At 68 With $1.2 Million, He’ll Move Across State Lines to Be Near His Grandkids. Until He Cuts His Ties, His Old State Can Still Call Him a Resident
This post may contain links from our sponsors and affiliates, and Flywheel Publishing may receive compensation for actions taken through them.
The moving truck is booked, and at 68, with $1.2 million saved, he’s about to trade video calls for Saturday soccer games with his grandkids. The caveat is that the old house hasn’t sold yet, though, and his car still has the old plates. If he isn’t careful, those loose ends can turn an exciting move into a surprise letter from his old state’s tax department.
If you’re moving to be closer to family, you’re in good company. IRS migration data shows 43,187[1] tax returns moved from New York to Florida alone in 2022-2023, carrying $5.75 billion in income. The Wall Street Journal featured Earl and Pat Vittitoe, who left Illinois for Arizona and cut their property tax bill from more than $13,000 a year to about $3,600. A move like that only pays off if the old state agrees you’ve left.
Why Your Old State Can Still Claim You
Changing your domicile, the place you intend as your permanent home, takes deliberate steps. States judge that intent by your actions and look at the overall pattern of your life.
The stakes are real because residents generally pay tax on all their income, while nonresidents pay only on income tied to that state, according to a residency audit guide from law firm Hodgson Russ. For a retiree, almost everything (IRA withdrawals, dividends, capital gains) follows domicile. If the old state still considers him a resident, it can tax all of it.
Where the Dollars Really Pile Up
A steady 4% draw on $1.2 million is about $48,000 a year. The bigger state tax exposure comes from uneven years.
Born in 1958, he doesn’t face required minimum distributions until age 73, with the first one due in 2031. That gap is prime time for Roth conversions or selling appreciated investments (we sized up that quiet window between the last paycheck and the first RMD: The Roth Window). Those big-income years are exactly when a high-tax state has the most reason to argue he never really left.
Big conversions carry a federal side effect too. In 2027, a single filer whose 2025 income exceeded $112,000[2] pays about $293 a month for Medicare Part B instead of the standard $209.
Ties Auditors Check First
High-tax states audit recent movers because the return is large. Hodgson Russ says a high-income taxpayer reporting a move out of New York faces an audit that is “a near certainty.” Rules differ by state, but these ties come up again and again:
- The old house. This is the biggest one. Some states, New York among them, have a second test called statutory residency that can treat someone living elsewhere as a resident if they keep a permanent home there and spend enough days in the state.
- Driver’s license and vehicle registration. Switch both quickly. Keeping old plates tells an auditor the move felt temporary.
- Voter registration. Register in the new state and cancel the old one. Voting absentee back home undermines everything else.
- Doctors, bank and daily life. Auditors notice where your physicians, safe deposit box, clubs, and pets are. Move them to where the grandkids live.
- Homestead exemptions. Claim the property tax break in the new state and drop it in the old one. Holding a homestead exemption is a sworn statement about where you live.
- Days spent in each state. Many states count days, and the thresholds vary. Know your old state’s rule before you plan long visits.
Two Paths, and One Usually Wins
Path one: a clean break. Sell the old house, or rent it long-term to an unrelated tenant so it isn’t available to you. Move licenses, accounts, and doctors within weeks of a clear move date. For most people in his position, this is the right call. It ends the argument before it starts.
Path two: keep the old house for visits. This can work, but only with careful records of every day spent in each state. If an audit comes, you’ll have to prove where you lived, and that can mean digging up years of documents. Paying for that expense to keep a guest room near old friends rarely makes sense, especially in a year with a large Roth conversion.
What to Settle Before the Truck Pulls Away
Pick a move date and build the paper trail now: calendars, credit card receipts, phone records, and closing documents that show where you actually spent your time. Keeping the old house and doing six-figure conversions in the first few years makes a state tax attorney worth paying for, because one lost audit could cost more than years of fees.
Avoid keeping the old home “just in case” while realizing high income right after the move. Cut the ties first, then take the tax hits. The grandkids’ games will be just as fun without a letter from your old state waiting at home.
Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.








