He Left a $300,000 Fixed Annuity in Year Three for a Better Rate. The 6% Surrender Charge Was in the Brochure. The “Market Value Adjustment” That Took Another $11,000 Was Buried on Page 14

Published November 22, 2026, 8:03am ET · 4 min read

The Full Benefits Desk desk. Editor: Gerelyn Terzo.

This post may contain links from our sponsors and affiliates, and Flywheel Publishing may receive compensation for actions taken through them.

Annuity Concept Displayed on Calculator With Financial Documents in Office Setting
© Fox_Ana / Shutterstock.com

A retired engineer put $300,000 into a fixed annuity. In year three he found a better rate somewhere else and asked for his money back. He already knew about the 6% surrender charge because the sales brochure listed it. He did not expect a second deduction: a market value adjustment of $11,000, an illustrative figure for this example. That term was disclosed, but deep in the contract.

This matters now because rates are high. On November 19, 2026, the 5-year Treasury yielded 4.86% and the 10-year yielded 5.04%. The upper bound of the federal funds target rate is 4.00%[1], up from 3.75% earlier this year. When new money earns more, owners of older contracts want to switch, and rising rates are exactly when an MVA reduces your payout.

How a Market Value Adjustment Reduces Your Payout

An insurer puts most of a fixed annuity premium into bonds that mature around the end of the guarantee period. If you leave early after rates have risen, those bonds are worth less than the insurer paid for them. The MVA passes part of that loss to you. Most contracts follow the same basic rules:

  • Two rates get compared. The contract names a benchmark, such as a specific Treasury maturity, a bond index or a rate the insurer defines. It compares the benchmark on the issue date with the benchmark on the surrender date.
  • Rates up, payout down. If the benchmark has risen, the adjustment is negative. If it has fallen, the adjustment can be positive and add to your payout.
  • Time left matters. Formulas usually grow with the years remaining in the guarantee period, so leaving in year three magnifies the effect.
  • It comes on top of the surrender charge. The two are calculated separately, and both can apply to the same withdrawal.
  • Floors usually exist. Many contracts limit a negative MVA so your payout can’t fall below a minimum guaranteed surrender value. Penalty-free withdrawals and death benefits are often exempt.

Treasury yields serve only as background here. Your contract defines its own benchmark. Even so, yields move fast. The 5-year went from 4.7% on November 2 to 4.98% on November 13, then eased to 4.86%. An MVA quoted one week can be different the next.

What the Early Exit Cost in Dollars

Hypothetical example. It assumes the surrender charge applies to the full contract value and leaves out credited interest:

Item Amount
Contract value $300,000
Surrender charge (6%) $18,000
Market value adjustment (illustrative) $11,000
Total exit cost $29,000
Left to reinvest $271,000

The new, higher rate has to earn back that $29,000 on a smaller balance before the switch comes out ahead.

Taxes Can Take a Third Cut

With a nonqualified annuity (one bought with after-tax money), a full surrender is taxed under 26 U.S.C. § 72[2]. Earnings above what you paid in count as ordinary income. The surrender charge and MVA lower the amount you receive, which also lowers the taxable gain. Owners younger than 59½[2] also owe a 10% additional tax on the taxable portion under 26 U.S.C. § 72(q)(1). Section 72(q)(2)(A)[2] exempts distributions made after that age. An annuity held inside an IRA falls under § 72(t)[2] instead.

A 1035 exchange changes the tax picture. Under 26 U.S.C. § 1035(a)(3)[3], no gain or loss is recognized when one annuity contract is exchanged for another. That postpones the tax. The old insurer still deducts the surrender charge and the MVA.

Is the Money Safe? Two Separate Risks

A fixed annuity’s guarantee is backed by the insurer’s claims-paying ability, and FDIC deposit insurance does not cover it. If an insurer fails, state life and health insurance guaranty associations provide coverage up to limits set in each state’s law. Those limits vary by state, so check your own state’s association. Guaranty coverage only applies when an insurer fails. Charges you trigger by leaving early fall outside it. The engineer’s $29,000 came from the contract working exactly as written.

Compare the Rate You Would Actually Get

A “better rate” needs a real point of comparison. The national average 12-month CD paid 1.81%[4] as of November 1, 2026, though top online banks routinely pay 3-5x that average. Series I bonds issued from November 2026 through April 2027 pay a combined 5.51%, including a 1.4% fixed rate. The 1-year Treasury yields 4.62%. Each option differs from an annuity in how easily you can get your money out, how it’s taxed and how much you’re allowed to put in.

Checklist Before You Leave Early

  1. Ask the insurer for a written surrender quote that shows the surrender charge and the MVA separately, along with the benchmark rates used.
  2. Find the year the surrender schedule ends. In most contracts, the MVA stops applying then too.
  3. Read the free-withdrawal provision. Moving only the penalty-free portion each year can avoid both charges on that money.
  4. Compare what the new rate would earn on your lower balance with what the old annuity would earn if you stayed. That shows how long it might take to recover the exit cost.
  5. Confirm your tax situation: qualified or nonqualified money, your age relative to 59½, and whether a 1035 exchange fits.
  6. Check the new product’s own surrender schedule. Signing a new one starts the clock over.

Keep an eye on intermediate-term yields. If they fall from current levels, the same contract’s MVA shrinks or even turns positive. If they keep rising, the cost of leaving early goes up until the surrender period ends.

Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.

Gerelyn Terzo

Gerelyn Terzo is the author of dividend investing handbook "Dividend Investing Strategies: How to Have Your Cake & Eat It Too." A veteran financial journalist, she covers agri-finance for outlets like Global AgInvesting and the broader stock market and personal finance for 24/7 Wall Street. She began at CNBC and later helped launch Fox Business in New York. Gerelyn currently resides in Woodland Park, Colorado and dabbles in nature photography as a hobby.

All articles →

Sources

  1. Federal Funds Target Range - Upper LimitBoard of Governors of the Federal Reserve System
  2. 26 U.S.C. § 72 — Annuities; certain proceeds of endowment and life insurance contractsOffice of the Law Revision Counsel, U.S. House of Representatives
  3. 26 U.S.C. § 1035 — Certain exchanges of insurance policiesOffice of the Law Revision Counsel, U.S. House of Representatives
  4. National Rate: 12 Month CDFederal Deposit Insurance Corporation