S&P Global: Why a $40 Billion Selloff Looks Like an Entry Point
As seen on the 24/7 Wall St. homepage on November 22, 2026.
TIP863: S&P Global (SPGI): A Market Titan Goes on a Rare Sale w/ Shawn O’Malley & Daniel Mahncke
- AI fears over Capital IQ, roughly 6% of revenue, erased about $40 billion of market value in ten days in February
- Ratings cycle may be peaking: three record issuance quarters fueled by $240 billion of hyperscaler debt as rates rise
- Index arm posted 14 straight record quarters; Cboe extended its exclusive S&P 500 options license through 2051
- Hosts peg fair value near $500, open a 1.5% position at about $450, buy target $400
The multiple has compressed from nearly 60 times earnings to around 26 while the business set records, and the hosts are acting on it with a starter position they intend to build toward a 5% weighting on further weakness. Their bet: AI drains value from the Capital IQ interface but raises the price of the proprietary data underneath.
Continue ReadingShow less
S&P Global's stock is roughly flat over five years despite the company posting record results, and that gap between business performance and share price is the central argument Shawn O'Malley and Daniel Mahncke make in this episode of We Study Billionaires. The catalyst for the latest leg down was fear that AI would disrupt Capital IQ, a product line that accounts for only about 6% of revenue, yet that anxiety erased roughly $40 billion of market value in around ten days this February.
The hosts walk through why they see that fear as partly misplaced. Their thesis is that AI is likely to commoditize the interface that sits on top of financial data while actually increasing the value of the proprietary, hard-to-replicate data that S&P owns underneath. That dynamic, they argue, makes the benchmark franchises (credit ratings, indices, and Platts energy price assessments) more defensible, because no competitor can replicate the underlying data sets.
Sponsored
The ratings business does carry a real near-term risk. Three consecutive record issuance quarters, partly fueled by roughly $240 billion of debt issued by hyperscalers, represent a possible cyclical peak, particularly as rates rise. The index arm has been a steadier story, posting 14 straight record quarters, and Cboe just extended its exclusive license to list S&P 500 options all the way through 2051, locking in a long royalty stream.
O'Malley and Mahncke peg fair value for the stock near $500. They opened a 1.5% starter position at around $450 and have set $400 as the level where they would add more aggressively, with a target of building to a 5% weighting. The position sizing reflects genuine uncertainty about the ratings cycle rather than any doubt about the quality of the underlying business.
Mentioned: GE, SPGI, ADBE, FICO, MCO, NFLX, TRI, TMSOF, CRM, MORN, ORCL, OCCLL, CBOE