She’ll Convert $70,000 to a Roth in December and Plan to Pay the Tax in April. The Payment Is Due Jan. 15, and Without One Form the IRS Will Charge a Penalty Back to Last April
This post may contain links from our sponsors and affiliates, and Flywheel Publishing may receive compensation for actions taken through them.
A taxpayer planning a December Roth conversion intends to move $70,000 from a pretax account into a Roth. Her plan for the tax bill is simple: settle up when she files in April, the way she always has. The timing creates a problem, though. Federal income tax is a pay-as-you-go tax, according to the IRS, and the conversion income lands in the final estimated-tax period of the year.
Why the Deadline Arrives Before Tax Season
IRS Publication 505 for 2026 splits the year into four payment periods. Income received from Sept. 1 through Dec. 31 is covered by a payment due Jan. 15, 2027. A December conversion falls in that window, so the tax on it is due in mid-January, three months before she planned to pay it.
The IRS does offer a shortcut. Anyone who files the 2026 return by February 1, 2027, and pays the full balance can skip the January payment. Most people waiting on W-2s and 1099s can’t file that early, so the shortcut doesn’t help the typical late-year converter.
How a December Move Gets Penalized Back to April
The penalty can also apply to periods well before the conversion. Under the regular installment method, Publication 505 divides the year’s estimated tax by 4 and assumes income came in equally. To the IRS, a December conversion resembles year-round income. So a share of its tax counts as due on April 15, 2026, months before the money moved.
The penalty is figured separately for each payment period. Under 26 U.S.C. § 6654(b)(2)[1], each shortfall accrues from its installment’s due date until it’s paid. The IRS set the underpayment rate at 7% for the quarter beginning October 1, 2026. As a result, the conversion is charged interest for months when there was no taxable income.
The IRS will usually figure the penalty itself and send a bill. If a taxpayer thinks the penalty can be reduced or eliminated, she must complete Form 2210, according to IRS Publication 17.
Schedule AI Matches the Tax to When the Money Moved
Form 2210’s Schedule AI, the annualized income installment method, replaces the even-income assumption. Publication 505 explains the method. It figures tax at the end of each period based on income from the start of the year through the end of the period. The periods build on each other, so the April, June, and September installments reflect only the income received up to those points.
For her, that means the conversion shows up only in the last period. The earlier installments don’t include it, so the penalty that reached back to April goes away as long as the January payment covers it. Anyone using this method must file Form 2210 with the 2026 return. Skip the form, and the IRS will assume the income came in evenly.
Safe Harbors Can Remove the Penalty Entirely
Many converters won’t need Schedule AI at all. Publication 505 says no penalty applies if withholding and estimated payments for 2026 reach the smaller of 90% of this year’s tax or 100% of the total tax on the 2025 return. A large conversion usually makes the prior-year test easier to meet.
Higher earners face a stricter version. If 2025 adjusted gross income was more than $150,000 ($75,000 for married filing separately), the prior-year threshold rises to 110%. Separately, people who expect to owe less than $1,000 after withholding and credits generally aren’t required to make estimated payments.
Withholding Counts as Paid All Year
Withholding gets treated differently from estimated payments. Under 26 U.S.C. § 6654(g)(1)[1], tax withheld is deemed paid in equal parts on each due date unless the taxpayer chooses to use the actual dates. Publication 505 for 2026 states that one-fourth of withholding is considered withheld on the due date of each payment period.
As a result, December withholding gets better timing treatment than a January estimated payment. Federal tax withheld from the IRA distribution, or extra tax taken from her last paychecks, counts as if it had been paid equally since April. A single estimated payment made in January gets no such treatment, and one trade-off with IRA withholding is that whatever is withheld doesn’t make it into the Roth.
What to Settle Before Jan. 15
Anyone converting late in the year has three options. One is to raise withholding before Dec. 31 so the total reaches the prior-year safe harbor. Another is to send an estimated payment by Jan. 15, 2027, covering the conversion tax, and attach Form 2210 with Schedule AI to the return. The third, for those with documents ready early, is to file and pay in full by February 1.
Paying the conversion tax in April instead of by mid-January is what causes the penalty. Extra withholding by Dec. 31 or a Jan. 15 estimated payment combined with Schedule AI can prevent a penalty reaching back to April.
For readers considering whether to convert at all, the quiet years between the last paycheck and when required withdrawals begin are often the cheapest time to do it, which is the whole subject of our free Roth Window guide.
Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.







