The Waltons Won a Tax Court Case in 2000 That Lets a Family Pass a Stock’s Growth to Heirs While Reporting a Taxable Gift of Nearly $0. The Trust It Approved Is Still Legal
This post may contain links from our sponsors and affiliates, and Flywheel Publishing may receive compensation for actions taken through them.
A 68-year-old widow owns $2 million of a single growth stock, part of an estate worth about $20 million. That puts her above the 2026 basic exclusion amount of $15,000,000. Any gain the stock makes from here lands in an estate that is already over the line.
Her attorney sets up a two-year trust. She moves the stock in and holds the right to two annual payments of $1,075,609. Her Form 709 reports a taxable gift of about $1.41. If the stock gains 20% a year, her children end the two years owning $513,660 of it outright, and none of that growth ever counts against her exemption.
The structure is a grantor retained annuity trust, or GRAT. The version she used exists today because a Walmart heir took the IRS to court and won.
How Audrey Walton Beat the IRS With Walmart Stock
Audrey J. Walton held more than seven million shares of Walmart (NASDAQ:WMT | WMT Price Prediction). In 1993 she put about 3.6 million shares into each of two GRATs. Each trust was worth just over $100 million and paid her 49.35% of its starting value in year one and 59.22% in year two. If she died during the term, the payments went to her estate. One daughter was the remainder beneficiary of each trust.
She reported each gift at $0. The IRS relied on Treasury Regulation 25.2702-3(e), Example 5, and argued that her chance of dying during the term reduced her retained interest. On that theory each gift was worth $3,821,522.12, and the agency assessed a deficiency of $4,532,776.82. Valued as a plain two-year annuity, each gift came to $6,195.10.
On December 22, 2000, a unanimous Tax Court called Example 5 “an unreasonable interpretation and an invalid extension of Section 2702”. The IRS later acquiesced. Today’s version of Example 5 treats a payment right held by the grantor “(and A’s estate)”[1] for a fixed term “in all events” as a qualified interest.
Section 2702 Taxes Only What the Heirs Are Expected to Get
Under the Internal Revenue Code, a retained right to “fixed amounts payable not less frequently than annually”[2] is a qualified interest, valued under Section 7520 (26 U.S.C. § 2702(b)(1) and (a)(2)(B)). The Section 7520 rate equals 120%[3] of the federal midterm rate for the month of the transfer.
The taxable gift is the value of the property minus the value of the annuity the grantor holds. If the annuity is set so its present value matches the full contribution, the gift is close to zero. Whatever the stock earns above the 7520 rate goes to the heirs free of gift tax.
Running the Widow’s Numbers
This example uses a 5.0% Section 7520 rate. The real rate resets every month. For context, the 10-year Treasury yielded 5.10%[4] on November 12, 2026.
| Step | Amount |
|---|---|
| Stock added | $2,000,000 |
| Annual annuity payment | $1,075,609 |
| Trust value after year-one payment | $1,324,391 |
| Trust value before year-two payment | $1,589,269 |
| Passes to children | $513,660 |
| Taxable gift reported | $1.41 |
If the stock goes nowhere, the trust pays everything back to her, just as Walton’s did. She loses only her legal fees.
Holds the Stock Costs Her Heirs $205,464
Say she skips the GRAT and the stock grows just the same. The $513,660 then sits in a taxable estate, where the top rate is 40%[5]. That costs her heirs $205,464. Giving the stock away outright is the other option, but a gift is valued “at the date of the gift”[6], so all $2 million would come out of her exemption.
The GRAT has costs. Her children take her original basis in the stock, with no step-up to fair market value on the date of death. And if she dies before the term ends, the trust assets are generally pulled back into her estate. (A GRAT is one piece of a larger plan, and the rest of the paperwork, ownership and beneficiary forms included, is where most estates quietly go wrong. The full checklist is available here: Die With a Plan.)
Steps to Take Before Funding a GRAT
- Fund it with the one holding most likely to rise sharply. Use a separate GRAT for each stock, so a loser cannot drag down a winner.
- Ask your attorney for the current month’s Section 7520 rate before you sign. A lower rate means the stock has less to beat.
- Choose two-year terms and roll the payments you get back into new GRATs. A short term limits the risk of dying before it ends.
- File Form 709 and disclose the trust in full. Under 26 U.S.C. § 2001(f)(2)[5], a value that is adequately disclosed and goes unchallenged becomes final.
- Ask a lawyer to weigh the lost step-up in basis against the estate tax you would save.
The number to remember is the $1.41 taxable gift. Since Walton, a gift that small can still move $513,660 of growth to the next generation.
Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.








