Dick’s Sporting Goods (NYSE:DKS | DKS Price Prediction) delivered a fiscal Q2 report that split its audience into four camps. Jim Cramer is holding the line. The sell side is cutting numbers. Retail is bargain hunting on thin volume. The institutional book was already trimming at the top.
What Broke the Stock
The retailer reported adjusted EPS of $3.53 against $3.78 expected, and revenue of $5.59 billion against $5.65 billion expected. The core banner held up. Dick’s comparable sales grew 4.9%, aided by World Cup demand. Foot Locker was the fracture point: pro forma comps fell 3.6% and the segment posted a $31.9 million operating loss on legacy silhouette exposure, weak launches, and EMEA softness.
Management lowered full-year non-GAAP EPS guidance to $11 to $12 from $13.50 to $14.50, and cut the Foot Locker outlook from an anticipated $110 million to $150 million profit to a loss of $40 million to $80 million. Shares closed at $124.31, down 30.68% on the session, the worst single-day drop in years and just above the 52-week low of $124.
[earnings_quotes symbol=”DKS”]
Cramer: Don’t Give Up on the Long Run
On Mad Money, Cramer refused to walk away from the name. “Dick’s Sporting Goods turned in a terrible quarter that led the stock to its worst one-day decline ever. Given the scale of the miss and the guidance cut, I don’t blame anyone for getting out of Dodge. Still, I don’t want to give up on Dick’s Sporting Goods at these levels in the long run.”
He pinpointed the wound as Foot Locker, not the flagship. “While management reiterated their outlook for same store sales at the Dick’s brand, that’s legacy Dick’s. They slashed their outlook for Foot Locker. They’re now talking negative 2% to flat instead of up 1.5 to 3 as they previously said.” His timing view: “It just might take a few months before the sporting goods footwear and apparel space clears that excess inventory and starts bouncing back. Usually can’t be done in a single quarter though.”
Sell Side: Targets Coming Down, Ratings Holding
Wells Fargo’s Ike Boruchow cut his price target to $185 from $240 while maintaining Overweight, arguing the athletic footwear backdrop “is not improving but rather deteriorating further” and that his 2027 bull case EPS now falls below his previous bear case. The prior consensus target of approximately $249.91 predates the guidance cut and is being revised. Treat any modeled forward EPS above the newly guided range as stale until refreshed.
Retail: Bullish Talk, Thin Volume
Reddit chatter on wallstreetbets skewed bullish with sentiment scores of 72 to 82, but observations logged only one qualified mention each with low activity. Dip buyers are vocal, but the activity is too thin to call a groundswell.
Institutional: 13F Data Predates the Break
The most recent 13Fs reflect quarter-end June 30, 2026, well before the collapse. Sachem Head held its position at 1.49 million shares valued at $337.9 million (7.01% of the portfolio), then trimmed. Maverick Capital added, bringing its stake to 1,473,873 shares worth $334.3 million. Viking Global trimmed. D.E. Shaw, Renaissance, and Gotham added; Two Sigma and Moore opened new positions. On the hedging side, Millennium added puts and Point72 added both calls and puts, consistent with downside protection carried into the print. None of these positions reflect what happened after the report.
Verdict: A Holding Period Call
Cramer’s patience is defensible, with conditions. The core Dick’s business is compounding: two-year and three-year comps of 9.9% and 14.4%, gross margin expansion of 79 basis points, and 14 House of Sport plus 20 Field House locations that extend the experiential moat. The Foot Locker deal is the wound, and management has committed up to $750 million in pre-tax integration charges, with $516 million already recognized, per the Q2 8-K exhibit.
This is fundamentally a holding period question. Watch for Foot Locker pro forma comps returning to positive and athletic channel inventory clearing so promotions ease. Until at least one of those turns, sell side numbers keep drifting lower and Cramer keeps waiting.
Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.
Top Gaining Stocks
Top Losing Stocks