Most investors think the worst 25-year stretch in stock market history must have been a financial graveyard. The numbers say otherwise, and they reveal one of the most counterintuitive truths in investing.
On the Money Guy Show podcast Everyday Investors Are Beating Fund Managers (Copy Their Strategy), hosts Brian Preston and Bo Hanson walked through a piece of history that should be required reading for anyone afraid of today’s market. The Dow Jones closed at 381 on September 3, 1929. It closed at 383 on November 23, 1954. A $2 gain over 25 years.
As Hanson framed it, “That’s not even a lost decade. That’s like a lost working career.”
The 11.7% Surprise
An investor who dollar-cost averaged through that same window, systematically buying every month and reinvesting dividends, earned an average annualized rate of return of 11.7%. The index went nowhere. The disciplined buyer compounded wealth anyway.
Preston explained the mechanism this way: “Your behavior was the all-terrain vehicle. It was buying while things were going down. You were still buying while things started to recover and had a sputter start, but then went back down. You were still buying.”
The math works because dividends reinvested at depressed prices buy more shares, and those shares then produce more dividends. A flat index masks the engine running underneath. By 1954, the dollar-cost averager owned a much larger share count than the price chart would suggest, all accumulated at average prices well below the 1929 peak.
Why This Matters In May 2026
Today’s investor faces a familiar cocktail of anxieties. The VIX sits at 17.82 as of May 18, 2026, off from a peak of 31.05 reached on March 27, 2026. Investors who panic-sold into that spring spike missed the recovery that followed automatically for anyone still making scheduled contributions.
Consumer sentiment tells the emotional story. The University of Michigan reading is 53.3 as of March 2026, down 5.5% from the prior month and sitting in the lower quartile of its 12-month range. Anything below 60 historically signals recessionary fear. This is precisely the psychological state when investors abandon systematic plans.
The macro backdrop is mixed. Real GDP grew 2.0% in the first quarter of 2026, recovering from a 0.5% near-stall in the fourth quarter of 2025 and a 0.6% contraction in the first quarter of 2025. Unemployment holds at 4.3% as of April 2026, well within the healthy range.
Meanwhile, the safe alternative keeps losing ground to prices. The 10-year Treasury yield reached 4.61% on May 18, 2026, its 12-month high, while CPI climbed to 332.4 in April 2026, a 90.9 percentile reading over the trailing year. Cash on the sidelines is quietly bleeding purchasing power.
The Always-Be-Buying Discipline
Preston’s mantra is unambiguous: “If you can set it and forget it and always be buying, that’s what I love about that strategy. It really doesn’t matter what’s going on in the economy, the geopolitical world.”
Practically, that means automating contributions to a 401(k), IRA, or brokerage account on a fixed schedule. It means leaving the dividend reinvestment box checked. It means accepting that the next decade may include a March 2026 style fear spike, a 2022 style drawdown, or worse.
The reward for sitting through that is what Preston described as the slow-then-fast nature of compounding: “one day the exponential growth takes so much traction, you look back and go, how did I get here?”
Investors who want to follow the discussion can listen directly through the Money Guy Show podcast archive. The 1929 to 1954 case study is the cleanest historical answer to anyone arguing the market is too scary to buy. It was scarier then. The buyers still won.
Top Gaining Stocks
Top Losing Stocks