A Retiree With a 3% Mortgage Needs Cash and Doesn’t Want to Sell Her Home. As HELOC Balances Hit $481 Billion, Borrowing at Roughly 7.5% Could Add Hundreds to Her Monthly Payment
This post may contain links from our sponsors and affiliates, and Flywheel Publishing may receive compensation for actions taken through them.
Picture a 70-year-old widow with a house that’s nearly paid off, a mortgage locked at 3%, and a roof that needs replacing. Selling would mean giving up the cheapest money she will ever borrow. So she’s looking at a home equity line of credit, which is a revolving loan secured by her house. Plenty of homeowners are making the same move. HELOC balances rose by $23 billion in the third quarter to $481 billion, according to the New York Fed, and rates have recently averaged around 7.5%.
Older Americans have the equity to do this. Households headed by someone 70 or older held about $13 trillion in owner-occupied real estate[1] in the second quarter of 2025, according to a Federal Reserve data analysis by Redfin. For someone like her, Social Security is the regular paycheck that has to cover whatever she borrows. That leaves two questions that matter: what the loan does to her taxes, and what it does to her monthly budget.
Why Borrowed Money Can Beat an IRA Withdrawal at Tax Time
Whether your Social Security gets taxed depends on what the IRS calls provisional income. About, that’s your other taxable income plus half of your benefits. If you file as an individual, benefits start to become taxable once that figure passes $25,000[2]. Once it passes $34,000[2], up to 85% of benefits can be taxed.
Loan proceeds generally fall outside of what is considered income for Social Security taxation. A $50,000 draw on a home equity line adds nothing to provisional income. A $50,000 withdrawal from a traditional IRA adds every dollar.
Here’s a simple example. Say she collects $24,000 a year from Social Security and $20,000 from a pension. Her provisional income is $32,000, so $3,500 of her benefits is taxable.
Now suppose she takes the $50,000 from her IRA instead of borrowing it. Her provisional income jumps, and the 85% cap applies, so $20,400 of her benefits becomes taxable. That’s $16,900 more of her Social Security exposed to tax, on top of the withdrawal itself. Borrowing avoids that chain reaction.
Where a 7.5% Credit Line Squeezes a Fixed Check
The tax savings come at a price. A fully drawn $50,000 balance at 7.5% costs about $313 a month in interest alone, or $3,750 a year. The average retired worker’s benefit is $2,071 a month in 2026, and that interest would eat about 15% of it.
Next year’s raise covers only a piece of it. Your 2027 cost-of-living adjustment (COLA) is 3.6% adds about $75 a month to that average check. Meanwhile, the standard Medicare Part B premium, usually taken straight out of Social Security, rises to $209.40 from $202.90[3] in 2027.
Interest-only payments also run on a clock. A home equity line has a draw period, when you can borrow and often pay just interest, followed by a repayment period. If she pays off $50,000 over 20 years at 7.5%, her payment rises to about $403 a month. The rate can change, too. It usually follows the prime rate, which moves with the Federal Reserve’s benchmark rate. The top of that range is 4%[4] today.
Combining the Loan With Her Other Income
Using only one source of cash is rarely the cheapest plan. A smaller IRA withdrawal, sized to keep provisional income under the 85% threshold, can cover part of the bill. The credit line can then cover the rest. That keeps both the tax bill and the interest bill smaller than either source would on its own.
Medicare is the other piece. In 2027, single filers with income over $112,000[3] pay $293.10 a month for Part B instead of the standard premium. Medicare sets that surcharge using your tax return from two years earlier, which is one of several IRS rules that can quietly drain a retirement account (we mapped the full set in a free guide here). So one big IRA withdrawal can raise your premiums long after the money is spent. Borrowed money can’t trigger that surcharge.
Two Questions to Answer Before Drawing a Dollar
- Decide how you’ll repay it before you borrow. If the answer is your monthly benefit, put the $313 payment into your monthly budget now, then the about $403 repayment amount, and see what’s left for groceries, prescriptions, and surprises. If the plan is to repay from a future home sale or from your estate, make sure your heirs understand that.
- Know which mistake is hardest to undo. A home equity line is secured by your house. Falling behind puts at risk the home you’re borrowing to keep. Drawing only what you need, instead of the full credit limit, keeps both the payments and that risk smaller.
A different pension, filing as a married couple, or even a quarter-point rate change can shift these numbers. Run your own figures before you sign anything.
Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.








