Deere and Caterpillar Are Both Up Over 40% This Year: Take Profits or Hold On for the Ride?

Shares of Deere & Company (NYSE:DE | DE Price Prediction) and Caterpillar (NYSE:CAT) sit near the top of the industrial leaderboard this year, and both are adding to the gain again in Friday midday trading. Deere stock is up 47% year to date (YTD) to $680.98, and it’s up 0.5% on the session. Meanwhile, Caterpillar stock is up 44% YTD to $821.19, rising 2% Friday.

The rally has run well ahead of the industrial group behind them. Notably, the Industrial Select Sector SPDR ETF (NYSEARCA:XLI) is up 12% YTD. The SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust (NYSEARCA:SPY) is also up 12% YTD, so the sector fund’s return is essentially matching the broad market rather than beating it.

That leaves Deere and Caterpillar shares out on their own. Each has produced roughly four times the industrial fund’s move, and the group they sit inside hasn’t done the lifting. The take-profits-or-hold debate for these two names really hinges on what a reader makes of that gap.

A Two-Name Rally Above the Sector

Paccar (NASDAQ:PCAR) is the control that clarifies what’s actually happened. Paccar stock is up 14% YTD to $123.38, close to the XLI industrials fund’s own return. Paccar makes heavy-duty trucks and sits in the same neighborhood as Deere and Caterpillar, yet it hasn’t come along for the ride.

With XLI’s move essentially tracking the S&P 500 fund’s rally, the rising-tide explanation runs out of room. Whatever has driven Deere and Caterpillar higher this year is specific to those two names, not a broader industrial re-rating. The move is narrow, and narrowness is the fact both the bull and bear cases have to work from.

Case for Taking Profits

The take-profits argument for Deere and Caterpillar rests on how concentrated the leadership has been. A gain two names produced without their sector behind them can unwind faster than one the whole group earned, because there’s no broader bid waiting to catch a rollover in either Deere or Caterpillar. If the story that lifted them cools, they fall alone.

The other piece is simple math on new money. After a year-to-date advance of this size in both names, the reward-to-risk on a fresh position in Deere or Caterpillar shares looks less attractive than it did in January, and today’s entry price already assumes a lot of the good news. Paying up at these levels leans harder on execution than it did earlier in the year.

Position sizing matters more than the directional call here. Investors sitting on full Deere or Caterpillar weightings after this run may want to check for whether their exposure has drifted well past their target and trim back toward it rather than exit outright (we wrote a free handbook on riding a big move and planning the exit, here). That preserves the original thesis without letting a single-name gain balloon into a single-name risk.

Case for Holding On

Neither stock has started giving the gain back, and that matters. Caterpillar stock is adding to the year’s advance again on Friday, and Deere stock is holding its ground rather than fading. Momentum that keeps grinding higher while the sector lags is unusual and typically reflects idiosyncratic strength that the broader group hasn’t fully priced.

For holders of Deere or Caterpillar shares, a major takeaway is that both names keep getting re-rated on their own merits, not as sector proxies. That’s the kind of setup where cutting winners early tends to cost more than staying with them, and neither name has flashed a real sell signal yet.

Momentum in these two names also tends to compound. Once Deere and Caterpillar shares have set up as year-to-date winners, benchmarked money often adds to what’s already working, and that flow can widen the gap before it narrows. Holders who trim purely on the size of the move can leave a lot of that late-cycle push behind.

What to Watch Next

The next real tell is whether Deere and Caterpillar shares can defend their leads if the industrials fund starts to catch up, since a rotation that lifts the XLI ETF without lifting the two leaders would be the first crack in the story. Buyers can watch for signs that Paccar stock begins closing the gap, which would signal the move is broadening rather than narrowing across the group.

Until then, the narrow-leadership question is the whole story for Deere and Caterpillar shares, and Friday’s price action isn’t fighting it. The choice between taking profits and holding on comes down to whether a reader treats that narrowness as a warning or a feature, and the answer decides how they size their positions from here.

Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.