Special Report

Most Memorable TV Serial Killers

Few characters on television are as compelling as a serial killer. Fueled by some kind of trauma or pathology that makes them kill in ritualistic ways, these twisted murderers have made some of the best and scariest villains in TV history.

While many TV shows feature serial killers as major plot points, some actors have created especially compelling, unforgettable onscreen murderers. (In real life, these are the most depraved serial killers in history.)

To compile a list of the most memorable TV serial killers, 24/7 Tempo reviewed dozens of the most iconic horror, thriller, and detective shows featuring murderers. We selected the serial killer characters who were a major part of the plot either over the course of the entire series or for several seasons.

Though these characters are all killers, they are also quite different from each other. Some are disaffected loners on the fringes of society, like Norman Bates of “Bates Motel,” while others are seemingly normal members of society hiding a dark secret – for instance Dexter Morgan on the long-running (and rebooted) series “Dexter.” (These are the 20 best episodes of “Dexter,” according to IMDb.)

Click here to see the most memorable TV serial killers

Many of the killers on this list get a special sense of satisfaction from keeping their identity a secret, taunting law enforcement for not being able to bring them to justice. Much like the real-life Zodiac Killer, some demented murderers entangle detectives into deadly cat and mouse games.

Source: Courtesy of CBS Television

Paul Millander
> Show: CSI: Crime Scene Investigation (2000-2015)
> Played by: Matt O’Toole

Like most police dramas, “CSI: Crime Scene Investigation” portrayed many serial killers and other sociopaths over the 15 years it was on TV. One of the most memorable was Paul Millander, who the public knew as Judge Douglas Mason. Millander was the archenemy of Gil Grissom, the scientist and CSI supervisor played by William Peterson. Millander kills people and stages the scene to look like a suicide, mimicking his father’s murder.


Source: Bennett Raglin / Stringer / Getty Images Entertainment

The Gravedigger
> Show: Bones (2005-2017)
> Played by: Deirdre Lovejoy

The Gravedigger haunted Booth, Brennan, and the rest of the “Bones” team over several of the early seasons of the series. This serial killer buried victims alive, demanding ransoms and leaving them to die if the demand were not met. Brennan eventually realizes the Gravedigger was state attorney Heather Taffet, who used her position to throw investigators off the case.

Source: Courtesy of CBS

Dexter Morgan
> Show: Dexter (2006-2013)
> Played by: Michael C. Hall

“Dexter” is one of the few shows on this list in which the serial killer is also the main protagonist. Michael C. Hall portrayed Dexter Morgan, a police forensic expert who moonlights as a murderer. Dexter harnesses his urge to kill to take out the worst people in Miami. The show was rebooted as “Dexter: New Blood” in 2001.

Source: Courtesy of CBS

The Trinity Killer
> Show: Dexter (2006-2013)
> Played by: John Lithgow

Like Dexter Morgan, Arthur Mitchell was a seemingly-normal family man, but had a secret second life as the Trinity Killer, who murdered hundreds of people in groups of three throughout his life. Dexter eventually kills him, but not before the Trinity Killer has murdered Dexter’s wife, Rita.


Source: Courtesy of CBS

Red John
> Show: The Mentalist (2008-2015)
> Played by: Xander Berkeley

Red John is the nemesis of the main character in the show, Patrick Jane. Red John and his many operatives have killed more than 70 people, among them Jane’s wife and daughter. The killer’s signature move is drawing a smiley face on the wall with his victim’s blood. Though Red John has been featured in every season, his identity is only revealed in the middle of season six.

Source: Courtesy of Filmlance International AB

Truth Terrorist
> Show: The Bridge (2011-2018)
> Played by: Lars Simonsen

The Truth Terrorist – whose real name is Jens Hansen and/or Sebastian Sandstrod – is the mastermind antagonist in this Nordic noir crime drama. A former police detective, he has a mental breakdown when he finds out his wife is cheating on him with his best friend and colleague, Martin. He kills people as a way to bring attention to the problems of homelessness and child labor.


Source: Courtesy of FX Network

Dr. Oliver Thredson
> Show: American Horror Story: Asylum (2012)
> Played by: Zachary Quinto

Dr. Oliver Thredson is a psychiatrist. He is also a serial killer who grew up in an orphanage after his birth mother abandoned him. Longing for a maternal presence, he is seeking out women to replace his mother. When he deems them inadequate, he skins them and turns their skin into a mask, earning him the name “Bloody Face.”

Source: Courtesy of Fox Network

Joe Carroll
> Show: The Following (2013-2015)
> Played by: James Purefoy

Joe Carroll is the main antagonist in “The Following.” He is the man behind the so-called Virginia Campus Murders, which claimed the lives of some 14 women. After the murders, he creates a cult of vicious serial killers, known as The Followers, who will do everything Carroll tells them to.

Source: Courtesy of National Broadcasting Company

Hannibal Lecter
> Show: Hannibal (2013-2015)
> Played by: Mads Mikkelsen

In “Hannibal,” Mads Mikkelsen played a younger version of the legendary serial killer Hannibal Lecter from “Silence of the Lambs.” In the show, Lecter’s true identity as a murderer is unknown. He works as a forensic psychiatrist, helping Special Agent Will Graham hunt other serial killers, using his position to throw investigators off his trail.


Source: Courtesy of ZDF Enterprises

Paul Spector
> Show: The Fall (2013-2016)
> Played by: Jamie Dornan

Paul Spector is a bereavement counselor and also a serial killer known as the Belfast Strangler, targeting women in Northern Ireland’s capital. After his mother commits suicide, Spector grows up in an orphanage, where he is believed to have been abused by a priest. Known for meticulously planning each murder and always killing his victims in their homes, Spector was partially motivated by his need to control others.

Source: Courtesy of A+E Networks

Norman Bates
> Show: Bates Motel (2013-2017)
> Played by: Freddie Highmore

“Bates Motel” is a psychological horror drama that tells the story of how Norman Bates, already made famous by the thriller novel and iconic Hitchcock motion picture “Psycho.” The series shows him slowly transforming from a shy and smart boy to a vicious serial killer with a split personality disorder.


Source: Courtesy of Home Box Office

Errol Childress
> Show: True Detective (2014-2019)
> Played by: Glenn Fleshler

Throughout the first season of “True Detective,” Detectives Rust Cohle and Marty Hart pursued the elusive Yellow King, a serial killer who terrorized women and children in rural Louisiana over the course of many years. They eventually learn it is Errol Childress, a member of a secretive religious cult that has operated in the area for generations.

Source: Courtesy of Banijay Entertainment

Mick Taylor
> Show: Wolf Creek (2016-2017)
> Played by: John Jarratt

“Wolf Creek” follows Australian outback serial killer Mick Taylor as he targets a new set of victims each season. The show was originally a pair of films that was spun off into a series, with the films’ star, John Jarratt, returning to portray the deranged Taylor.

Source: Courtesy of ITV Studios Global Entertainment

Kieran Whitehead
> Show: The Loch (2017)
> Played by: Jack Bannon

The Scottish drama “The Loch” centers on a small town whose idyllic image is shattered when a serial killer strikes. Kieran Whitehead kills and removes parts of his victims, leaving them in plain sight for investigators to find.


Source: Courtesy of Audience Network

Brady Hartsfield
> Show: Mr. Mercedes (2017-2019)
> Played by: Harry Treadaway

In the TV adaptation of the Stephen King book “Mr. Mercedes,” a killer uses a stolen Mercedes-Benz to run over his victims. The killer taunts recently retired detective Bill Hodges, sending him letters and emails to lure him into a cat and mouse game.

Source: Courtesy of Lifetime Television

Joe Goldberg
> Show: YOU (2018-)
> Played by: Penn Badgley

In “YOU,” Penn Badgley plays Joe Goldberg – a misguided romantic who is willing to do anything for the woman he loves. Goldberg easily becomes infatuated, stalking the object of his desires and killing anyone who he thinks might stand in the way of his potential relationship.


Source: Jamie McCarthy / Staff / Getty Images Entertainment

> Show: The Alienist (2018-2020)
> Played by: Bill Heck

“The Alienist” tells the fictional story of one of New York City’s first serial killers. In the late 1800s, John Beecham targeted and killed young boys throughout the city, and it is up to one of the first criminal psychologists, a secretary, and a newspaper illustrator to track down the culprit.

Source: Courtesy of Fox Network

Dr. Martin Whitly
> Show: Prodigal Son (2019-2021)
> Played by: Michael Sheen

Michael Sheen stars in “Prodigal Son” as Dr. Martin Whitly, a charming doctor, family man, and secret serial killer. When his son Malcolm discovers his secret, he turns Dr. Whitly in to the police. Years later, Malcolm works as a criminal profiler working with the NYPD. After being estranged from his father for years, he has to ask for his help when a copycat killer emerges.

Source: Courtesy of American Broadcasting Company

Ronald Pergman
> Show: Big Sky (2020-)
> Played by: Brian Geraghty

In “Big Sky,” private detectives set out to Montana in search of two sisters who have gone missing. As they investigate, they realize the sisters may be linked with other disappearances tied to a serial killer – truck driver Ronald Pergman.


Source: Courtesy of BBC Studios

Thomas Massey
> Show: Ragdoll (2021-)
> Played by: Sam Troughton

AMC’s “Ragdoll” follows a team of detectives as they investigate the case of the Ragdoll Killer – a London murderer who kills and dismembers his victims, then sews their body parts together to form a gruesome spectacle.

Buffett Missed These Two…

Warren Buffett loves dividend stocks, and has stuffed Berkshire with some of his favorites.

But he overlooked two dividend legends that continue to print checks on a new level, they’re nowhere in his portfolio.

Unlock the two dividend legends Buffett missed in this new free report.

Thank you for reading! Have some feedback for us?
Contact the 24/7 Wall St. editorial team.