Her 5-Year Annuity Matured in March. The Letter Gave Her 30 Days to Move the $280,000, and Doing Nothing Locked It Up for Another Five Years at a Lower Rate

Published November 20, 2026, 8:01am ET · 4 min read

The Full Benefits Desk desk. Editor: Gerelyn Terzo.

This post may contain links from our sponsors and affiliates, and Flywheel Publishing may receive compensation for actions taken through them.

An elderly woman with gray hair and glasses on her head sits at a rustic wooden table, looking down at a stack of documents with a distressed expression. To her left, a steaming mug of tea and a pair of eyeglasses rest on the table. A window looking out to bare trees and a blue-gray wall are in the background.
This image depicts the stress and regret an elderly woman might feel after missing a critical deadline for her annuity, locking her into a lower interest rate. © 24/7 Wall St.

A hypothetical retiree bought a five-year multi-year guaranteed annuity (MYGA) that matured in March. The insurer’s letter gave her 30 days to move the $280,000 or take it as cash. She put the letter aside. When the window closed, the contract rolled into a new five-year guarantee period at a lower renewal rate, along with a fresh surrender schedule. It is now November, and she has two questions: is she stuck, and is the money safe?

How a MYGA Renewal Window Works

A MYGA pays a fixed rate for a set term, much like a CD, except an insurance company issues it. When the guarantee period ends, the contract opens a short window. During that window the owner can withdraw the money, move it, or let it renew. The length of the window varies by contract. Hers was 30 days. Other contracts allow more or less time.

If the owner does nothing, the default is a renewal at whatever rate the insurer declares, subject only to the minimum guaranteed rate written into the contract. Some contracts renew for the same term with a new surrender schedule. Others renew year to year with no new charges. The contract language decides which one applies, so the first step is to reread it.

Why Her Renewal Rate Came in Lower

The insurer set her renewal rate in a lower-rate environment. The upper bound of the federal funds target was 5.5[1] in mid-2024. It was cut to 3.75[1] by December 11, 2025 and stayed there through her March renewal. It then moved to 4.00%[1] as of November 19, 2026. Insurers set renewal rates based on their own bond portfolios and pricing, and the rate offered to existing owners can trail the rate the same company pays new buyers.

Is the $280,000 Safe?

A MYGA’s “guaranteed” rate and principal are backed by the insurer’s claims-paying ability. FDIC insurance does not cover them. If an insurer fails, state life and health insurance guaranty associations provide a backstop. Coverage limits vary by state, and the association where the owner lives generally applies. Before deciding anything, she can check two things: the insurer’s financial strength ratings and her own state’s annuity coverage limit. Retirees whose balance is above that limit sometimes spread the money across more than one insurer.

What Moving the Money Now Could Cost

She should ask the insurer to put four numbers in writing: the current surrender value, the surrender charge percentage, any market value adjustment (MVA), and how much she can withdraw each year without a penalty. All four vary by contract. An MVA usually lowers the surrender value if rates have risen since the guarantee period began and raises it if rates have fallen.

Taxes add to the cost. If the annuity holds nonqualified money (money that was taxed before it went in), any amount withdrawn before the annuity starting date is taxable to the extent allocable to income on the contract[2] under 26 U.S.C. § 72(e)(2)(B)(i). Under § 72(e)(3)(A)[2], earnings come out first. An owner younger than age 59½[2] also owes an additional tax equal to 10% of the taxable portion under § 72(q)(1), unless an exception applies.

She can avoid those taxes by moving the money directly into another annuity. Under 26 U.S.C. § 1035(a)(3)[3], no gain or loss is recognized when one annuity contract is exchanged for another. Treasury limits this to cases where the same person or persons are the obligee or obligees[4] under both contracts (26 CFR 1.1035-1(c)). An exchange removes the tax cost but does not remove the old contract’s surrender charge. If the annuity sits inside an IRA, distributions are taxed in the manner provided under section 72[5] per § 408(d)(1), and a direct trustee-to-trustee transfer keeps the money inside the IRA.

Benchmarks to Measure the Renewal Rate Against

Benchmark Rate Date
5-year Treasury yield 4.86 Nov. 19, 2026
52-week Treasury bill yield 4.59 Nov. 19, 2026
National average 12-month CD 1.81%[6] Nov. 1, 2026[6]
I bond composite (fixed rate 1.4) 5.51 Issued Nov. 2026 through Apr. 2027

The CD figure is an average across banks. Top online banks routinely pay 3-5x this[6]. Treasury yields leave out an annuity’s tax deferral, surrender restrictions, and insurer credit risk. Interest on nonqualified money in an annuity is deferred until withdrawn, while CD and Treasury interest is taxed every year.

A Decision Framework Before Anything Else Goes on Autopilot

  • Compare exit cost with the yield gap. Add up the surrender charge, the MVA, and any tax due. Then compare that total with the extra interest an alternative would earn over the remaining years of the term, using the actual figures from the contract.
  • Use penalty-free withdrawals. If the contract allows yearly penalty-free withdrawals, she can move part of the money each year without paying a surrender charge.
  • Match the term to liquidity needs. Money that may be needed within five years belongs in something she can reach without a surrender charge.
  • Calendar the next maturity. She should ask the insurer when the next notice will be mailed, how long that window lasts, and whether renewing owners get the same rate as new buyers.

A renewed MYGA can suit an owner past 59½ who wants tax deferral, will not need the money before the term ends, and has a renewal rate close to market yields. It fits poorly for someone who needs access to the cash, is under 59½, or has more than her state’s guaranty limit with one insurer. From here, the main things to track are the direction of Treasury yields as the Fed holds at 4.00%[1], her contract anniversary, and the date the next window opens.

Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.

Gerelyn Terzo

Gerelyn Terzo is the author of dividend investing handbook "Dividend Investing Strategies: How to Have Your Cake & Eat It Too." A veteran financial journalist, she covers agri-finance for outlets like Global AgInvesting and the broader stock market and personal finance for 24/7 Wall Street. She began at CNBC and later helped launch Fox Business in New York. Gerelyn currently resides in Woodland Park, Colorado and dabbles in nature photography as a hobby.

All articles →

Sources

  1. Federal Funds Target Range - Upper LimitBoard of Governors of the Federal Reserve System
  2. 26 U.S.C. § 72 — Annuities; certain proceeds of endowment and life insurance contractsOffice of the Law Revision Counsel, U.S. House of Representatives
  3. 26 U.S.C. § 1035 — Certain exchanges of insurance policiesOffice of the Law Revision Counsel, U.S. House of Representatives
  4. 26 CFR 1.1035-1 — Certain exchanges of insurance policies.Office of the Federal Register (eCFR)
  5. 26 U.S.C. § 408 — Individual retirement accountsOffice of the Law Revision Counsel, U.S. House of Representatives
  6. National Rate: 12 Month CDFederal Deposit Insurance Corporation