Two unconventional ETFs promise to monetize information edges that traditional fund managers ignore. The Unusual Whales Subversive Democratic Trading ETF (NASDAQ:NANC) mirrors stocks disclosed by Democratic members of Congress under the STOCK Act, while the VanEck Social Sentiment ETF (NYSEARCA:BUZZ) uses natural language processing to score social media chatter around large-cap US stocks. Both test alternative data signals. Only one has held up.
What each fund bets on
NANC bets that political insiders with proximity to regulation, defense contracts, and committee hearings own quality compounders. The portfolio looks like a tech-heavy S&P 500. The top five positions are NVIDIA at 10.44%, Microsoft at 7.88%, Alphabet at 4.88%, Amazon at 4.84%, and Apple at 3.98%, with names like American Express, Salesforce, Philip Morris, and Netflix filling the top ten. The fund holds roughly $255 million and charges 0.74%.
BUZZ bets that retail attention front-runs price. Its index ranks the 75 most-discussed US large caps by positive sentiment, rebalanced monthly. That mechanic systematically pulls in high-beta tech, momentum names, and whatever Reddit, X, and stock forums favor. When sentiment leads earnings, BUZZ wins. When the crowd is wrong, rebalancing keeps buying losers.
The performance gap
NANC, launched February 7, 2023, has returned 93.23% through May 13, 2026, beating the SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust (NYSEARCA:SPY | SPY Price Prediction) return of 78.79% over the same window. BUZZ, launched March 4, 2021, has returned 60.15% since inception, while SPY returned 78.19% over the trailing five years. BUZZ was buying peak meme stocks in 2021, then rebalancing into the wreckage through the 2022 drawdown. The signal amplified exactly the wrong exposures.
Over the past year, BUZZ returned 37.56% against NANC’s 24.45%, with SPY at 26.49%. Sentiment works in trending tape. It breaks in regime shifts.
The comparison
| Metric | NANC | BUZZ |
|---|---|---|
| Signal source | Democratic congressional disclosures | Social media sentiment (NLP) |
| Inception | Feb 7, 2023 | Mar 4, 2021 |
| Since-inception return | 93.23% | 60.15% |
| Expense ratio | 0.74% | 0.75% |
| Style drift risk | Low, mirrors quality mega-caps | High, follows crowd attention |
The verdict
NANC is the structurally better product for buy-and-hold investors. Its signal pool, lawmakers with long holding periods and advisor-managed accounts, naturally selects for durable franchises. The portfolio overlaps heavily with the S&P 500, a feature for anyone treating it as a tilted core holding. BUZZ functions as a tactical trade vehicle. It works when momentum is rewarded and rebalancing flows are tailwinds, and it punishes patient money during sentiment reversals. The congressional ledger has been the more honest signal.
Top Gaining Stocks
Top Losing Stocks