Why a 63-Year-Old With $1.2 Million in a 401(k) and No Pension Should Be Living on the IRA First and Claiming Social Security Last
This post may contain links from our sponsors and affiliates, and Flywheel Publishing may receive compensation for actions taken through them.
One retiree matches this profile: born in 1963, single, newly retired, with $1.2 million in a 401(k) and no pension. She needs about $80,000 a year to live on. The common instinct is to claim Social Security right away and leave the nest egg alone.
The tax code rewards the opposite order. If she lives on 401(k) withdrawals from 63 to 70 and then starts the largest Social Security check available to her, she pays less federal tax every year after 70 and faces smaller required withdrawals later.
Why Claiming Early Feels Like the Safe Move
The case for claiming early is reasonable. A government check means smaller portfolio withdrawals, and many retirees would rather have money now than a promise. The 2026 Trustees Report projects that the combined Social Security trust funds will run dry in the third quarter of 2034[1]. After that, incoming payroll taxes would cover 83%[1] of scheduled benefits.
Run the numbers year by year, though, and claiming early costs her more in tax.
Seven Years of Withdrawals Taxed Below 11%
Because she was born in 1963, her required minimum distributions (RMDs) start at age 75 under 26 U.S.C. § 401(a)(9)(C)(v)(II), with her first RMD year in 2038. Until then she can decide how much to withdraw each year.
Say she takes $80,000 from the 401(k) in 2026. She deducts the $16,100 single standard deduction, which leaves $63,900 of taxable income. The first $12,400 is taxed at 10%, income up to $50,400 at 12%, and only the rest at 22%. Her federal tax comes to $8,770, an effective rate of about 11%.
She has no Social Security income yet, so none of her benefits are being taxed. Her income also stays under the $109,000[2] single IRMAA threshold (the income line where Medicare premium surcharges begin). That matters even before 65, because Medicare sets premiums using income from two years earlier. Her 2026 income will set the premiums she pays at 65. Above that line, the 2026 Part B premium rises from $202.90[2] to $284.10 a month.
How Waiting Until 70 Cuts Her Tax Bill
Assume her full-retirement-age benefit at 67 is $3,000 a month. Claiming at 63 cuts that to $2,250. Waiting until 70 raises it to $3,720, or $17,640 more per year before cost-of-living raises. For reference, the 2026 COLA was 2.8%[3].
Under 26 U.S.C. § 86(a)(2)[4], up to 85%[4] of benefits become taxable once “provisional income” (other income plus half of your benefits) passes the base amounts in the statute. Those base amounts have never been indexed for inflation. Here is how each path looks at 70 if she spends the same $80,000, using 2026 brackets:
| At age 70 | Claimed at 63 | Claimed at 70 |
|---|---|---|
| Social Security | Smaller benefit | $44,640 |
| 401(k) withdrawal | Larger withdrawal | $35,360 |
| Taxable Social Security | $22,950 | $24,628 |
| Federal income tax | $7,879 | $5,018.56 |
The early claimant pays about $2,860 more each year, because her larger 401(k) withdrawals push dollars into the 22% bracket. The age-65 extra standard deduction would lower both bills.
RMDs widen the gap. The early claimant drew less from her 401(k) in her 60s, so she reaches 75 with a bigger balance. The first-year divisor at 75 is 24.6, which means every $100,000 still in the account forces out $4,065. An untouched $1.2 million would force out about $48,780. Missing an RMD triggers the 25% excise tax on the shortfall.
Who Should Still Claim Social Security Early
Claiming early still fits retirees in poor health, those without savings to cover seven years of spending, and anyone whose IRA is small enough that a bad market could empty it. For married couples, the higher earner’s delay also raises the survivor benefit, which strengthens the case for waiting.
State taxes can change these results. Many states exempt Social Security but tax IRA withdrawals, while states with no income tax take neither.
Three Moves Worth Weighing Before December 31
- Rolling the 401(k) into an IRA. RMDs from 401(k) plans must be taken separately from each plan. IRA owners can take the combined total from one or more IRAs.
- Use the room left under the IRMAA line. With $80,000 already withdrawn, she has about $29,000 of space below the 2026 threshold. A conversion of that size shrinks the account that will generate future RMDs, and Roth IRAs require no RMDs while the owner is alive. Conversions count for the year only if completed by December 31.
- Plan for gifts from the IRA at 70½. Qualified charitable distributions, which go straight from the IRA to a charity and stay out of taxable income, are capped at $111,000 for 2026.
Choosing the withdrawal order affects taxes for decades, so it’s worth running these numbers with a fiduciary advisor or CPA before the first withdrawal.
Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.








