution through trustee-to-trustee transfers means one custodian calculates the full RMD. It also reduces the annual check to one statement rather than three.
- Keep the categories straight. Aggregation applies only to your own IRAs. Each 401(k) requires its own RMD from that plan. Inherited IRAs follow beneficiary rules and cannot be aggregated with the owner’s own accounts unless the inheritance came from a spouse.
The most common mistake is reading “Your RMD” on one firm’s portal as the total obligation. When accounts are spread across multiple custodians and balances are substantial, a tax professional reviewing your combined total each year is a worthwhile safeguard.
Editor’s note: This update clarifies that Form 5498 Boxes 12a and 12b are optional fields for custodians (only Box 11 is required), strengthening the article’s core point that the IRS receives only single-account figures from each firm; it also distinguishes the automatic 10% correction-window rate under IRC §4974(e) from the separate full-waiver authority under §4974(d).
Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.








