The YieldMax MSTR Option Income Strategy ETF (NASDAQ:MSTY) trades near $24, and the trap in that number is what it has done while bitcoin spent most of the last year doing something else. MSTY launched in February 2024 as a way to monetize the option premium on MicroStrategy shares and hand investors a triple-digit distribution yield. The problem for MSTY holders is that the fund can decline even when MicroStrategy holds up, because the option overlay caps the good days and leaves the bad ones fully exposed.
How the fund makes money
MSTY runs a synthetic covered call on Strategy Inc. (NASDAQ:MSTR | MSTR Price Prediction), the bitcoin treasury vehicle formerly known as MicroStrategy that now holds 713,502 BTC. The fund buys synthetic long exposure through options, sells short-dated calls against it, and pays the premium out to shareholders.
MSTR is the perfect raw material for this trade because its implied volatility is enormous: it carries a $58 billion market cap that swings like a small-cap biotech, which inflates the call premiums YieldMax harvests.
PS: Google has its market cap figure wrong at $2.57 billion as of this writing. The real market cap is much higher, and the enterprise value (market cap + net cash) is even higher at $77.2 billion.
But back to the catch… MSTY’s catch is built into the structure. Selling calls means giving up the right tail. When MSTR ripped from $50 in February 2024 to a peak near $400 last May, MSTY collected premiums on the way up but surrendered most of the convexity. When MSTR fell back to $167, MSTY ate the full drawdown.
The arithmetic of capped upside
Since inception, MSTR has returned 231%. MSTY, on a distribution-adjusted basis, returned 96% over the same window. The SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust (NYSEARCA:SPY) returned 51%. MSTY beat the index since launch but forfeited more than half of what its underlying actually did. You took single-stock concentration risk on a bitcoin proxy and got roughly twice the S&P, when the proxy itself delivered four times the S&P.
The trailing twelve months are uglier. MSTY is down 50% while SPY is up 24% and bitcoin itself only fell 27%. MSTR dropped further, at 58%, but a holder who wanted bitcoin exposure with income got punished worse than buying spot BTC and writing nothing.
The distribution is shrinking on purpose
Look at what shareholders are actually receiving. In April 2024 MSTY paid $4.1286 per share in a single monthly distribution. By November 2024 it paid $4.4213. Mid-2025 distributions fell to the $1.00 to $2.37 range. The fund then shifted to weekly distributions, and the May 14, 2026 payment came in at $0.5363.
Smaller, more frequent checks reflect a shrinking NAV base producing less premium. A $20-something share price cannot generate $4 monthly distributions forever, and YieldMax has stopped pretending it can.
The tax bill nobody mentioned
Three structural costs deserve attention before this fund touches a portfolio.
- Ordinary income treatment. The May 13, 2026 distribution was classified 100% ordinary income, 0% return of capital. That is the worst possible tax outcome in a taxable account. MSTR holders defer everything until sale and then pay long-term capital gains. MSTY holders pay top marginal rates on every weekly check.
- Single-stock derivative concentration. You are not diversified. You hold options exposure to one company whose value is a leveraged bet on one asset.
- Asymmetric payoff. Short calls plus synthetic long equals capped upside, uncapped downside. In a sideways or trending-up MSTR tape, NAV bleeds while the yield headline keeps the marketing deck honest.
Who this fund actually fits
MSTY makes sense in exactly one situation: a tax-advantaged account, sized small, owned by someone who genuinely wants weekly cash from bitcoin volatility and accepts that the principal will likely shrink.
Anyone using it for bitcoin exposure with income has the trade backwards. Spot bitcoin or MSTR shares delivered better total returns since MSTY’s inception, with simpler taxes and no ceiling on the upside.
Top Gaining Stocks
Top Losing Stocks