Her $200,000 IRA Annuity Pays $15,000 a Year. Under a 2022 Law, That Check Now Counts Toward the RMD on the Other $400,000, and Her Forced Withdrawal Fell by About Half
This post may contain links from our sponsors and affiliates, and Flywheel Publishing may receive compensation for actions taken through them.
A retiree who reaches 73 this year owes her first required minimum distribution (RMD), and the size of that withdrawal can shrink sharply if part of her IRA already pays out as an annuity. The change traces to Section 204 of the SECURE 2.0 Act of 2022, enacted December 29, 2022. Fidelity has confirmed how the provision works. Many retirees still take the larger withdrawal and pay tax on income the law no longer requires them to take.
Why This 2022 Change Matters for a First RMD
Under the older approach, an annuity held inside an IRA and an IRA invested in funds each had its own RMD. The annuity checks covered the annuity contract’s requirement and nothing else. Any amount paid above that requirement could not reduce the withdrawal owed from the owner’s other IRAs.
IRA owners could already combine RMDs across accounts. The IRS says an owner “must calculate the RMD separately for each IRA they own but can withdraw the total amount from one or more of the IRAs.” Section 204 adds a new option: the annuity’s payments can now count toward the combined total.
How the Aggregation Election Works
The Treasury regulation says an individual who holds an IRA that is an annuity contract described in section 408(b) “may elect to aggregate that IRA with one or more IRAs with account balances,”[1] treating those balances “as if the account balances were the remaining account balances following the purchase of the annuity contract with a portion of those account balances” (26 CFR 1.408-8(e)(1)(ii)). In practice, the owner adds the annuity’s value to her account balances and divides the total by her life expectancy factor. The annuity checks she receives during the year then count toward that combined figure.
The election has limits. Only IRAs she holds as owner are combined. Under 26 CFR 1.408-8(e)(3), payouts from traditional IRAs “may not be used to satisfy the required minimum distribution requirements with respect to a Roth IRA, or a section 403(b) contract.”[1]
Hypothetical Example: $15,094 Versus $7,642
Take a hypothetical retiree born in 1953. Her applicable age is 73, her first RMD year is 2026, and that first withdrawal is due by April 1, 2027. Her Uniform Lifetime Table factor at 73 is 26.5. She has $400,000 in an IRA invested in funds and an IRA annuity that pays $15,000 a year. To keep the example simple, assume that the annuity’s fair market value at year-end 2025 was $200,000, same as the purchase price.
| Approach | RMD Calculation | Required From the $400,000 IRA | Total Taxable Payouts |
|---|---|---|---|
| Separate (old approach) | $400,000 divided by 26.5 | $15,094 | $30,094 |
| Aggregated (Section 204 election) | $600,000 divided by 26.5 = $22,642, minus $15,000 in annuity checks | $7,642 | $22,642 |
The required withdrawal from her $400,000 IRA falls to about 51% of what the old approach required. That is about half. Her total payouts subject to tax, before any withdrawals she chooses to add, also fall. That matters because traditional IRA distributions are taxed as ordinary income.
Who Gains and Who Gets Little From It
The election works best when the annuity pays out more each year than the RMD factor would require on the contract’s value. In this example, the $15,000 check is far larger than the annuity’s own share of the RMD, so the extra amount reduces what she must take from the fund account. Three factors limit the benefit:
- Age: The life expectancy factor gets smaller each year, so required withdrawals rise and the advantage narrows.
- Contract value: The insurer’s reported value goes into the combined total. A higher value raises the combined RMD.
- Cash needs: A retiree who spends her full account withdrawal every year gains little, because she takes the money out anyway.
The election tends to suit retirees who don’t need the extra withdrawal and want to keep it growing tax-deferred. It also suits those trying to keep taxable income in a lower bracket. Annuities held in 403(b) plans or Roth accounts fall outside it.
What Backs the Check and the Cost of Getting It Wrong
The guarantee on the $15,000 annual payment depends on the insurer’s claims-paying ability. If the insurer fails, state guaranty associations provide a backstop, but their coverage limits vary by state. Check your own state’s limit against the contract value.
Mistakes cost money. Under 26 U.S.C. § 4974(a), a missed RMD triggers an excise tax of 25% of the shortfall. That drops to 10% if the owner corrects the shortfall within the correction window in § 4974(e). Before SECURE 2.0, the rate was 50%. Anyone who claims the smaller aggregated withdrawal must be able to show the annuity payments and the contract value to back up the calculation.
What to Check Before Electing
Treasury is still finishing parts of the RMD rules. In Announcement 2026-7, dated March 9, 2026, the IRS said certain portions of future final regulations will apply to the distribution calendar year that begins no earlier than 6 months after they are published. Until then, taxpayers must apply a reasonable good-faith interpretation of the law.
A retiree weighing the election can work through four questions:
- Is the annuity held as an IRA under section 408(b), and are the other accounts traditional IRAs she owns?
- Will the insurer provide a year-end contract value, and will her custodian accept the combined calculation?
- Do her annuity checks exceed the contract’s own share of the RMD by enough to matter?
- Does she need the larger withdrawal for spending, which would make the tax savings moot?
A qualifying longevity annuity contract (QLAC) is a different product with its own rules. The QLAC premium limit is $210,000 for tax year 2026 and rises to $220,000 for 2027. For an annuity that is already paying, the Section 204 election is the rule to raise with a tax preparer before the first deadline on April 1, 2027.
Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.







