Broadcom’s Selloff Shows the New Rule of AI Stocks: Great Isn’t Good

Photo of Omor Ibne Ehsan
By Omor Ibne Ehsan Published

Quick Read

  • AVGO dropped 13% despite 143% AI chip growth after Q3 guidance trailed Wall Street's $17B whisper number.

  • Broadcom's guidance shortfall triggered a $1.3 trillion chip sector selloff, proving in-line results now act as downgrades at AI-inflated multiples.

  • Act now: the analyst who called NVIDIA in 2010 just named his top 10 AI stocks — and Broadcom didn't make the cut. Grab the names FREE today.

Broadcom’s Selloff Shows the New Rule of AI Stocks: Great Isn’t Good

© Atichat Wattanasin Stone / Shutterstock.com

Broadcom (NASDAQ:AVGO | AVGO Price Prediction) beat both lines last week and still got punished, which shows how this AI cycle now grades the report card.

Broadcom is the second-largest AI chip franchise behind NVIDIA (NASDAQ:NVDA), supplying custom accelerators and networking silicon to hyperscalers. CEO Hock Tan has been guiding the Street toward $56 billion in AI semiconductor revenue this fiscal year and over $100 billion by 2027. Expectations have been carrying much of the stock price.

A beat that wasn’t enough

Q2 results were objectively excellent. Revenue of $22.19 billion rose 47.9% year over year, AI semiconductor revenue hit $10.80 billion on 143% growth, and free cash flow set a record at $10.26 billion. Operating margin printed at 67%. Tan said “demand for XPUs and networking is simply insatiable” and disclosed over $30 billion in AI bookings against the quarter’s shipments.

The problem was the next number. Q3 AI guidance of $16.00 billion implies over 200% growth, which sounds spectacular until you learn the sell side was modeling closer to $17.2 billion. The print cleared consensus but trailed the whisper number. The earnings-day close was $418.91, a 12.59% drop from the prior close of $479.23.

Why the whole sector got dragged

Broadcom doesn’t trade in a vacuum. When the second-biggest AI chip story posts triple-digit growth and gets sold, every adjacent name reprices for the same risk. The broader chip selloff that followed erased roughly $1.3 trillion in market value across the sector. One podcast host noted Broadcom was “down 14%” intraday despite being widely viewed as “one of the most impressive companies in this space.”

When forward multiples assume accelerating growth above consensus, in-line guidance functions as a downgrade. Gross margin guidance also slipped, with Q3 consolidated gross margin pointed to approximately 74%, down from 77.1%, as the lower-margin TPU mix scales.

The data behind the verdict

Shares trade at $383, off 20.4% from its peak. Year to date, AVGO is up 10.2%, and over five years it has returned 797%. Forward P/E sits at 34x, trailing P/E at 64x. The Street consensus price target is $502, comfortably above the current quote.

Analysts are still behind on most AI stocks like Broadcom. These businesses are making progress so fast that analysts have not caught up. For Broadcom, it’s a mix of that phenomenon, plus a few passionate bears who have price targets as low as $215.9, which drives the average down.

Why patience is the right call at this price

At $383, Broadcom is a Hold.

The business is firing. Bookings of over $30 billion against $10.8 billion of shipments, multi-gigawatt commitments from Google, Anthropic, OpenAI, and Meta, and management visibility stretching into 2028 argue against selling. The fifteenth consecutive annual dividend raise and a $10 billion buyback authorization keep the capital-return story intact.

The problem is what’s priced in. Forward earnings of 34x times assume the AI capex curve keeps bending up, and the Q2 reaction proved that even a 143% growth quarter can disappoint when whisper numbers run hotter than guidance. Customer concentration in six hyperscalers means a single capex pause ripples directly into the model. Gross margin will compress as TPUs scale.

A reset toward the low-$300s on further sector pressure, or a Q3 print that delivers above the $16 billion AI bar and lifts the 2027 framework, would force a Buy reassessment. A second straight quarter of in-line-versus-whisper guidance, or any sign that hyperscaler capex is plateauing, would push the call toward Sell. Until one of those arrives, the setup favors patience over action.

 

Photo of Omor Ibne Ehsan
About the Author Omor Ibne Ehsan →

Omor Ibne Ehsan is a writer at 24/7 Wall St. He is a self-taught investor with a focus on growth and cyclical stocks that have strong fundamentals, value, and long-term potential. He also has an interest in high-risk, high-reward investments such as cryptocurrencies and penny stocks.

Continue Reading

Top Gaining Stocks

KLA
KLAC Vol: 1,765,667
LRCX Vol: 14,945,146
MU Vol: 58,621,789
AMAT Vol: 12,402,066
IP Vol: 9,752,909

Top Losing Stocks

PTC
PTC Vol: 2,996,036
CTRA Vol: 73,319,495
ORCL Vol: 63,482,311
ADSK Vol: 4,269,253
GDDY Vol: 2,694,891