She Stashed $374,000 of IRA Gold Coins in Her Home Safe and Thought She’d Found a Loophole. The Tax Court Judge Didn’t Agree, and the Penalties Followed
This post may contain links from our sponsors and affiliates, and Flywheel Publishing may receive compensation for actions taken through them.
Donna McNulty thought she had found a way to own gold through her IRA and keep it close. In 2015 she moved $378,487 from a MetLife annuity into a self-directed IRA. The IRA had an LLC it owned, Green Hill Holdings, buy 320 one-ounce American Eagle gold coins for $374,000. The coins were shipped to her home and kept in a safe.
The loophole came from a website. In August 2015 she bought services from Check Book IRA, LLC, whose website advertised that IRA owners could hold the coins at their homes “without tax consequences or penalties so long as the coins were ‘titled’ to an LLC.” Her own IRA custodian, Kingdom Trust, said otherwise: the court noted that part of its website “states that AE coins must be held in a depository.”
The loophole didn’t hold. In November 2021, in McNulty v. Commissioner, 157 T.C. No. 10, the U.S. Tax Court ruled that she received a taxable distribution equal to the cost of the coins when she got them.
Her case matters again for retirees. Spot gold slipped below $3,800 an ounce on November 17, 2026, about 32% below its $5,594.82 record from January 29, 2026, and SPDR Gold Shares (NYSEARCA:GLD) is down 11.06% this year.
Say you’re 67, living on Social Security and $400,000 in an IRA, and the drop has you thinking about moving $100,000 of it into coins you can keep in a safe at home. Under the same ruling, that decision would turn $100,000 of retirement savings into $100,000 of taxable income in a single year. That example is hypothetical. Her case is real.
Her Numbers, Step by Step
- 2015: $378,487 moved into the IRA, and $374,000 went to gold coins. The IRS counted $374,000 as a taxable distribution for 2015, and the court agreed.
- 2016: $48,375 came over from her 401(k), and the LLC bought $37,380 of American Eagle silver coins. The IRS counted another $37,380 as a distribution.
- Total treated as withdrawn: $411,380, taxed as income in the years she received the coins.
The IRS determined income tax deficiencies of $250,558 for 2015 and $18,094 for 2016, $268,652 in all, covering both her IRA and her husband’s.
Why the Court Ruled Against Her
“Mrs. McNulty had complete, unfettered control over the AE coins and was free to use them in any way she chose,” the court wrote. “Personal control over the IRA assets by the IRA owner is against the very nature of an IRA.”
The tax code allows certain bullion in an IRA only “if such bullion is in the physical possession of a trustee.” Naming the LLC as owner didn’t change who controlled the coins.
Then the Penalties
The court also upheld accuracy-related penalties for both years. “Petitioners did not seek or receive any advice from their C.P.A., who prepared their 2015 and 2016 returns, regarding their self-directed IRAs,” Judge Goeke wrote. “Petitioners are both professionals.” The court found they had moved nearly $750,000 out of their retirement accounts without telling their accountant, and ruled they had no reasonable-cause defense.
What You Can Do
- Keep IRA metals with the custodian or trustee. If your IRA owns gold, it shouldn’t be in your house.
- Tell your tax preparer about any self-directed IRA transaction before you file.
- If you want gold in an IRA without handling coins, a fund such as GLD holds the metal for you.
Bottom Line
Gold’s 32% slide is a paper loss that could reverse. A tax bill doesn’t. If your IRA owns gold, make sure someone other than you is holding it.
Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.







